Stock Heatsink/Fan the same for single core Athlon 64 and Dual Core Opteron?

[Laztlain]

I have an Athlon 64 3200+ in my machine right now with the stock HS and Fan. I just bought a used Opteron 170 and am wondering if the HS/Fan I have is the same that would come with a retail Opty anyway?

 

[Martimus]

Originally posted by: Laztlain
I have an Athlon 64 3200+ in my machine right now with the stock HS and Fan. I just bought a used Opteron 170 and am wondering if the HS/Fan I have is the same that would come with a retail Opty anyway?

The dual cores run much hotter than the single core A64's. I would get a Freezer 64 or something cheap that cools well. I found that mine wouldn't keep my X2 cool enough to avoid thermal protection with the stock cooler, switching from a 3500+. (Although there may have been some other issues as well, I can't remember exactly.)

 

[SlowSpyder]

My single core 3000+ used an all aluminun heatsink without any heatpipes. My Opteron came with an aluminum/copper heatsink that is basically the same demensions, but has a copper plate at the base and it has with 2 copper heatpipes. I used that for a while, then found that there is a 4 heat pipe version too. I bought that from Ebay for not much money, maybe $10. I think it was what came with some of the FX chips. That is what I'm using now on my Opteron.

 

[jjmIII]

Originally posted by: SlowSpyder
I used that for a while, then found that there is a 4 heat pipe version too.

I use one too. Best OEM cooler EVER!

EDIT: link

 

[heyheybooboo]

Athlon 64 3200+ TDP = 51w
Opty 170 TDP = 110w

and those copper heatpipe coolers are gerat

 

[Martimus]

Originally posted by: jjmIII

Originally posted by: SlowSpyder
I used that for a while, then found that there is a 4 heat pipe version too.

I use one too. Best OEM cooler EVER!

EDIT: link

That is a nice cooler, but it is more expensive than the Freezer 64, which performs better. Of course it is smaller, so there is an advantage to using it. The Freezer is difficult to install, so this may be a better option if you aren't planning ot overclock just for that reason. (Frustration caused by installation may not be worth the extra 5 dollars you save.)

 

[BlueAcolyte]

That's some beefy stock cooling there...