• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Update: Suggestions for the best daily commuter/Mom-mobile

glenn1

Lifer
Update: Wife and I have gone and looked at some other dealers. She seems extremely partial to the 5-door hatchback style cars. In particular, she seems exceptionally fond of the Honda Fit and Toyota Matrix, and she has chosen to narrow down the search to between these two. For the Fit, the flip-up style rear seats seem to particularly intrigue her and be a huge plus, and she feels the car is more "fun." The Matrix, in her words, is a more "polished" car, and seems to have slightly better construction and a more "premium" feel to it.

With the above being said, would like to solicit any additional input we can. Anyone who owns either car and can speak of their experience would be appreciated, as well as anyone who has owned both makes and can compare them in terms of maintainence/upkeep, overall owner experience, etc.

Will include pollage as well, but comments are particularly welcome.


Original post:

My wife and I are looking for a new(er) car. I have a '94 Acura Integra, and she a 1995 BMW 318i. The Integra just flipped 200k miles and we're anticipating its eventual demise. With that in mind, we'd like to narrow down the scope. Usage would likely be 60-70% commuter car (approx 20-30 minutes each way), 20-30% kid transportation, and 10% light-medium hauling (bags of mulch for the garden, etc).

Neither one of us think of our cars much beyond utilitarian concerns. Performance is utterly a secondary concern, would probably prefer a 4-cyl. for fuel economy, and we can drive a stick shift. While cost is not an issue (within reason), if I needed to spend more I'd prefer to do so to get a car or features which will allow me to keep the car for a long time (10 years plus).
 
get a used 7th gen accord (2003-2007). the 4 cyl 7th gen accords don't need timing belt replacement ever, insurance is low and it gets good gas milage. it can fit kids and groceries in the backseats and the trunk is spacious. there are enough creature comforts to make the car comfy to last a good 10 + years.
 
honda fit: inexpensive, reliable and practical. okay for transporting 4 people short distances, and lots of interior room for minimal exterior size. The accord is more comfortable, but the fit is way better for light-medium duty hauling.
 
Sub-compact: Honda Fit
Compact: Honda Civic
Mid-size: Honda Accord
Small SUV: Toyota RAV4
AWD: Subaru Legacy GT
Entry-Lux Mid-Size: Infiniti G37
Lux Mid-Size: BMW 535i
Hybrid: Toyota Prius

That should cover quite a bit. Then again, those are my personal preferences.
 
I think the best candidate would be a Honda Civic because of the low operating cost, good fun to drive, good handling, great gas mileage. The other contenders are the Accord, Altima and Camry, but they will have higher operating costs and will be less fuel efficient.

I am waiting for the next-gen Honda Fit. It looks great and will be also very economical to own and operate.

Link:
http://www.edmunds.com/insidel...ves/articleId=122688#2
 
Kid hauling, light transporting, am I the only person that immediately thought van?

How would you feel with a Toyota Sienna or Honda Odyssey?

If those are too big how about a Mazda 5? It's the same platform and engine as the Mazda 3 hatch, but slightly bigger.
 
Actually I have a van , have 2 kids but you go to grandma's for Xmas, full
Go to the farm for the wkend throw in a couple bikes, full
Go get sheet of glass to cover dining room table, full
Camping, full
Haul some of the hockey team around, full
and on and on and on
 
Originally posted by: dud
A question that no one has yet to ask:

"What is your budget?"

For sake of argument, I'll say we'd be targeting $20,000 on the upper limit, and would probably be happy to spend less if we could. We could afford more and I'm not opposed to spending more (if for the right car), but I know how easy it is to spend more if you don't set some kind of limit for yourself.

Originally posted by: KelvrickYep, that and would you be fine with FWD, or do you want awd.

Probably wouldn't even be able to tell the difference, so unless there's an extremely compelling reason to choose otherwise, would probably take FWD (which I presume is cheaper also).


Originally posted by: raildogg
I think the best candidate would be a Honda Civic because of the low operating cost, good fun to drive, good handling, great gas mileage. The other contenders are the Accord, Altima and Camry, but they will have higher operating costs and will be less fuel efficient.

I am waiting for the next-gen Honda Fit. It looks great and will be also very economical to own and operate.

I've driven a Honda Civic before and that was one I did think of, but I'm trying to avoid having a bias towards (or against) any particular makes. So far we've looked at Hyundais and weren't particularly impressed, and Toyota (the Matrix and Prius made strong impressions). Will continue to look at other dealers as time goes along and appreciate any/all suggestions both current and future 🙂
 

I'm thinking that both your cars are pretty similar; maybe you'd be better off with one smaller car (like a Civic or Prius) that's the first option for commuting, etc. for fuel economy and a second car/SUV for kid and mulch hauling (like a Forester or RAV4) that still is a decent commuter.

 
Your wife might like the Vibe.
Pontiac just re-designed it for 2009. It's based on the Corolla and twin to the Toyota Matrix. Four doors+ hatchback+ good fuel economy+ cheaper than $20K new all seem to meet your needs. Get the GT if you want sportier handling.
 
Update: Wife and I have gone and looked at some other dealers. She seems extremely partial to the 5-door hatchback style cars. In particular, she seems exceptionally fond of the Honda Fit and Toyota Matrix, and she has chosen to narrow down the search to between these two. For the Fit, the flip-up style rear seats seem to particularly intrigue her and be a huge plus, and she feels the car is more "fun." The Matrix, in her words, is a more "polished" car, and seems to have slightly better construction and a more "premium" feel to it.

With the above being said, would like to solicit any additional input we can. Anyone who owns either car and can speak of their experience would be appreciated, as well as anyone who has owned both makes and can compare them in terms of maintainence/upkeep, overall owner experience, etc.

Will include pollage as well, but comments are particularly welcome.
 
Originally posted by: Fmr12B
Have you looked at the Mazda 5?

It's worth the drive as its extremely spacious but compact.

I suggested that vehicle also, but wife vetoed.

Car shopping when you're married is completely different than when you're single, and you can throw logic and common sense out the window. In the end, it comes down to "if Momma ain't happy, ain't no one happy."
 
Originally posted by: glenn1
Originally posted by: Fmr12B
Have you looked at the Mazda 5?

It's worth the drive as its extremely spacious but compact.

I suggested that vehicle also, but wife vetoed.

Car shopping when you're married is completely different than when you're single, and you can throw logic and common sense out the window. In the end, it comes down to "if Momma ain't happy, ain't no one happy."

Saw the new matrix on the freeway today. Looks pretty good in my eyes. Too lazy to research, what are the mpg/price differences?
 
Originally posted by: Kelvrick
Originally posted by: glenn1
Originally posted by: Fmr12B
Have you looked at the Mazda 5?

It's worth the drive as its extremely spacious but compact.

I suggested that vehicle also, but wife vetoed.

Car shopping when you're married is completely different than when you're single, and you can throw logic and common sense out the window. In the end, it comes down to "if Momma ain't happy, ain't no one happy."

Saw the new matrix on the freeway today. Looks pretty good in my eyes. Too lazy to research, what are the mpg/price differences?

Fit: 27/34 (auto) or 28/34 (stick)

Matrix: 25/31 (auto) or 26/32 (stick)
 
The Fit will get better mileage than the Matrix and will be better at handling and more fun to drive. Buy the one which you like to drive the most as both are good cars.
 
Originally posted by: raildogg
The Fit will get better mileage than the Matrix and will be better at handling and more fun to drive. Buy the one which you like to drive the most as both are good cars.

I test drove the new Matrix and thought it was sort of stiff and boring to drive. I didn't think it felt "premium" but to each his/her own. But the two are sort of in a different class, no? Subcompact vs. compact? What about the Mazda3 hatch that so many people on AT like?

I voted for the Fit as well, it'll give you slightly better gas and being more fun to drive is important down the road.
FYI though, a 2009 model (slightly bigger and slightly more hp) is coming out sooner or later:
http://automobiles.honda.com/2009-fit/
Edmund's First Drive
So, either you can wait for that or get a 2008 for cheaper.
 
Back
Top