Here are my comments on that list:
1) Allan Ray didn't get his eye poked out. His eyelid went behind his eyeball, to create an illusion of his eye getting poked out.
2) Napolean McCallum is not on that list? WTF.
3) Who was that backup QB (I think for the Cardinals) a few years back that fell to the ground and dislocated his pinky finger. You could see the pinky bent at a 90 degree angle at the joint.
4) Not a gruesome injury, but very bizarre. During a TD celebration after he ran in for a score, Vikings QB Gus Ferotte suddenly headbutted a wall, giving himself a concussion.