Upcoming mortgage. Overwhelmed with so many banks. How to best consolidate?

manlymatt83

Lifer
Oct 14, 2005
10,051
44
91
Over the years, I’ve formed “relationships” with banks for various reasons.

When I first started my business over 15 years ago, I had a Business Checking account and credit card with Chase. But then I had incentives to move to First Republic, and they opened a personal checking account for me with a perpetual fee waiver. First republic was pretty awesome because they refunded all ATM fees and had great customer service.

But then I moved my investments to Schwab and opened their checking account which also included worldwide ATM fee refunds and a benefit of having everything in one place. Separately, I opened an account with Alliant Credit Union to get 2.5% cashback on their visa signature card.

About a year ago, I began using Chase self-directed brokerage for their auto investment into Vanguard mutual funds for free. I save so much more when I can setup autopilot which Schwab didn’t have at the time. I also use their credit cards. I also had to move my business account back to Chase last year.

Because of all that, I have been wanting to close everything else (first republic, Alliant, Schwab, etc) and just have banking in one place to keep things simple. I am planning on applying for a mortgage next year and intend to use a mortgage broker.

However, a friend of mine told me, especially with the waived fees on the First Republic account and the fact that Alliant is a credit union, I might want to keep all the other accounts open if I am about to apply for a mortgage. Because apparently sometimes banks will give you mortgage discounts for long term relationships.

Everything I have read seems to say the opposite. That if you don’t have a relationship with the bank and you apply for a mortgage, they might be willing to give you a discount if you agree to MOVE to that bank.

Given that I will be applying for a mortgage next year and don’t really have any experience in that arena, does it really matter if I keep these accounts open? Will that really change the rate a lot? Or can I just consolidate to Chase now and figure all that out later if I’m incentivized to move assets? And will I really regret closing an account - I can’t imagine a bank saying “well we would have beat that rate by 25 points but you left us last year”.

Appreciate any insight from those who have been through the home buying process.
 

deadlyapp

Diamond Member
Apr 25, 2004
6,651
732
126
You'll probably find with a mortgage that most of the bigger names may have some good "bonuses" but the rates are pretty trash. I wouldn't worry about which bank you want to consolidate to because you probably won't end up with them on your mortgage anyways.

Personally I've preferred to split my money over numerous accounts. Some of them I've opened for bonuses over the years, some I got preferable rates on loans and maintain an account to make it easy to pay those loans.

I guess it takes a certain type of person to maintain that number of accounts vs simplifying to a single account, but I'm also the type to manufacture spend for CC bonuses and rotate through, so take that how you will
 
  • Like
Reactions: manlymatt83

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
61,290
16,794
136
I had 4 of them vying for my loan and made sure they all knew I was shopping around. This won't be an option for everyone, but I went with NBKC because they waived the 1% origination fee on my VA loan, nobody else (including Veterans United) was able to offer that, and they all had the same interest rate. It's being serviced by Dovenmuehle now, of course, but I expected that and thus far having my mortgage passed on to another company hasn't affected me with my prior home purchases. My main account is with Navy Federal, but they were just moving way too slowly for the market out here with the way things were going, and didn't really offer anything better than the others could give me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: manlymatt83