I'm a bit wary of other people's opinions on restaurants after having recommendations turn out to be bleh. We went out to a local restaurant called the Laguna Grille for Valentine's after seeing numerous good reviews on a local website for restaurants. The food was expensive, mediocre at best, and the service was deserving of a 5% tip - it wasn't even all that busy. And people said they go there 3 times a week for dinners. Another recommendation was given to us for the best Mexican restaurant around here... we waited 25 minutes for our food, which also wasn't as good as expected. They charged $6 for a little side dip of guacamole too. Yet another recommendation was a local Italian restaurant... good service, terrible food... I've never swallowed so much oil in pasta in my life.
I think some people have low expectations. If those are the best restaurants around, I'm deeply saddened. I've had better tasting food at Red Lobster or Olive Garden.
I like to stick to the chains because they are at least consistent. Local restaurants, despite being known as the best, are entirely a crapshoot.