• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

The nightmare that is Windows XP 64

Schadenfroh

Elite Member
Well, I finally got the money and bought a copy of XP32bit and downgraded to it about a week ago. I am glad to have that behind me and I will not be going back to XP64 until there is a point to it for me.

What do i do on my PC?

I play games, music, browse the internet and use various office products.

There was no point in going to xp64 for me. I should have known better, i had 2gb of ram, but i did not run any 64bit applications hardly. Like many, I bought it because i wanted to be on the cutting edge, little know i was the one that was about to be cut. So, at the launch of xp64, i purchased it.


Drivers:

I checked out my system and drivers existed for all my hardware. The nvidia nforce3 drivers were beta from nov of 2004. I thought, no big deal, nvidia makes the best drivers on the planet. Wrong! They did not install properly on my Gigabyte K8NS Ultra-939 (nforce3 ultra). The ones from Gigabyte's site worked, but the system was very flaky. What did i do? I installed nforce4 drivers on it and solved the bulk of the problems, but i did get a "windows has suffered a error, check the system log" message in the task bar every hour or so, but it did not lock up and was stabled.

The Geforce Drivers were as good as the 32bit ones for my 6800GT, so i cannot complain there.

The creative labs drivers for my audigy 2 ZS (while they have improved since the launch of xp64 and moved out of btw) caused strange sound bugs in many of my games, especially when going back and forth between games and desktop (high pitched howl sound), the latest creative labs drivers also gave me bugs in Skype that did not exist in their 32bit drivers. None of these problems existed in the 32bit version of XP that i had used before (it was not very legit, but i have since put such things behind me and bought legal copies of all my software).

TV Tuner: Drivers did not exist, plain and simple, people on the planetamd64 forums thought that they were close at hand, so i said, no biggy, they will be out soon. WRONG. They still do not exist and very few tuners if any support xp64. Having gone back to xp32, i can enjoy my $150 Hauppauge again.

Mouse: Logitech did not have drivers for xp64 and neither did windows. I was forced to use it as a 2 button mouse with no special features.

Applications:
Virtual Drive: Daemon tools for xp64 was released the day i downgraded back to xp32. But, more importantly, Alcohol 120% still does not support xp64 and i doubt it will anytime soon.

Microsoft does not think this operating system is a priority. They force you to use the 32bit version of IE when using windows update. They also say that one care will not work on xp64bit (email i got from their beta team when i signed up for the One Care beta).

64bit browsing: Java plugin for IE64 does not exist or any plug-in for that matter. You are basically forced to use a 32bit browser in xp64 if you want compatability to most sites, including many of microsofts.

Gaming: Most older games refused to run thanks to lack of 16bit code support. My civilization 2 did not work, neither did mIRC. I was surprised that MOO2 worked, however. Many newer games that i tried to play thought that i did not have DirectX 9 installed and therefore refused to install themselves. Need for Speed Most Wanted's demo was one such game, but this is probably due to the fact that is an EA Game, most odd was that NFS:U worked fine.

Antivirus: My favorite antivirus product, antivir, did not work. I was forced to use CLAMwin. Many other antivirus products lack XP64bit support as well as firewalls.

64bit applications that i used: beta build of 7-zip compression, slightly faster than the 32bit build when compressing large files.

Stability: About the same as xp32 once i got the nforce4 drivers on my nforce3 system.

Boot time: About 2 sec faster than standard xp32.

Speed: I could not tell a difference in xp32bit and xp64bit gaming performance. They were identical; the benchmarks that i ran were also near identical.

If one is going to use a system to run 64bit applications or use massive amounts of memory, then by all means use xp64. It is a solid operating system, but developer support for it is STILL lacking.

I just wanted to make all of the difficulties that i have had with it clear so people that don?t need it will not waste money on it to be, "on the bleeding edge of technology".
 
I held off installing x64 until this weekend, even though I've had the CD for months now. The wait has paid off somewhat in that most of the drivers have matured (somewhat).

My observations thus far.

Hardware:

nForce3 = The current (and very dated) 6.25b installed OK and I haven't had any problems with them running on my Epox as far as I can tell.

Creative X-FI = was very surprised at how solid this initial x64 release was. Very lean, simple console panel (vs the fancy GUI under x32), no install CD required, no sound anomalies as far as I can tell running the x64 of UT2004, Doom3, etc.. Will try the BF2 and the x64 version of FarCry tonight.

ATI X800XT PE = Although desktop and 3D works fine using the Cat 5.11 CCC (regular CP couldn't detect my monitor correctly), the Rage Theater component didn't install. I guess ATI decided to not include any x64 drivers for this piece of the card.

Logitech MX518 = What a stroke of luck of that the x64 version of Setpoint v2.47 was release this weekend as well.

ATI TV wonder VE = didn't even want to try it - retired.

Software:

Like you, I found benchmarks to be approximately the same, usually 0.5 to 1.5 fps slower. No incompatibilities with any of the misc titles I tried.

Winzip and WinRaR worked, but the (very useful) context menus were missing and made it cumbersome to use. Switched to 7Zip and that solved the problem. Was used to using Norton Corps. Ed. for my Antivirus needs, but made to the switch over to Avast! 4.61 which seems to work just as good.

I tried the x64 version of Internet Explorer, but it annoying in that it didn't support any of the MacroMedia flash plug-ins and oddly enough, I needed to be running the x32 version in order to do the Windows Update. If there's any value to using the x64 version of IE over the x32 version, someone please let me know.

Overall, the system is just as stable as the previous x32 version, however I noticed that there was one really annoying thing that it would do from time to time. Whenever shutting down, sometimes (not always), it would just hang on the the screen "Windows is shutting down", but don't actually shut down. I woke up in the middle of the night and noticed that the damn machine was still running.

Now, I don't dislike this OS, it's just that I feel a tremendous sense of being "underwhelmed" with it. Like a lot of folks here, I jumped on the bandwagon a few months ago because I wanted to be on the bleeding edge, but this has turned out to be the wasted effort that most people have said it was. Hind sight is 20/20, but if I had to do it over again, I would have never traded my old x32 serial to MS for this.

I'm going to stay with it for a little while longer, but if I encounter any more annoyances, I'll probably switch back also. I'm not sure if my old serial # for my x32 will still work, but I still have another unregistered OEM copy in the wings if I need it.
 
Originally posted by: Brian48
I held off installing x64 until this weekend, even though I've had the CD for months now. The wait has paid off somewhat in that most of the drivers have matured (somewhat).

My observations thus far.

Hardware:

nForce3 = The current (and very dated) 6.25b installed OK and I haven't had any problems with them running on my Epox as far as I can tell.

Creative X-FI = was very surprised at how solid this initial x64 release was. Very lean, simple console panel (vs the fancy GUI under x32), no install CD required, no sound anomalies as far as I can tell running the x64 of UT2004, Doom3, etc.. Will try the BF2 and the x64 version of FarCry tonight.

ATI X800XT PE = Although desktop and 3D works fine using the Cat 5.11 CCC (regular CP couldn't detect my monitor correctly), the Rage Theater component didn't install. I guess ATI decided to not include any x64 drivers for this piece of the card.

Logitech MX518 = What a stroke of luck of that the x64 version of Setpoint v2.47 was release this weekend as well.

ATI TV wonder VE = didn't even want to try it - retired.

Software:

Like you, I found benchmarks to be approximately the same, usually 0.5 to 1.5 fps slower. No incompatibilities with any of the misc titles I tried.

Winzip and WinRaR worked, but the (very useful) context menus were missing and made it cumbersome to use. Switched to 7Zip and that solved the problem. Was used to using Norton Corps. Ed. for my Antivirus needs, but made to the switch over to Avast! 4.61 which seems to work just as good.

I tried the x64 version of Internet Explorer, but it annoying in that it didn't support any of the MacroMedia flash plug-ins and oddly enough, I needed to be running the x32 version in order to do the Windows Update. If there's any value to using the x64 version of IE over the x32 version, someone please let me know.

Overall, the system is just as stable as the previous x32 version, however I noticed that there was one really annoying thing that it would do from time to time. Whenever shutting down, sometimes (not always), it would just hang on the the screen "Windows is shutting down", but don't actually shut down. I woke up in the middle of the night and noticed that the damn machine was still running.

Now, I don't dislike this OS, it's just that I feel a tremendous sense of being "underwhelmed" with it. Like a lot of folks here, I jumped on the bandwagon a few months ago because I wanted to be on the bleeding edge, but this has turned out to be the wasted effort that most people have said it was. Hind sight is 20/20, but if I had to do it over again, I would have never traded my old x32 serial to MS for this.

I'm going to stay with it for a little while longer, but if I encounter any more annoyances, I'll probably switch back also. I'm not sure if my old serial # for my x32 will still work, but I still have another unregistered OEM copy in the wings if I need it.


When you select x64 drivers from the ATI website, you also need to download the "WDM Integrated Driver". Its additional to the Display Driver/Control Panel download.

I had this little issue when I first tried x64. The x32 ATI driver installs all drivers.. and VIVO functions...
 
There's a separate download for the WDM Integrated Driver? Would you happen to have a link? I just doublechecked the site and the only two driver sets they offer for x64 is the plain CP and CCC. I didn't see anything else other than what's for the Fire line of products and IGP boards.
 
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
Originally posted by: Brian48
There's a separate download for the WDM Integrated Driver? Would you happen to have a link? I just doublechecked the site and the only two driver sets they offer for x64 is the plain CP and CCC. I didn't see anything else other than what's for the Fire line of products and IGP boards.

<a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://support.ati.com/ics/support/default.asp?deptID=894&task=knowledge&folderID=27">https://support.ati.com/ics/support/......tID=894&task=knowledge&folderID=27</a>

Yeah, that's link I originally followed. The only available download for x64 is the Cat 5.11 CP and CCC. If the x64 WDM drivers are not included in the Cat x64 driver suite, where can I find it?
 
I got WinXP 64 with my AMD Tech Tour bundle, so I just used it.

No problems with the nVidia drivers for both my Asus A8N-E nForce4 motherboard and 6600GT graphics card.

The only hardware issue I was getting was BSOD when I plugged in my ext HDD enclosure. It worked fine with the same setup in 32 bit Windows. Puzzled me forever but never solved it.

I don't use mouse drivers anyways, but the side buttons on my Logitech MX310 worked fine. I never used the MouseWare stuff anyways,

Daemon-Tools for 64 bit was just released and so far it has been flawless for me. Alcohol 120% can work (with some issues) if you copy the installed files over or go through the install process, get to the error, copy the folder, exit the installer and copy the folder back. The imaging/burning parts of the tool still work fine

Same issues with you with 64 bit IE and OneCare not being compatible.

The newer WinRARs have contextual menues.

Games, I only play WC3 and WoW and both work fine.

Would I recommend 64 bit Windows? No.
 
Back
Top