Originally posted by: DV8
Originally posted by: monkied
To break things down a bit, I rank the different solutions in this order:
1) separate video card and separate tuner card with hardware encoding/decoding
2) all in one solution with hardware encoding/decoding
3) separate video card and separate tuner card with software encoding/decoding
which is the best solution??
im assuming #1 because of the dedicated tuner and hardware encoding << am i correct? what are some of the names of these cards?
im in the market for a TV tuner aswell so keep this thread going
Hauppauge's PVR 250 and 350 have hardware encoding; the 350 does hardware decoding as well, but ONLY for its TV output. For some reason, they opted not to have the hardware decoding active for the display on the computer monitor.
The drivers....they're alright. They have improved a good bit. There were lots of problems with their first PVR card, the PVR-PCI. It did hardware encoding, but it showed the TV signal live; the new cards have a slight delay, as they encode and decode the stream before you see it.
The PVR-PCI would not install right, would display corrupted video, give audio/video sync problems, display nothing at all, or work absolutely perfectly. Hauppauge just gave up on it at some point and put their R&D money into their newer 150, 250, and 350 cards - and now they've got the PVR 500, a dual-tuner card.
At any rate, the Hauppauge cards are tough to beat; the hardware encoding is really nice, as you'd need a really fast PC to encode full-resolution MPEG2 in realtime. My PVR-350 does a fine job.
Oh, I mentioned the TV output briefly - its quality is excellent. Videocards' TV output usually introduces some distortion, but this thing does a fine job - no black borders around the screen, no interpolation artifacts, nothing; it's like running a cable right from the hard drive platters to the TV's phosphors.....or at least close. The TV output is picky about its format though - you must use Hauppauge's WinTV2K application to output through the PVR's video-out, and you need to use only MPEG2 files, with MPEG audio. No Divx files, no AC3 audio. You'll need a transcoder to make such files pure MPEG.