Tale of the Yardbirds Guitarists..

Analog

Lifer
Jan 7, 2002
12,755
3
0
The Yardbirds are an English rock band, noted for starting the careers of three of rock's most famous guitarists: Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck and Jimmy Page. A blues-based band whose sound evolved into experimental pop rock, they had a string of hits including ?For Your Love?, ?Over, Under, Sideways, Down? and ?Heart Full Of Soul?. They were a crucial link between British R&B and psychedelia.

The Yardbirds were pioneers in almost every guitar innovation of the '60s: fuzz tone, feedback, distortion, improved amplification, and were one of the first to put an emphasis on complex lead guitar parts and experimentation. The term, "Yardbird" is used in the southern United States as slang for 'chicken' (as in poultry), and it is a slang expression for "prisoner".

The group's move into pop outraged lead guitarist Eric Clapton, at the time a no-holds-barred blues purist, who had already doubted the ability of "nice college kids" like bassist Paul Samwell-Smith to play the "real blues". Clapton left the group in protest.

The loss could have been devastating to the Yardbirds; Clapton had already shown the striking, stabbingly virtuosic style he would later expand and deepen with Mayall and unfurl as a full-fledged virtuoso statement with the improvisational blues rock/psychedelic Cream. Clapton recommended Jimmy Page, a studio guitarist he knew (and with whom he would soon cut a series of stirring blues guitar duets, including "Tribute to Elmore" and "Draggin' My Tail"), as his replacement, but Page?uncertain at the time about giving up his lucrative studio work and worried about his health?recommended in turn his friend Jeff Beck, whose fleet-fingered style and bent for experimentation pushed the Yardbirds to the direction from which they became widely credited for opening the door to "psychedelic" rock. Beck played his first gig with the Yardbirds only two days after Clapton's departure.
 

Platypus

Lifer
Apr 26, 2001
31,046
321
136
Beck has the most unique style and mastery of the instrument as demonstrated with his complete control over the sonics of his guitar.
Clapton invented woman tone and changed the 'sound' of electric guitar at the tiime
Page is a bit sloppy but has a good sense of phrasing and spawned a million killer riffs

It's hard to pick a favorite but for me it's definitely not clapton. I would say most likely Page for tone and Beck for mastery of the craft. Beck just never wrote anything REALLY compelling on his own, he does a good job of dressing up others' work... so in a pinch I would say Page.
 

reeserock

Member
Jan 7, 2008
191
0
0
They are all VERY skilled guitarist, but I don't go out of my way to listen to any of them. They are equally good in their own style. I vote "all of the above"
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
torn between page and clapton, picked clapton

never heard of beck before (feel free to chastise me now)
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,393
14,792
146
Each of the three is a near Guitar God in his own right...

It'd be tough to pick one as "BEST." While each MIGHT be "BEST" in one category or another, NONE are"BEST" in all categories.
I'd STILL go out of my way to hear any of them play again...The Yardbirds were GREAT in their day...as was Cream,John Mayall's Blues Breakers, the Jeff Beck Group...ah yes...nostalgia trip...:)
 

Analog

Lifer
Jan 7, 2002
12,755
3
0
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Each of the three is a near Guitar God in his own right...

It'd be tough to pick one as "BEST." While each MIGHT be "BEST" in one category or another, NONE are"BEST" in all categories.
I'd STILL go out of my way to hear any of them play again...The Yardbirds were GREAT in their day...as was Cream,John Mayall's Blues Breakers, the Jeff Beck Group...ah yes...nostalgia trip...:)

Notice I didn't say "BEST", just your favorite. :)
 

Electric Amish

Elite Member
Oct 11, 1999
23,578
1
0
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Each of the three is a near Guitar God in his own right...

It'd be tough to pick one as "BEST." While each MIGHT be "BEST" in one category or another, NONE are"BEST" in all categories.
I'd STILL go out of my way to hear any of them play again...The Yardbirds were GREAT in their day...as was Cream,John Mayall's Blues Breakers, the Jeff Beck Group...ah yes...nostalgia trip...:)

Agreed!

My favorite is Clapton.
 
Feb 16, 2005
14,080
5,453
136
Favorite has to be Page. Just too many killer riffs, stage presence, and downright nasty growls coming from his guitar (yea, I know Beck could out-growl most, but Page had/has something different.)
Saw Clapton (w/SRV), saw Page with The Firm, never saw Beck, but I know he is extremely skilled.
 

aplefka

Lifer
Feb 29, 2004
12,014
2
0
Originally posted by: Ns1
torn between page and clapton, picked clapton

Yeah that's about how it shook down for me too because overall I feel that Clapton is the second greatest guitarist of all time.
 

judasmachine

Diamond Member
Sep 15, 2002
8,515
3
81
It was once upon a time Jimmy Page, then I got older and moved to Jeff Beck, but now that I'm just old, it's Eric Clapton.
 

Legendary

Diamond Member
Jan 22, 2002
7,019
1
0
I just started getting into Yardbirds and Cream etc., have been a Zep fan for a few years.
I chose Clapton.
 

Midnight Rambler

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,200
0
0
As a long time Clapton fan I'm afraid I must say that he was simply awesome with the Bluesbreakers and Cream, but after that, well ...

So my vote definitely goes to Jeff. Page has never even been in my Top 10, as someone else mentioned, he's downright sloppy. Good thing he played bass while he and Beck both were in the Yardbirds. JB produces sounds from a guitar that are simply unimaginable for most, yet he plays exclusively fingerstyle and uses little to no "electronics", IOW, it's all down to his own talent.

In fact, I rate Jeff Beck my all-time #1 guitarist (SRV and Buddy Guy come in tied for 2nd). Funnily enough, one of the best concerts Ive ever seen was SRV and JB together on a double bill. Huge driving rainstorm throughout the whole show, but both played on undeterred. They joined forces for the encore, during which JB gave SRV an old wah wah pedal that he said belonged to Jimi Hendrix.

JB is not only an amazing player, he also spawned many "inventions" a la Les Paul. Sadly, he plays only infrequently, and tours less often. He's been a little more active the last 5-6 years though and in killer form. Amazes me the guy can not pick up an axe for months/years on end, then just turn it all back "on". But alas, JB loves his hot rods a little more than the guitar even ...
 

jjones

Lifer
Oct 9, 2001
15,424
2
0
No question for me. Jimmy Page is my favorite of the three. Beck second, Clapton comes in third. The "best" of the three, again there is no question for me. Jeff Beck.
 

TBone48

Platinum Member
Feb 23, 2005
2,431
0
0
Originally posted by: Captante
My favorite of those 3 is Jeff Beck.

+1. Page came up with some awesome riffs, but his solos always sound "sloppy" to me.
 

dawp

Lifer
Jul 2, 2005
11,347
2,710
136
Originally posted by: Analog
I never realized that Page was considered sloppy by so many.

Seeing as Wired is one of my favorite CDs, i'll have to go with Jeff Beck.