Turning the wheel while stationary

[Skurge]

I heard that if you turn the wheel while the car is stationary, you might damage the transmission in FWD cars.

Not that I do this, I can turn the wheel pretty fast while moving, I just wanted to know if its another one of those car myths or if its a real concern as soon people, especially women do it a lot.

 

[simonizor]

I really doubt that there is any truth to that what-so-ever. How would people back out of parking spaces if their transmissions were going to go out when they turn their tires while stationary? If there is any truth, you would probably have to sit there and turn it back and forth for a very long time, and your power steering would probably go out long before the transmission.

 

[exdeath]

Myth.

 

[desy]

You can damage your power steering if you go all the way over and hear the pump strain and hold without easing off a bit

 

[exdeath]

The closest related real problem is towing an AWD car with half the wheels still on the ground with the center differential locked and burning up the clutches.

 

[Skurge]

You can damage your power steering if you go all the way over and hear the pump strain and hold without easing off a bit

Is it pretty easy to damage the power steering by doing that or does it take repeated abuse over a long period of time?

 

[desy]

Not very easy, just more wear and tear on the pump than needs be which eventually leads to failure. .

 

[Christobevii3]

If you don't have power steering and can man child it then you can mess up the steering column on a car that used to have power steering.

 

[sdifox]

I heard that if you turn the wheel while the car is stationary, you might damage the transmission in FWD cars.

Not that I do this, I can turn the wheel pretty fast while moving, I just wanted to know if its another one of those car myths or if its a real concern as soon people, especially women do it a lot.

If your car is stationary, how is the tranny being hurt? You could argue you are hurting your tires or maybe (remotely) rack and pinion, but tranny?

 

[shabby]

If your car is stationary, how is the tranny being hurt? You could argue you are hurting your tires or maybe (remotely) rack and pinion, but tranny?

Well the tranny is connected to the front wheels, and the wheels are connected to the steering wheel, it only makes sense...

 

[ShawnD1]

Is it pretty easy to damage the power steering by doing that or does it take repeated abuse over a long period of time?

Parents RV makes that weird noise when steering and it still works after ~30 years

 

[exdeath]

Well the tranny is connected to the front wheels, and the wheels are connected to the steering wheel, it only makes sense...

That's like saying your arm and leg are connected via the same skeleton, so if you break your arm, it will damage your leg.

 

[shabby]

That's like saying your arm and leg are connected via the same skeleton, so if you break your arm, it will damage your leg.

I agree its possible...

 

[Bartman39]

I agree its possible...

Only if you fall on the broken arm and stick it up your arse...:thumbsup: (might get a leg in the process...?)


The sound your hearing is just the relief valve in the pump doing its job which is designed to do millions of times during the life of the pump... Run it out of fluid one time and see what happens (more likely to fail)...

 

[skyking]

It's a crappy habit for a couple of reasons:
1)hard on the steering gear.
2) scrubs the tires.
3) this is my pet peeve, it tears up what you are driving on.

Go ahead and scoff but I have seen cars dig into soft asphalt on a hot day doing just that. I run equipment and supervise, and guys will get a piece of my mind if they do it with a backhoe or dump truck on my site.
It is much cooler and suave~ to start to roll, and then roll in your turns.
Folks who used to have manual steering may have that habit already.

 

[JulesMaximus]

I heard that if you turn the wheel while the car is stationary, you might damage the transmission in FWD cars.

Dumbest fucking thing I've ever heard. Completely not true.

What moron told you this anyway?

 

[exdeath]

Dumbest fucking thing I've ever heard. Completely not true.

What moron told you this anyway?

We know who, he's not on this forum anymore. :awe:

It's probably a long winded out friend of a friend of a friend told friend of a friend of a friend of an experience burning a differential (eg: often a transmission component in many cars) from being towed improperly from the front or rear wheels in gear, and as it got passed down it turned into this.

 

[JulesMaximus]

We know who, he's not on this forum anymore. :awe:

It's probably a long winded out friend of a friend of a friend told friend of a friend of a friend of an experience burning a differential (eg: often a transmission component in many cars) from being towed improperly from the front or rear wheels in gear, and as it got passed down it turned into this.

Inflate to sidewall? :awe:

 

[MrWizzard]

You can damage your power steering if you go all the way over and hear the pump strain and hold without easing off a bit

Not damage just more wear and tear. Just like burning out shortens the life of your tires, or improper shifting wears out your clutch faster. It's a wear and tear part. That being said I have seen lots of people abuse their power steering and never had that part of their car fail. Most people don't keep their cars long enough to even worry about this.