US 'blocking Arab freedom report'

BBond

Diamond Member
Oct 3, 2004
8,363
0
0
US 'blocking Arab freedom report'

The editor of a UN survey of freedom and governance in Arab societies says the US has impeded its publication.

Nader Fergani said the US objected to sections of the document on Iraq and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

He said it had been threatening to cut its contribution to the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).

A US spokesman denied that his country had asked for a postponement of publication. The UNDP said reports of threats to its funding were inaccurate.

But Mr Fergani - who also says the Egyptians have objected to the report's assessment of political freedom in Egypt - believes the report will not come out under the UNDP logo.

The Arab scholars who prepared it are meeting in Beirut next week to discuss publishing it under their own names.

"My understanding is that the UNDP will not publish it under its logo, but they will not prevent it from being published under the names of the authors," said Mr Fergani.

"It seems that the pressure that was put on the UNDP was too heavy to bear."

Frank and comprehensive

The BBC's Heba Saleh in Cairo says this year's report is the third in a much-acclaimed series of studies commissioned by the UNDP.

The reports, she says, are the work of dozens of independent Arab scholars who dissected their own societies to present a frank and comprehensive picture of their weaknesses and failings.

US state department spokesman Tom Casey said: "We have not seen a draft of the forthcoming Arab Human Development report. We have not urged deferral or postponement of the report, as has been alleged."

A UNDP statement said the report was in the "final stages of preparation".

It went on: "While at different times, concerns have been raised by some governments about the content of the forthcoming report, no formal discussions on editorial content have taken place, no government has asked for their suppression."

Press reports that Washington had threatened to cut future funding for UNDP over the report "are inaccurate," it added.

 

Genx87

Lifer
Apr 8, 2002
41,091
513
126
Your title says the US is going to block funding. Then supply us with an article refuting your own claim.

This is like taking candy from a child.

 

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
The OP is just parroting the title of the article. Happens a lot nowdays; slanting the title to potray bad news that is not always there. Warm fuzzys do not get celebrity status.

The article has such a title for shock value.

Just like some of the other news articles that are posted.
The title is to get attention; it does not always reflect what is inside.

Two half truths end up with questionable info, but by tht time it is to late for the sheep.
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,881
6,420
126
It seems Mr Ferangi(whoever he is) seems to suspect the US, though he seems to suspect the Egyptians as well. Whether the US is part of it or not is certainly not established though. In that light, the article Title is accurate, though somewhat sensationalist, but it was based on the words of Mr Ferangi.

Time will tell who is behind this.
 

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
Originally posted by: sandorski
It seems Mr Ferangi(whoever he is) seems to suspect the US, though he seems to suspect the Egyptians as well. Whether the US is part of it or not is certainly not established though. In that light, the article Title is accurate, though somewhat sensationalist, but it was based on the words of Mr Ferangi.

Time will tell who is behind this.

Bolded phrases are the key w/ respect to sandorski statement above and the article quotes from Below

Also
A UNDP statement said the report was in the "final stages of preparation".

It went on: "While at different times, concerns have been raised by some governments about the content of the forthcoming report, no formal discussions on editorial content have taken place, no government has asked for their suppression."

Press reports that Washington had threatened to cut future funding for UNDP over the report "are inaccurate," it added.