Kind of want both... How realistic is F1 2010 (compared to, say, iracing)?
Well, I've been playing F1 2010 since it came out. F1 games are mostly made for F1 fans, but if you like F1 I'll definatelly recommend you this one! For me, the best F1 I have played! (for me, much better than GP2,GP3,GP4, rFactor,GPL,F1 2006)
You'll get what F1 is all about... making laps and consistently improve your times by 0.1s or 0.2s, trying to be regular, taking 5 or 6 laps to attempt an overtake.
I know some ppl will talk about rFactor, but as Anthony Davidson (F1 2010 team development, former F1 driver, F1 test pilot):
AD:'' Lots of people have asked me if it's rFactor, is it incredibly hard or is it like the real thing? 'Am I just going to spin in the pit garage because that's what I want because I'm so hardcore.' Well, no your not because this is such a mass market game and that doesn't happen in real-life. You wouldn't jump in the car and spin coming out of the garage''
'' For instance the Mercedes simulator back in the Brawn days, when we were in first development Rubens, Jenson and myself, we used it a lot, me more-so than them. They would come into the sim after driving a car, and be spinning around all over the place and would complain, saying 'This isn't realistic, what are we doing?''