I don't think I was whining in the other thread when I said I wasn't going to buy it, but after I posted, I thought maybe I should have said more to explain.
I also love AT - and I'm not anything close to a computer expert, so my contributions and benefits are very limited. I really like a lot of people I've "met" here and have fun reading posts and learning stuff now and then. I joined AT's SETI team and run it every day, even though I don't produce many work units, because I do like this place and a lot of people here and I try to do what I can when I can to show it.
I won't pay to subscribe though, but it's a personal choice that isn't about whether or not it "should" be free. I know it's expensive to run this place and the forums are a drain - I certainly don't blame Anand for making the decision to offer additional benefits for a small fee. He'd be a dumb businessperson if he kept this venture as it lost money. So he's striking a balance between paying subscribers and members who have access to most things that are free.
I don't conduct business here, I don't sell or trade things, I'm not building my own computer right now and when I go into the Highly Technical forum, my ears bleed. I'm also on a highly limited income as a mostly single parent, I'm thinking about starting a home-based business because it looks like my health is going to keep me at home for a while and I have a kid who'll be going to college in about 9 years. To me, $30 a year is unaffordable, although it's a teeny amount in the overall scheme of things. And because I don't contribute all that often anyway.....I guess it's okay if I can't access the forums sometimes because there's too much non-subscriber traffic.
I can't afford to pay a fee for the degree of companionship and amusement I get here, and since I don't have any professional need for the forums, I guess I'll just take my chances and stay a regular old member without the bells and whistles. And if it eventually goes to all paid subscribers, that's okay too. I understand why it'd be done.