Vantec Stealth fans - not that great

jrichrds

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,537
3
81
I bought online a pair of Vantech Stealth 60mm and 80mm fans, and tried them out today.

Overview: They're double ball bearing like many other quality fans, and made by Nidec, who also makes CPU fans for Intel. Basically, they're your typical fan, set to run at a lower speed, in nice packaging, and with the price jacked up 100% or more. I see nothing special in the design, and they actually look rougher in quality than all the other fans I own.

Performance: The 60mm version, at a pathetic 12cfm max output, is probably unsuitable as a CPU fan in most situations. I got it because I wanted some air blowing at my heatsink with as little noise as possible. With what I do on this particular computer, the CPU is mostly idling and the heatsink remains cold to the touch most of the time. The 80mm version is much better at 27cfm, but seems much louder than the 21dBA rating would indicate.

Noise: These fans have a noticeable whine/tone/sharpness (whatever you want to call it) to them. I have seen other people mention this, and I can now confirm it. It's more annoying to me than the noise created by modestly higher CFM fans that I have. Which seems to defeat the purpose of getting the Stealths in the first place.

A couple days before the Stealth fans arrived, I figured out I could control the RPM of my fans simply through my motherboard's on-board sensor. And when my Stealth fans arrived, what I discovered was that I could set my "noisy" high-speed fans to output MORE CFM at a LOWER noise level than the Vantec Stealth (and without the annoying noise that the Stealth emits).

With that said, I would forgo the Stealths. If you can't control fan RPM through your motherboard, try the "7 volt" mod on your current fans. Search for "7 volt" in the Cases and Cooling archived messages. Or go with the Panaflos if you can get them for cheap. The cheaper places to get them would probably be shops that sell them for a purpose other than PC modding and overclocking (where you get the crazy markups). In reality, any high quality fan set to run at a lower speed (either through some RPM control mechanism or preset like in some NMB models) would probably be better or at least equivalent to the Stealths. So I don't see a point of paying a premium for these Vantec Stealths. I know I just wasted $20.
 

SaveYourself

Member
May 6, 2002
91
0
0
I run 4 Steath fans in my SX1030B case and they do indeed produce a whine. However, I resent the remark that the fans are of poor quality. The rougher-quality looks of the fans come from a glass-fibre reinforced plastic that they are made out of. The motors run quite smoothly. One fan really doesn't bother me. The 4 fans all at the same time produce whines of slightly different pitch, creating a dissonance that is nasty to my ears, but bearable. If you buy the Stealths, buy them because they are quality-construction, double-ball, and have a lifetime warranty. Otherwise, get Vantec ThermoFlows, which are thermally-controlled. I actually think the Volcano 9's fan has more imperfections than the Stealths do. The motor tends to have a little scuff in it (which has mostly worn away by now) and its motor also gets very hot during its operation. Even the back of the motor (actually on the impeller) becomes warm, the heat is so high. The Stealths were quiet from the day I installed them. I have a 44CFM NMB and it is louder than all 4 Stealths running together.
 

jrichrds

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,537
3
81
If you have RPM monitoring on your Stealth fans, what RPM are you getting when they are at full speed?

The 60mm is rated at 2600rpm and the 80mm is rated at 2050rpm. But I only get 2220rpm from the 60mm and 1834rpm from the 80mm. The RPMs on my other fans are reported correctly, so I'm not so sure it's just an issue with the sensor. On the 80mm Vantech, the whine goes away if I set it to run at 1400rpm.

The main problem I have with the Vantec Stealths is that they're made specifically for quietness, yet they perform worse and are louder than "normal" fans I have with which I have lowered the RPM. Not to mention that they typically cost a lot more.
 

OulOat

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2002
5,769
0
0
How long did you have your V9? I think mine is making more noise now, and it's about a month old