Sony Vaio, Toshiba, or Dell Laptops ? Which is better

iwillhelp

Banned
Mar 15, 2004
48
0
0
Anyone have any comment on which company is better to go with for a laptop.
Any problems or good things about Vaio laptops please post them.
same for dell, and toshiba.

Thanks,
 

FleshLight

Diamond Member
Mar 18, 2004
6,883
0
71
vaio = most expensive, then toshiba, then dell.

If i were to get a vaio, I'd get their lightest one (1.7 pounds)...other wise I'd get a dell.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Dell is on my sh!t list for laptops at the moment. Their latest Inspiron lineup is pure crap. I've never seen such flimsy, chintzy poorly constructed laptops in my life. Bah!
I've never been a fan of any sony computing products outside of their trinitron monitors.
The last couple Toshiba's that I've bought (M30 series) were pretty nice machines.

Personally, I'd give the Thinkpads a look at. Also, I've been pretty happy with the laptops Gateway has been putting out lately.
 

Rogue

Banned
Jan 28, 2000
5,774
0
0
Can't comment from experience with the Sonys, however, I'd stay away from Toshiba. My former employer settled on them after we landed their technical support account and I've never known so many unhappy users or problematic systems. By contrast, we still have several Dells that 5 years old and used every day as desktop replacement systems in a docking station and the only problems we've had with them is the CD-ROM drives go bad after a while, but all CD-ROM drives do that when you play music CDs in them all day 5 days a week or more in a laptop for 5 years. I stand by Dell laptops 100%.
 

PhilsPhan

Member
Jul 10, 2003
45
0
0
Apple Powerbook but wait for the G5.

If you need to have a PC, I feel sorry for you but for laptops definitely IBM.

Sorry that doesn't help with any of your choices
 

Zim Hosein

Super Moderator | Elite Member
Super Moderator
Nov 27, 1999
65,515
409
126
From my own personal experience, I'd buy a Dell. The Sony laptops are nice, but like their PDA's I feel they are "fragile." As for the Tosh laptops, it's bit hard to find them at a decent price. I Hope this helps a bit iwillhelp :)
 

dethman

Lifer
Oct 12, 1999
10,263
3
76
having had an inspiron 4100 and 600m, i'd rate dell's laptop quality as 'fair' at best. my old vaio was a bit better constructed but much more expensive.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Originally posted by: Rogue
Can't comment from experience with the Sonys, however, I'd stay away from Toshiba. My former employer settled on them after we landed their technical support account and I've never known so many unhappy users or problematic systems. By contrast, we still have several Dells that 5 years old and used every day as desktop replacement systems in a docking station and the only problems we've had with them is the CD-ROM drives go bad after a while, but all CD-ROM drives do that when you play music CDs in them all day 5 days a week or more in a laptop for 5 years. I stand by Dell laptops 100%.

I'd agree with you on the last 5 years worth of Dells laptops. But this latest rollout of the "silver & blue" themed machines has just been horrible. Dell just totally cheaped out on the build quality and parts. The trackpads are terrible, the mouse buttons are terrible, the plastic is cheap that you can warp the laptop just by wresting your palms on the palm rest. To sum it up, they are just cheaply built, and not at all on par with what Dell used to build.
 

phonemonkey

Senior member
Feb 2, 2003
806
0
0
I've had both Toshiba and Dell laptops (Satellite 1735 and Inspiron 1100 respectively), and I'd have to say that I'd rather have a Dell. The screen is more crisp, and the color is better as well. I also like the battery life (usually about 3 hours per charge). From the people that I've known that have had other Toshiba's, they have lots of problems with parts going bad relatively quickly (the LCD and mobo mainly).

I wouldn't buy an IBM myself, but that's cause I don't like their prices for the quality of the equipment. We've got IBM laptops all over the place here, and it feels like the mid 90's when using them.
 

Dacalo

Diamond Member
Mar 31, 2000
8,778
4
76
Out of those choices, I would go with Toshiba first, then Dell, and then Sony.

Of course, I would get an IBM out of all those choices :)
 

brunswickite

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2002
6,386
1
0
i have an old IBM thinkpad 600 i am using
266 p2 , 192 mb ram with windows XP, doesnt lag at all for browseing and chat!
this thing is so well built, and the keyboard is amazing..
 

Sid59

Lifer
Sep 2, 2002
11,879
3
81
my old toshiba is rock solid. it's from 1999 and for the last year +, it's been sitting in the closet cause my brother damaged the AC Unit. I pulled it out for the funk of it and to try a battery i bought new years ago and see how well it held a charge. It's still awesome.

Thing once had an uptime of 24 days. a laptop! Old thing handled XP decently and now is retired.
 

DurocShark

Lifer
Apr 18, 2001
15,708
5
56
My work just switched from Dells to IBMs because of the complaints from the Dell users.

I personally have an old HP (P3 700) that rocks.
 

UNCjigga

Lifer
Dec 12, 2000
25,715
10,471
136
pointerstick = ownage! Get an IBM with the red dot (invented by Indian engineers?) or else get a toshiba with the dot. Anything else has touchpads, in which case I'd say Vaio, then Dell.
 

Chiropteran

Diamond Member
Nov 14, 2003
9,811
110
106
I had a sony and it was absolute garbage. Despite a "designed for windows 2000" sticker on it, it came preloaded with Windows ME and Sony refused to give out windows 2000 drivers even if you install 2000 on your own. It sorta-kinda worked eventually with 2000 by loaded a bios from a different model, but it left a bad taste as far as sony. Ever sony we have at work has problems also. Dell are pretty bad too, but better than Sony IMO. Toshiba is probably your best bet from the listed choices, but I go with IBM myself.
 

KMurphy

Golden Member
May 16, 2000
1,014
0
0
Originally posted by: Jigga
pointerstick = ownage! Get an IBM with the red dot (invented by Indian engineers?) or else get a toshiba with the dot. Anything else has touchpads, in which case I'd say Vaio, then Dell.

Dell's have that too.
 

hans007

Lifer
Feb 1, 2000
20,212
18
81
i've had a LOT of laptops.

i tend to settle on compaq/hp ones, because their phone support for RMAs is a lot better than dell and they tend to cost less than dell. plus they dont look as dull.

the dells ive used and had, well for one thing i dont think i've ever seen a dell in the 15 + years i've used computers that i would ever say felt "rock solid" not like an ibm.

toshiba's business tecra lines, are solid. the consumer one is just as bad as dell in flimsy plastic mcdonalds toy like ness. then again most consumer laptops are in general (there are like 4 companies that build all of them anyway).

toshiba consumer tech support is quicker than dell and a lot less time on the phone. but toshibas tend to cost more and there are never any deals. you also cant custom build a toshiba. i had to rma a toshiba ones, and they tried to give me all these options to do instead of sending it in. i knew it was dead.
and had to keep pestering the guy on the phone until he let me send it in. it was fixed in about a week. not too horrible.

HP on the other hand (my favorite for this purpose) they seem to freely give RMA numbers, so you just send it in , overnighted by them for free and get it back in like 4-5 days. its pretty nice, a lot less phone calling and hassling.



sonys are just pretty. probably a bit more solidly build for thin ones (generally thin laptops are made of titanium, or magnesium alloy, so they always feel sturdier than the larger plastic mainstream laptops). sonys do look cool, but they are really expensive. that and from what i've heard, their support is down right terrrible, and their turnaround times on repairs are god awful like up to a month.


so i guess in that case, given the choice of a dell sony or toshiba i'd sadly have to admit i'd get the dell, since you probably get more for your money and build quality and support probably are all even across those 3 brands.