Sabrewings
Golden Member
- Jun 27, 2015
- 1,942
- 35
- 51
I think this is just where SC fans are not going to agree - in the end, one of the groups is going to end up unhappy with the FM.
When some people think spaceship dogfights, they think Star Wars. Another group thinks Battlestar Galactica, which is much closer to what SC is at the moment.
When I think space combat, I think strafing. The MAVs should have massive thrust available to them, as thruster shunting routes energy from the powerplant where it is needed. Right now we have a sort of automatic version of this and a set ratio. In future builds we might be able to change the mains / mavs ratio to tweak the forward speed vs maneuverability of the ship.
The thing with thruster shunting is that for it to make sense rationally they are limited by their size. Assuming the mains are producing some sort of gas to be expelled which creates thrust, there is a max pressure it creates. The thrust would be limited to that pressure (which would be the same between mains and mavs) and the cross-sectional area of the opening. This puts the thrusters at an inherent disadvantage (which I'm fine with). The mains are there for a reason, and people should learn how to use them.
I'm fine with strafe existing, but it needs to have an acceleration disadvantage compared to rotating and using your mains.
This makes sense, as when you change flight modes into Cruise, you're essentially providing your mains almost all available powerplant energy to attain huge forward speed, and almost no maneuverability. You obviously can't laterally strafe at cruise speeds because the size of MAV thrusters limits how much thrust they can produce.
But that's not what we're told by the devs and in lore. Max speed is limited by how powerful your MAVs are. It's tied to how fast you can stop on your weakest axis. Want to go faster? Get strong MAVs so that you can stop faster and it will let you go faster.
I think you're right that there's going to be contention no matter what is released. IMO, I don't want to see a strafe-fest, nor do I want a boring atmo ED style model. Something between (Galactica style is a good way to put it) that's very mains centric and slidey sounds perfect for me.