Anything is better than what Microsoft is cooking up with Xbone. Markets abhor vacuums anyway, if Microsoft falls on their face, it's not like Sony will be the only game in town. After all, Xbox original was vibrant enough during PS2's heydey. N64 was a success even if PS1 was the overall winner. PC gaming has been GROWING over the past few years as well, as people are figuring out that it's not that expensive. One must also realize that the majority of gamers these days game on at least two platforms, there's plenty of room for players in the game.
Nobody in console history has EVER tried to do the extent of anti-consumerist BS that Microsoft is pulling with Xbone. Not once.
Paywalled F2P, locked used games, overpriced XBL, DRM disguised as 'cloud' power, 24hr online checks, etc, Xbone and Microsoft can go straight to hell.