Taslima Nasreen removes comment...

magomago

Lifer
Sep 28, 2002
10,973
14
76
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7120473.stm

Taslima Nasreen removes comment
Taslima Nasreen
Ms Nasreen faced death threats in Bangladesh
Controversial Bangladeshi feminist writer Taslima Nasreen has said she will withdraw some "controversial" lines from one of her books.

The lines are from Dwikhondito (Split into two) which, some Muslim groups say, are derogatory to Islam.

The book was banned by the government in India's West Bengal state where a quarter of the population is Muslim.

There have been violent protests against Ms Nasreen by Muslims in West Bengal's capital, Calcutta, recently.

She has been moved from one city to another in the last few days for her own safety after these protests and is now lodged in a safe house in the capital, Delhi.

What I really don't like is simply that just because you don't agree with someone doesn't give you a right to threaten them. For all those who love to bash Muslims or Islam, this historically isn't what has happened. There were often many lively debates about religion (well atleast the Mid East, I don't know much about Bengali history). Either way - this attempting to muzzle people by Imams is CLEARLY itself creating problems. The Quran warns that the greatest threat is not people who outwardly deny ISlam - but those who are hypocrites. And the chauvanists male cultures are creating such problems.

2:8 And there are people who say "We do Believe in God and the Last Day," the while they do not really believe.
2:9 They would deceive God and those who have attained faith - the while they deceive none but themselves, and perceive it not
2:10 In their hearts is disease, and so God lets their disease increase; and grievous suffering awaits them because of their persistent lying
2:11 And when they are told, "Do not spread corruption on earth," they answer, "We are but improving things!"
2:12 Oh, verily, it is they, they who are spreading corruption - but they perceive it not!

Although this points to early Medina history when some Muslims called themselves Muslims but were really not. There is some good commentary and here it is: "As is always the case with Quranic allusions to contemporary or historaical events, the avove and the following verses have a general, timeless import inasmuch as they refer to all people who are prone to deceive themselves in order to evade a spiritual commitment"
The Indian government has pledged to continue to host and protect Ms Nasreen.

But External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee told parliament that India expected its guest to behave as one.

'Upset'

Ms Nasreen told TV channels on Friday that she would be dropping some lines from Dwikhondito, her 2003 autobiography.

She said she had not wanted to "hurt anybody's religious sentiments" while writing the book.

"Now that some people in India have said they are upset with what I have said, I have decided to drop the controversial portions of the book and have told the publisher to take necessary action," Ms Nasreen said.

I guarantee you that it has to be the Imams sitting in Mosques purposely trying to fan the flames. Anything that challanges their power - good or bad - is a threat that they must try to deal with. They hide behind the name of Islam - and if they , for any reason lose their "protection" tehn their actions come into question and their power diminished. But so as long as they can claim to represent Islam, and violently attack anything under the guise of "anti Islam" they gain a powerful shield to hide their questionable actions from scrutiny.
A car destroyed during riots in Calcutta
Protests against the author turned violent in Calcutta

"After these portions are removed, I think there will be no more scope for controversy and all the tension so far caused should die down."

Leading writers in Bengal have welcomed Ms Nasreen's move.

"It is a clever and a timely move. It is not a surrender to the fundamentalists but a compromise to tackle the present situation where Muslims across the board are feeling upset ," said Abul Bashar.

Shirshendu Mukherjee said Ms Nasreen's move should "assuage ruffled sentiments".

However, noted painter Shuvaprassana said Ms Nasreen had compromised by withdrawing the lines.

"This is a compromise that she has been forced into for the sake of getting refuge. But if she can drop two pages to get refuge in India, she can drop three pages and go back to Bangladesh," he said.

Interesting...I suppose one could say she could remove the book and then everything is fixed as well

Death threats

Critics have accused the writer of calling for the Koran to be changed to give women greater rights, something she denies.

If those critics followed what the Quran said, then they'd realize they were probably chauvanist
Ms Nasreen fled Bangladesh in the early 1990s after death threats and has spent the last three years in Calcutta after a long stay in Europe.

Last week, after the riots in Calcutta, Ms Nasreen was flown out of Calcutta in a special plane to Delhi from where she was taken to Jaipur in the western state of Rajasthan.

A day later, she was brought to Delhi where she spent a couple of nights in the Rajasthan government's guest house.

On Tuesday, she was moved again, this time to a safe house at an undisclosed location in Delhi.

Taslima Nasreen's Indian visa is valid until March 2008.

In August this year, she was giving a lecture in the southern city of Hyderabad when she was attacked by Muslims who said they had been upset by her remarks on the Prophet Muhammad and the Koran.

*sigh*
 

chucky2

Lifer
Dec 9, 1999
10,038
36
86
I just named the piece of dog sh1t across the street Mohammed, think they'd like that?

Chuck
 

Pabster

Lifer
Apr 15, 2001
16,987
1
0
Originally posted by: chucky2
I just named the piece of dog sh1t across the street Mohammed, think they'd like that?

Chuck

That's got to be worth at least 200 lashes.
 

jonks

Lifer
Feb 7, 2005
13,918
20
81
Originally posted by: chucky2
I just named the piece of dog sh1t across the street Mohammed, think they'd like that?

Chuck

Probably about as much as you would like them digging up your grandma's bones, marinating them with a mixture of soy sauce, BBQ, and paprika and feeding it to their dogs.
 

chucky2

Lifer
Dec 9, 1999
10,038
36
86
Originally posted by: sirjonk
Originally posted by: chucky2
I just named the piece of dog sh1t across the street Mohammed, think they'd like that?

Chuck

Probably about as much as you would like them digging up your grandma's bones, marinating them with a mixture of soy sauce, BBQ, and paprika and feeding it to their dogs.

Actually, you mean as them saying such a thing. In which case I wouldn't like it, but, as long as it didn't happen, WhoTF cares?

Oh well...there's the modern human race and then there's sub-human's...maybe sometime they'll evolve...

Chuck
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,466
3
76
well at least she doesn't have a teddy bear named Mohammed

lest we forget Satanic Verses by Salmon Rushdie as well

"He whosoever offends Islam shall die a million deaths" attributed to any radical cleric in any middle east country.

Woah, ohh Rushdie had a slamming wife...

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20040517/w5.jpg
 

chucky2

Lifer
Dec 9, 1999
10,038
36
86
Originally posted by: blackllotus
Originally posted by: chucky2
Oh well...there's the modern human race and then there's sub-human's...maybe sometime they'll evolve...

Please stop voting

Why? Because I don't tolerate F'ing idiots and the much shrewder extremists that use them?

As far as I can tell, the Western world is ahead of these idiots by hundreds of years. Sub-human was too strong, I'll admit that, but calling them disallusioned humans makes the situation no less serious.

I'll keep voting thanks, I like our way of life much better than the rest of the worlds...

Chuck
 

Vonkhan

Diamond Member
Feb 27, 2003
8,198
0
71
Originally posted by: chucky2
Originally posted by: sirjonk
Originally posted by: chucky2
I just named the piece of dog sh1t across the street Mohammed, think they'd like that?

Chuck

Probably about as much as you would like them digging up your grandma's bones, marinating them with a mixture of soy sauce, BBQ, and paprika and feeding it to their dogs.

Actually, you mean as them saying such a thing. In which case I wouldn't like it, but, as long as it didn't happen, WhoTF cares?

Oh well...there's the modern human race and then there's sub-human's...maybe sometime they'll evolve...

Chuck

Himmler is that you?
 

chucky2

Lifer
Dec 9, 1999
10,038
36
86
Originally posted by: Vonkhan
Originally posted by: chucky2
Originally posted by: sirjonk
Originally posted by: chucky2
I just named the piece of dog sh1t across the street Mohammed, think they'd like that?

Chuck

Probably about as much as you would like them digging up your grandma's bones, marinating them with a mixture of soy sauce, BBQ, and paprika and feeding it to their dogs.

Actually, you mean as them saying such a thing. In which case I wouldn't like it, but, as long as it didn't happen, WhoTF cares?

Oh well...there's the modern human race and then there's sub-human's...maybe sometime they'll evolve...

Chuck

Himmler is that you?

Yeah, I just said to blackllotus sub-humans was too strong...see my post above yours.

Chuck