SPYWARE on a motherboard???????? is this true?

hairygit

Member
May 11, 2001
135
0
0
Hi -
I saw the following post on another (sysopt.com) techie site.
Its a long one but frightening if it is true..............
Oh No! *Hardware-Based* Phone Home Apps!

It's true: Phoenix, the BIOS people (they make the Phoenix and Award BIOSes), recently launched PhoenixNet, which will work with an
advertising-based phone-home app built right into the hardware of your PC. Although the announcement is couched in careful terms, the gist is clear. "...system builders and resellers... can use PhoenixNet's
services to distribute... products and services to millions of users."
Millions of captive users, that is.

According to the PhoenixNet site:

The PhoenixNet Internet Launch System (ILS) is a patent-pending technology built into the firmware of your PC.
PhoenixNet's technology resides safely within ROM (Read Only Memory). PhoenixNet is activated automatically at the initial launch of your new PC....

Once running, the PhoenixNet software will use your Internet connection to force-feed you downloads, advertising, "sites to see," and support services. The PhoenixNet utility apparently integrates with Windows; it's controlled--- if that's the word--- via a system tray applet.

However, because at least some of this code is operating at the firmware/BIOS level, it's possible for this code to run "below the
radar" of the OS or of local desktop firewalls. It could be difficult to know just what this code was doing, or when it's doing it.

Why is Phoenix doing this? The PhoenixNet site (http://home.phoenixnet.com/about/index.html )
spins it one way:

New and experienced users alike face some tough hurdles whentrying to get running on a new computer. From connecting to
the Internet to learning about and managing their PC. How do they get started? ... Now, thanks to PhoenixNet, the solution is only a mouse click away. Save time and effort by using PhoenixNet built into the PC.... PhoenixNet services can be individually customized to meet the needs of any user. This service continues over the life of the PC. And it's free.

But despite this happytalk explanation, to me this doesn't look like an impartial third-party advisor to end users, but rather an advertising vehicle. The PhoenixNet site says, "... we select the best providers of
these products and enter into partnerships with them in order to provide these tools directly through our network," To me, this sounds like: "Vendors pay us, or give us a cut of their action, to get their stuff
listed on PhoenixNet."
PhoenixNet may be hard to avoid: A number of motherboard makers have already agreed to start using PhoenixNet: They include AOpen, Chaintech, ECS, EpoX, Giga-Byte, Jetway, Legend-QDI, MSI, Soltek and Zida.

For biased info on this, see the PhoenixNet FAQ at http://home.phoenixnet.com/about/index.html#fre ; for third-party,
independent views, see Steve Gibson's GRC newsgroup on 'spyware:" Point your usenet/newsgroup reader at news.grc.com, and join the grc.spyware discussion.


WELL FOLKS - WHADDYA THINK.

 

Duvie

Elite Member
Feb 5, 2001
16,215
0
71
I am thinking how do we disable it??? I can't remember if on posting my bios says award or phoenixnet now with Biostar kt133 board...YIKES!!! Technology is not out yet , right?
 

splice

Golden Member
Jun 6, 2001
1,275
0
0
The latest Epox 8K7A BIOS has PhoenixNET... you can disable it in the BIOS.
 

hairygit

Member
May 11, 2001
135
0
0
Splice - Are you sure about that?
I don't wanna sound paranoid or anything but.....

i am scared and wanna goto bed with the lights on
 

Imaginer

Diamond Member
Oct 15, 1999
8,076
1
0
A baby's security blanket to the newbie user.

Any word on a version of a BIOS WITHOUT this?
 

Sundog

Lifer
Nov 20, 2000
12,342
1
0


<< The latest Epox 8K7A BIOS has PhoenixNET >>



I'll make sure to look for that in two days when my new mobo gets here.
 

splice

Golden Member
Jun 6, 2001
1,275
0
0


<< Splice - Are you sure about that?
I don't wanna sound paranoid or anything but.....

i am scared and wanna goto bed with the lights on
>>



It should be under &quot;Advanced BIOS Features->PhoenixNET Support&quot; [ENABLE/DISABLE] default is disabled. This is how it is on the Epox 8K7A.
 

hairygit

Member
May 11, 2001
135
0
0
ANYONE object to putting this on a couple of the other forums?

I think that more ppl should know about this.

I'll wait for a few minutes
 

Shmorq

Diamond Member
Aug 10, 2000
3,431
1
0
As long as splice is correct about being able to disable this, it's not too big of a deal.
 

pulpp

Platinum Member
May 14, 2001
2,137
0
0
actually this sounds like a good feature, i mean geez people give me a freaken break, whats so bad about looking at advertising? or do you think they are trying to hyptonize you through ads and takeover your life? i suppose you sit shivering on your coach as those nasty TV networks run the commercials, then you run out of the house scared for your life and get in your car, but noooooooooo!!!!!! there are ads on the radio, you get hysterical, you cant drive, so you ditch your car and run in the street, Noooooooo!!!!!!! there are banners on the streets too... give me a fvucking break, advertising is how business works, consumers get informed and the economy grows.
 

Dually

Golden Member
Dec 20, 2000
1,628
0
0
That is evil, especially since the two merged a while ago, there is no compitition to say no. I suspect computer manufactors will get in the bios making effort for their computers.
 

Courtland

Senior member
Jun 11, 2001
703
0
0
As long as you can disable it, it is ok, if you couldn't, I would never buy any piece of hardware that used it, we don't buy motherboards to look at ads.
 

Auric

Diamond Member
Oct 11, 1999
9,591
2
71
The real question is: do we need yet another thing that has to be disabled or ignored? We already have to disable Intel's CPU serial number, employ anti-advertising counter measures while browsing the web, wrestle with software spyware and integrated update programs, use VCR or TIVO devices to avoid television advertising, shun the radio for our own recordings, and generally try our best to ignore print and billboard advertising. It's all just noise.
 

rc5

Platinum Member
Oct 13, 1999
2,464
1
0
if it is really that bad, we always can remove the entire ads code from bios by using cbios. :)
 

McCarthy

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,567
0
76
pulpp - let me guess, you wear a T-shirt with big GAP letters, shoes with a blinking neon swoosh, and sing &quot;Have you driven a Ford lately&quot; every time you start your car, close?

The point of this is we've bought the hardware. Period. When you watch TV, you're trading your time watching commercials in order to receive the product, the program. Same with the radio. If your TV was cutting out during the programming to display more advertising from built in hardware, you'd be for that too?

The spyware aspect is troubling too for other reasons, but good grief man, what advertising firm do you work for which makes you support people using hardware you've bought with your own money to throw more of their ads in your face?

I should stop at the video store, are people renting videotapes of nothing but commercials to watch yet? Oh, sorry, showing my age, DVDs.

Economy is just another overhyped E-word. Doesn't matter how the national spreadsheet works out if it's infringing on your lifestyle. I'd rather be a bit poorer than live in a &quot;great economy&quot; where the firmware in my clock radio is programmed to send me subliminal messages all night.

--Mc
 

damocles

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,105
5
81
Well said McCarthy

When i buy hardware i don't expect to be submitted to additional advertising
 

KevinH

Diamond Member
Nov 19, 2000
3,110
7
81
Jus the very thought of this makes me sick. Regardless of how trivial the spyware may be, the very principal is soo damned shady it's disgusting.
 

acexg1

Senior member
Feb 24, 2001
355
0
0
I didn't even see the option for this in my KK266 bios (0307), but it was listed in the manual.... it hasn't activated anything that I know of yet though.
 

smp

Diamond Member
Dec 6, 2000
5,215
0
76


<< As long as splice is correct about being able to disable this, it's not too big of a deal. >>


Yes it is. Advertising is a very big deal.
McArthy: VERY well said! I agree.

I'll relate this to my recent movie theatre experience;

I went to go see Tomb Raider (horrible horrible movie, babboon butt lips overacted like no tomorrow and the whole thing really just stank) at the theatre the other night and payed 12.oo to get in (CND).. lo and behold.. they raised the prices to that much money, and now they're showing us WAAAY more commercials too. This is like the television example from before. With TV you trade. What about the movie theatre.. I payed to go watch ads for a fvckin half hour? NO WAY!!! And it's not like you can turn the damn channel either. The thing with the bios is way worse. They are getting info on you, without you knowing. Man, my computer is as personal to me as my goddamn underwear okay! I don't want anything or anybody in there without me knowing or without my permission. I read something about this one time.. what was it called??.... er..

1984 or no.. uh.. BRAVE NEW WORLD.. er.. dammit, people gotta wake up and realize that we aren't commodities, or numbers.. and no, I won't be happy just cause I can buy great products.. I want to know where they come from and at what cost to the people who made me .. etc etc.. click on the link in my sig to see what this kind of sh!t breeds. People are PEOPLE.. not products or commodities. Oh yeah .. and FVCK nike and the Gap..
 

smp

Diamond Member
Dec 6, 2000
5,215
0
76
Long live Linux and the whole open source community. Linux is anarchy in practice.
 

hairygit

Member
May 11, 2001
135
0
0
I go with both of you there except the Linux bit.
-don't know enough about it, and am frightened to learn, cos when I get going, I can break a puter at 100yards.
 

JellyBaby

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2000
9,159
1
81
This functionality does not belong at the BIOS level and simply adds to component costs. I believe the long-term goal is to enable advertising that can't be turned-off. What sucks is that there's not much competition at all in the BIOS services arena. I guess this is what happens as a result...? :(