Using $1k to pay off student loan or pay down cc - which has better effect credit wise?

PeeluckyDuckee

Diamond Member
Feb 21, 2001
4,464
0
0
My credit at the moment is rated at CC, as I was told by my bank. They use a system from A to E, A being worst.

I have a couple loans, two credit cards, and a credit line.

There was a part time loan that took me 4yrs to pay off. The loan amount was only around $2500, so it must've looked bad on the books for me to drag it on for so long. But then, I was only a student doing minimum wage @ McDicks.

The other two current loans are $10,000 and $1k each.
One cc has been with me for 5yrs, with a balance of around $5k.
Another retail cc I have is $300, which I plan on paying it off soon and closing it out.

Now the question is, would it be better for me to use the $1k to pay down the cc or use it to pay off the $1k loan? The cc that's been with me for 5yrs has been gradually sliding upwards over the years, and its about time I take control of it.

If I pay off the $1k loan now, that means the $25 that I use each month to pay that loan can now go towards the $5k cc as well. Interest on the $1k loan is prime plus 2.5%.

I plan on moving the $5k cc to my new credit line, since it's 10.50% vs 5.5%.

One last question while I'm at it. Would I get dinged tax wise if I moved my daily savings RRSP into an investment account? Technically, I'm not withdrawing the money, right? So they can't treat that as "other income" on my year end income tax report?



 

her209

No Lifer
Oct 11, 2000
56,336
11
0
I would pay off CC since it is more likely to have a higher interest
 

Hossenfeffer

Diamond Member
Jul 16, 2000
7,462
1
0
Yep, pay down the CC. you'll have much lower interest rates and more leniency on the student loan.

The general rule I follow (read: wish I had enough money to follow), is pay off the highest interest first.

Pay off the retail CC first (likely 19-21%) then work on the CC. If you can transfer that 5K to a lower rate, Great!
 

cyclistca

Platinum Member
Dec 5, 2000
2,885
11
81
One last question while I'm at it. Would I get dinged tax wise if I moved my daily savings RRSP into an investment account? Technically, I'm not withdrawing the money, right? So they can't treat that as "other income" on my year end income tax report?

If you move any sort of RRSP item into any sort of non RRSP item then this item will not be sheltered and you will have to pay tax on it. If your moving the money you are withdrawing it. Even if you don't fisically have it in you hot little hands.

Thank God I only have debt of a few 100 dollars on my cedit card. Of course I'll be changing that in a few month when I get a brand new baby mortgage. :D
 

Tsaico

Platinum Member
Oct 21, 2000
2,669
0
0
Originally posted by: cyclistca
One last question while I'm at it. Would I get dinged tax wise if I moved my daily savings RRSP into an investment account? Technically, I'm not withdrawing the money, right? So they can't treat that as "other income" on my year end income tax report?

If you move any sort of RRSP item into any sort of non RRSP item then this item will not be sheltered and you will have to pay tax on it. If your moving the money you are withdrawing it. Even if you don't fisically have it in you hot little hands.

Thank God I only have debt of a few 100 dollars on my cedit card. Of course I'll be changing that in a few month when I get a brand new baby mortgage. :D

I agree. Also if your loans are student loans like government subsidized, then they also do not factor into your credit rating and should not count for any loan descisions any bank decides. What does factor in are your income from last w-2 and current amount owed. So if your last year w-2 is for $10k and your total debt is 10k, you should end up with an D. Or an overall good rating. (This is also assuming that you do not have any defaults/bankrupcies/leans on your record) Which I also thinks sucks, since your debt is current and your income is last years'