I've got no idea how the agp-performance is compared to a i-840 based motherboard. I bought this board because I didn't trust the 840/sdram-combo (which indeed turned out to be a disaster) and a 840/rdram-combo was way too expensive.
Anyway, there were a couple of initial problems with the motherboard since it shipped with a preliminary bios. A first non-beta bios was put up on the Tyan-site some weeks ago and most problems have vanished. (some people (incl. myself) had problems with system-freezes running Win2K, on WinNT4 there were no such problems...)
The only thing that still causes occasional systemfreezes/programcrashes is videocard-related. I suspect it's a driver-thingie: I run an Elsa Gloria II in the AGP-bus. When using the Elsa drivers, the whole thing freezed like 10 times a day. The system became more stable when nVidia's 6.18 (detonator 3) reference drivers became available. Since then I've upgraded the bios, but I've had no time to test the Elsa-drivers with the new bios yet. (I'm planning on testing these again within a few weeks, I have some production-deadlines now that I can't afford to miss).
The only real trouble with the nVidia-drivers is their very poor OpenGL-performance in 3D-applications (I'm not talking games here...). The good old Heidi-driver performs more stable than the OpenGL-driver....
Anyway, it's a great board (it's used in the Intergraph ZX10 Server and that's one mean machine ;-) )and when I have some time, I'll run a few benchmarks on it. As for now: if you don't need it immediately, I advise to wait a bit: it will become cheaper (don't expect it to drop to 200 US$ though...) and a few more bios-upgrades are expected.
As for the rest of the system: this is my current configuration:
OS: Win2Kpro
Fongkai FK320 extended ATX-case with 2 120mm coolers (black case, since beige sucks)
Tyan Thunder 2500
2* 256 MB 133 Registered SDRAM
2* PIII 800 Mhz 133 FSB
2* Maxtor DiamondMax40 Plus (40 Gb each, 7200 rpm)
Elsa Gloria II AGP + Iiyama Pro 510 22"
Guillemot TNT2 M64 32mb PCI + Relisys 19"
Kenwood TrueX 72 cdrom
Plextor 12-10-32 cdrw
SB Live + 720Watt Philips speakers+subwoofer
HP Deskjet 1220 A3 printer
Agfa Duoscan T1200
Wacom Intuos A4 tablet
Logitech Wireless Mouse + Keyboard (really nice: I can control my pc from a distance of 8 meters...)