• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

There is a sadness in the middle east

linuxboy

Elite Member
As I watch with some trepidation the unfolding events in the middle east and ponder implications for the modern world, the soldiers who serve and die come to mind. We argue here about the conflict to try and understand our own thoughts about issues of right and ownership. This is great, but sometimes in this, we forget that people on both sides die. Soldiers and young men are in the armies and their families want peace. Here is a poem of what it means to recollect the times of a child and an escalation into something unforeseen and unexpected. Maybe it will help us see this situation from a new perspective.

Just Folks by Edgar A. Guest: Grown Up

Last year he wanted building blocks,
And picture books and toys,
A saddle horse that gayly rocks,
And games for little boys.
But now he's big and all that stuff
His whim no longer suits;
He tells us that he's old enough
To ask for rubber boots.

Last year whatever Santa brought
Delighted him to own;
He never gave his wants a thought
Nor made his wishes known.
But now he says he wants a gun,
The kind that really shoots,
And I'm confronted with a son
Demanding rubber boots.

The baby that we used to know
Has somehow slipped away,
And when or where he chanced to go
Not one of us can say.
But here's a helter-skelter lad
That to me nightly scoots
And boldly wishes that he had
A pair of rubber boots.

I'll bet old Santa Claus will sigh
When down our flue he comes,
And seeks the babe that used to lie
And suck his tiny thumbs,
And finds within that little bed
A grown up boy who hoots
At building blocks, and wants instead
A pair of rubber boots.

Cheers ! 🙂
 
What does that song have to do with soldiers giving their lives for their country? The kid wants rubber boots, but em for him so he'll shut up. My standard issue boots are leather anyways, so I don't really see the connection.
 
"What does that song have to do with soldiers giving their lives for their country? The kid wants rubber boots, but em for him so he'll shut up. My standard issue boots are leather anyways, so I don't really see the connection."

Uhmmm, Raw Output, maybe I'm missing something, but the poem does seem to be about a boy turned into a grown-up who wanted to /decided to join the reserve to fight (perhaps for a cause? I don't know). I guess it is difficult for those who knew him from childhood to accept or understand it? 😱 So, how is that not related to soldiers giving their lives for their country? Do you mean because we do not know for what cause he fights or for whom he fights? 😕 😱
 
Hi rawoutput 🙂

What does that song have to do with soldiers giving their lives for their country?

I don't recall every stating the poem was about giving up life for a State or an idea as much as it is about change and what it means for a parent to see progeny take up arms.

The kid wants rubber boots, but em for him so he'll shut up. My standard issue boots are leather anyways, so I don't really see the connection.


Well, I think this was at a time when rubber boots were standard issue. The point I tried to convey is the humanity involved in what is occuring as opposed to some political issues or issues of the just exchanging their flashing messages in the sky. Debate can be productive, but one should not be quick to overlook the situation and understand it as fully as possible.

I rather like the way this idea was conveyed by Guest.

Cheers ! 🙂
 
How I understand is that he wanted something that most of us take for granted as something we have or something we can always can easily get, he didnt get it. So for some reason he turned violent and wanted a gun because he didnt get his boots.
 
i DON'T THINK SO cZAR. But then what would I know. i don't even know when my cap locks are on.

For me the pome is kind of light and painless for the tragedy it signifies. People can't imagine what it takes to turn what was meant to be a god into a monster, because it happened to each of us.

 
Moonbeam,
have you been screaming at alot of members 😉

The weird thing about poems is that in many cases people understand them totaly differently, your explination seems just as reasonable as mine.
 
No screaming Czar, just fat fingers. The poem itself, I think, is about the transformation from a stage in life where we were at pease and had gratitude for what was, what came our way. We didn't have wants and every gift was a surprise and joy. We grow up and find ourselves wanting this or that because we have find an ego has replaced the 'I am'. Boots cars girls, it's all the same, something to fill the void where we used to be.
 
Back
Top