• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

The consequences of superstition -- extinction

Status
Not open for further replies.

Charles Kozierok

Elite Member
Yet another example of the irreparable harm done to the world by supersitition is the destruction of rhinoceros populations. This is getting worse because of burgeoning wealth in Vietnam, which is driving demand with offered prices in the hundreds of thousands of dollars per horn:

A rhino-head heist spree swept Europe in 2011, as thieves raided museums and auctions houses in seven countries, prompting 30 investigations by Europol, 20 of which are ongoing. Similar heists have also been on the rise in Africa, as well as in the odd American backwater town. Meanwhile, an online business thrives as well—including one dealer on Facebook who only accepts bitcoin.

What is driving this “highly organized” crime ring?

If you guessed “China,” you were wrong. The answer is Vietnam. The country’s appetite for rhino horn is so great that it now fetches up to $100,000/kg, making it worth more than its weight in gold. (Horns average around 1-3 kg each, depending on the species.)

The weird thing is that the surge in Vietnamese demand is fairly recent. Though rhino horn elixirs for fevers and liver problems were first prescribed in traditional Chinese medicine more than 1,800 years ago, by the early 1990s demand was limited. Trade bans among Asian countries instituted in the 1980s and early 1990s proved largely effective in quashing supply, with some help from poaching crackdowns in countries where rhinos live. Meanwhile, the removal of rhino horn powder from traditional Chinese pharmacopeia in the 1990s had largely doused demand. In the early 1990s, for instance, horns sold for only $250-500/kg (pdf, p.85). And only around 15 rhinos were poached in South Africa each year from 1990 to 2007.
...
What happened in 2008 to prompt a resurgence in demand? The closest guess is a rumor that swept Vietnam in the mid-2000s that imbibing rhino horn powder had cured a Vietnamese politician’s cancer. That rumor persists to this day. And note that this has nothing to do with traditional Chinese medicine. As Huijun Shen, the president of the UK Association of Traditional Chinese Medicine explained to Nature magazine, there’s no record of using rhino horn to treat cancer in nearly two millennia worth of Chinese medical texts.
...
So why are Vietnamese willing to shell out thousands for the pharmacological equivalent of chewing your fingernails? The short answer: wealth. Vietnam’s tally of multimillionaires has grown 150% in the last five years. The Convention on the International Trade on Endangered Species notes that this rising wealth is “inflating a bubble of demand for rhino horn”.

The full story is worth reading, and is heavily hyperlinked to source materials and related documents.

Beyond the generally dubious nature of "traditional" medicines, here we have a case where the benefits are not just unsupported by evidence, but entirely a modern invention. This is a noble creature driven to extinction by wealthy ignoramuses.

We're so, so "advanced" compared to our animal forebears, aren't we?
 
When I was in Africa they killed something like 30 Rhinos. They killed 9 in just one day. It's terrible. I've seen a bunch in the wild but my kids probably won't have the opportunity.

At the beginning of the 20th century there were 500,000 rhinos across Africa and Asia. In 1970 there were 70,000. Today, there are fewer than 29,000 rhinos surviving in the wild.


Between 1970 and 1992, large-scale poaching caused a dramatic 96% collapse in numbers of the critically endangered black rhino. Shockingly, 95% of the rhino population has consequently been wiped out.


The way they poach is incredibly cruel too. They go in, tranquilize the animal, saw off it's face with a chainsaw, and leave. What happens is that in the morning they wake up and the poor park rangers and anti-poaching soldiers then have to kill the animal to put it out of it's misery.
 
I'd say this stupidity couldn't happen in America, with the availability of information, but that would belie the human condition. A baseless rumor may sweep the internet and be taken as gospel.

Though the one caveat is we'd be able to produce medical studies / leading opinions to counter such a rumor. The problem is people may choose not to believe the truth. We can't help them there.

Poor Rhinos.
 
I'd say this stupidity couldn't happen in America, with the availability of information, but that would belie the human condition.

Yep, no shortage of fools who believe dangerously stupid things here either. I mean, apparently about 25% of the American public either thinks Obama is the "antichrist" or aren't sure. It's just mind-boggling.
 
We should not put all this on superstition - custom and development are major factors threatening animals.

And the profits of development are not something the US has found a way to deal with in many cases for protecting other interests, like the climate.

We do somewhat better with animals thanks to the endangered species act.
 
Last edited:
Yep, no shortage of fools who believe dangerously stupid things here either. I mean, apparently about 25% of the American public either thinks Obama is the "antichrist" or aren't sure. It's just mind-boggling.

But more on point we have all sorts of pseudoscience medicine here in the States, which despite all the medical evidence, people believe. Stuff like Homeopathic medicine, Airborne, Hypnotherapy, Naturopathy, Bioelectromagnetic-based therapies, and Reiki are all commonly believed in.
 
But more on point we have all sorts of pseudoscience medicine here in the States, which despite all the medical evidence, people believe. Stuff like Homeopathic medicine, Airborne, Hypnotherapy, Naturopathy, Bioelectromagnetic-based therapies, and Reiki are all commonly believed in.

Let's not forget the anti-vaccination stuff.

I have to say, someone I think very highly of generally, Roberty Kennedy, Jr., blew it on that issue.

He made it his cause based on insufficient information with the best of intentions, and I have not seen him correct it.

I initially supported him, then changed my position with more evidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top