Texas school district suspends transgender teacher

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Texashiker

Lifer
Dec 18, 2010
18,811
197
106
Interchangeable phrases and/or similarities do not a psychological diagnosis make.

Not just phrase, but also actions.

Lets do multiple choice.

Phrase - "I was born in the wrong body"

Proposed solution:

A. Cut leg off so I can be an amputee.

B. Cut penis off so I can be a woman.

Which one is mentally ill?
 

alzan

Diamond Member
May 21, 2003
3,860
2
0
Not just phrase, but also actions.

Lets do multiple choice.

Phrase - "I was born in the wrong body"

Proposed solution:

A. Cut leg off so I can be an amputee.

B. Cut penis off so I can be a woman.

Which one is mentally ill?

Sorry, I do not subscribe to your simplistic black/white, either/or view of the world.
 

AyashiKaibutsu

Diamond Member
Jan 24, 2004
9,306
3
81
Was (s)he not a member of the union?

Where I substitute taught in Florida several years ago, there was no union for subs. You processed into their system and then just received offers on a daily basis for work. It was basically a temp job.
 

Texashiker

Lifer
Dec 18, 2010
18,811
197
106
Was (s)he not a member of the union?

I do not know.


Sorry, I do not subscribe to your simplistic black/white, either/or view of the world.

Our politically correct society says we have to excuse certain sexual behavior as being normal.

If that same behavior was exhibited outside of a sexual nature it would be condemned.

If tying your leg and acting like an amputee is a form of mental illness, then so is dressing up and acting like the opposite sex.
 

smackababy

Lifer
Oct 30, 2008
27,024
79
86
If you listen to what a lot of transgender people say, and then compare it to what people who have been diagnosed with other mental disorders say, the phrases are interchangeable.

This phrase for example - "Born into the wrong body."

If a transgender says it, that term is not a sign of mental illness.

But if someone with body integrity identity disorder says that exact same phrase, they are mentally ill.

Pretend to be a woman, no mental illness.

Pretend to be an amputee, mental illness.

How can we excuse one behavior as being natural, but when someone does something very similar they are mentally ill and need help.

If you listen to what a lot of anti marriage equality, it is the same / similar to those that were anti racial equality. The phrases are interchangeable.

Deny rights based on race, bigot.

Deny rights based on sexual preference, not bigot.
 

alzan

Diamond Member
May 21, 2003
3,860
2
0
I do not know.




Our politically correct society says we have to excuse certain sexual behavior as being normal.

If that same behavior was exhibited outside of a sexual nature it would be condemned.

If tying your leg and acting like an amputee is a form of mental illness, then so is dressing up and acting like the opposite sex.

Hint: "normal" is a subjective term.
 

Texashiker

Lifer
Dec 18, 2010
18,811
197
106
If you listen to what a lot of anti marriage equality, it is the same / similar to those that were anti racial equality. The phrases are interchangeable.

Deny rights based on race, bigot.

Deny rights based on sexual preference, not bigot.

You are somewhat right and I somewhat agree with you.

However, race is not a choice, sexual preference is.

Why should society accommodate a perverted lifestyle?
 
Feb 6, 2007
16,432
1
81
You are somewhat right and I somewhat agree with you.

However, race is not a choice, sexual preference is.

Why should society accommodate a perverted lifestyle?

Doctors disagree with your assertion that sexual preference is a choice, and as you have absolutely no training in neurobiology, your uneducated opinion on the matter is essentially worthless.
 

Texashiker

Lifer
Dec 18, 2010
18,811
197
106
your uneducated opinion on the matter is essentially worthless.

So is yours.

As discussed in a previous thread, Spartans lived a gay lifestyle in the military. Since most Spartans served in the military, where did baby Spartans come from?
 
Feb 6, 2007
16,432
1
81
So is yours.

Fair enough. So let's skip right past our uneducated opinions and go with what the doctors say; human sexuality is neither a binary opposition nor a conscious choice. Neither one of us has the credentials to refute the accepted medical wisdom on the subject, so we're forced to accept it.
 

Texashiker

Lifer
Dec 18, 2010
18,811
197
106
go with what the doctors say; human sexuality is neither a binary opposition nor a conscious choice.

Remind me again how many times doctors and scientific studies have been wrong?

Scientist can not even agree on global warming, but they can agree on sex?

More like they have a theory on sex. And every time the wind blows the theory will change.


I agree! We should stop accommodating the ignorance spewed by people who think a book written 2,000 years ago trumps science. .

You are not playing nice.

Please quote when I referenced religion.
 
Last edited:
Feb 6, 2007
16,432
1
81
Remind me again how many times doctors and scientific studies have been wrong?

Scientist can not even agree on global warming, but they can agree on sex?

More like they have a theory on sex. And every time the wind blows the theory will change.

Too late; we've already agreed our own opinions on the matter are worthless given our complete lack of training in any areas applicable to neuroscience. However, if you do decide to pursue an education or career in neuroscience to help solve this medical dilemma once and for all, the world could be a better place for it. Something to consider.
 

smackababy

Lifer
Oct 30, 2008
27,024
79
86
Remind me again how many times doctors and scientific studies have been wrong?

Scientist can not even agree on global warming, but they can agree on sex?

More like they have a theory on sex. And every time the wind blows the theory will change.
I think you need to reread those global warming studies. Science is in agreement that is happening, they only disagree with how much, if any, humans are increasing the speed at which it occurs.

Furthermore, nice argument "scientists are sometimes wrong, so they are always wrong".

You are not playing nice.

Please quote when I referenced religion.

I never said you did. Simply that we should stop accommodating, as a society, willful ignorance, especially such that leads to discrimination and hatred.
 

BoberFett

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
37,562
9
81
So now that we're hearing cross dressers should be a protected class, because it's not an action, it's how they were born.

As the leftists around here have become fond of saying, conservatism is a genetic defect. Does that mean that firing someone for donating to a right wing cause - something that they can't change if their genes make them conservative - makes you a bigot?

:hmm:
 

smackababy

Lifer
Oct 30, 2008
27,024
79
86
So when do we stop accommodating cross dressers?

Never. Who gets to determine what clothing is acceptable for each gender? And why is it perfectly acceptable for a women to wear men's clothing and not the other way around? If a teacher had worn Wranglers, work boots, and a t-shirt nobody would be causing a fuss, regardless of which gender she identified with. Same with if she had worn a suit.
 

Soundmanred

Lifer
Oct 26, 2006
10,780
6
81
It would be a sad life to love so full of hate and caring so much about what others do. I simply can't imagine living like that.
 

shira

Diamond Member
Jan 12, 2005
9,500
6
81
It's useless to try to educate bigots. Citing the statements of authoritative bodies is lost on these know-nothings. They lack all ability to understand nuance. To them, it is impossible that a completely sane person born with a penis can think and feel and self-identify as a woman.

But let's try:

Imagine a completely normal woman who awoke one morning to find that her female body had been replaced with a male body. Yet in every other way this person continued to experience the world as a woman. If this could actually happen, would you call this person "insane" for continuing to insist "I'm a woman"?

Or is it possible that a totally sane person can look at their body and their feelings and say, "I can see that I have a penis, a square jaw, a muscular physique, and lots of facial hair that needs to be shaved every day. I can see that in every physically-detectable way I have a man's body. But my body doesn't define my gender. In every psychological way that a person knows whether they're a man or a woman, I know that I'm a woman."

Well, this is exactly the state that transgender people find themselves in: their perception of their own gender is exactly the opposite of their biological gender. And professional bodies who assess mental illness do not list being a transgender person as a mental illness.

But of course, the right-wing know-nothings have an opinion. And because they just aren't capable of "getting" what a transgender really is, they make the gross oversimplification that it's just "cross-dressing" and insist it's a mental illness.

If all of the right-wing bigots were replaced with transgender, the world would be a lot better place.
 

schneiderguy

Lifer
Jun 26, 2006
10,765
52
91
Imagine a completely normal woman who awoke one morning to find that her female body had been replaced with a male body. Yet in every other way this person continued to experience the world as a woman. If this could actually happen, would you call this person "insane" for continuing to insist "I'm a woman"?

Interesting scenario, but that doesn't happen in real life.

Or is it possible that a totally sane person can look at their body and their feelings and say, "I can see that I have a penis, a square jaw, a muscular physique, and lots of facial hair that needs to be shaved every day. I can see that in every physically-detectable way I have a man's body. But my body doesn't define my gender. In every psychological way that a person knows whether they're a man or a woman, I know that I'm a woman."

How do they know that they're a woman? I thought gender is a social construct? :hmm:

On a related note, I discovered this morning that on the inside I am a tortoise, despite all outward appearances of me being a human. If you disagree you're a bigot and need to check your non-transtortoise privilege.
 

schneiderguy

Lifer
Jun 26, 2006
10,765
52
91
Is it acceptable for a woman to wear pants and a blazer in a professional setting?

Due to female privilege, it is acceptable for women to wear men's clothes but not vice versa.

Probably for a good reason, actually. Which one will scare the children?

Kate-Heathrow-Smythe-Blazer-4-shot-1024x457.jpg


Klug-Facebook.jpg