- Jun 23, 2001
- 27,730
- 8
- 0
Originally posted by: Howard
Overbearing political message, even to somebody (like me) who's inclined the same way. Especially... ah, Faith of the Fallen, I think.
A lot of story elements he plain ripped from WoT.Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Howard
Overbearing political message, even to somebody (like me) who's inclined the same way. Especially... ah, Faith of the Fallen, I think.
Yep, very much so. A lot of the plot lost its adventurous feel after that book. It really started to get overbearing in the one just before it.
I still find them enjoyable, but I'm getting tired of some things. Like when Richard analyzes things and they point out every little obvious point like they're talking to a child. You'd think after being around him for so long some of the other characters would be able to follow his logic. I've noticed that a lot of the conversations resemble FAQs.
There's some novel ideas and he does a decent enough job keeping it entertaining but its definitely passed its prime. In my opinion it hasn't gotten as bad as the Wheel of Time, but its getting close.
Originally posted by: Andy22
I liked the Sword of Truth series of Books...but tell me when a Song of Ice and Fire gets made into a series and I will be excited.
Originally posted by: Howard
A lot of story elements he plain ripped from WoT.
I have to agree. That's why I stopped reading; all the books became revoltingly didactic. I started reading Phantom and had to stop near the beginning because Richard was being such a tool. When he put the complete verbal smackdown on probably the 3 most powerful wizards in the world -- who have just over 2000 years of combined experience with magic -- I just couldn't take it any more.Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Howard
Overbearing political message, even to somebody (like me) who's inclined the same way. Especially... ah, Faith of the Fallen, I think.
Yep, very much so. A lot of the plot lost its adventurous feel after that book. It really started to get overbearing in the one just before it.
I still find them enjoyable, but I'm getting tired of some things. Like when Richard analyzes things and they point out every little obvious point like they're talking to a child. You'd think after being around him for so long some of the other characters would be able to follow his logic. I've noticed that a lot of the conversations resemble FAQs.
There's some novel ideas and he does a decent enough job keeping it entertaining but its definitely passed its prime. In my opinion it hasn't gotten as bad as the Wheel of Time, but its getting close.
Originally posted by: Wuffsunie
I have to agree. That's why I stopped reading; all the books became revoltingly didactic. I started reading Phantom and had to stop near the beginning because Richard was being such a tool. When he put the complete verbal smackdown on probably the 3 most powerful wizards in the world -- who have just over 2000 years of combined experience with magic -- I just couldn't take it any more.
Casting will be very interesting and I look forward to seeing how it'd adapted for the screen. I still enjoy the first few books. Hopefully Goodkind himself will stay the hell out of the screenplay process and not bury it under his philosophical claptrap.
