So what should we do with John Walker (the American kid who fought with the Taliban), columnist says let him go

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126
Story link

"...Walker's misfortune is that his search for identity intersected precisely with the World Trade Center attacks, and the U.S. declaration of war against the Taliban and Osama bin Laden.

With a slightly different turn of events, Walker might have become the idealistic doctor he once talked about, in order to help the poor in developing countries. Then we would have been celebrating his achievements, instead of wondering what went wrong.

Charging Walker with treason would mean showing him less compassion than Taliban fighters who are being welcomed with open arms by Northern Alliance fighters, or Pakistani fighters who were flown back to their villages with tacit U.S. approval.

Instead of labeling him a traitor, as we did to Aaron Burr, Tokyo Rose and Ezra Pound, President Bush should allow Walker's parents to fly him back to Fairfax, and let him get his life back on track. We'd want nothing less for our own children, who could easily have found themselves in a similar mess."



 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
I thought this was a very good article.

I totally understand that he never intended to do anything wrong and if anything, he was brainwashed into fighting for the Taliban.

Truly, he just got dealt a lot of crappy luck but the responsibility for what he did can only come on him.

In this thread, we discussed a similar article
 

rutchtkim

Golden Member
Aug 2, 2001
1,880
0
0
sounds compelling. but the fact is, he did carryout injustice to the United States and for that reason, should be punished accordingly to our law. However, if he were someone I knew, I would want him freed.

later all, time to go to Linear Algebra, shoot me!!!
 

Czar

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
28,510
0
0


<< Charging Walker with treason would mean showing him less compassion than Taliban fighters who are being welcomed with open arms by Northern Alliance fighters, or Pakistani fighters who were flown back to their villages with tacit U.S. approval. >>


Actually the NA are killing many of their prisoners and NOT treating those who are not killed well.
http://www.commondreams.org/headlines01/1210-02.htm


<< ``The world community must consider the fanatic nature of the Northern Alliance and Taliban. Northern Alliance and Taliban are the same,'' Alia Nazeer said >>

 

GasX

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
29,033
6
81
I thought this was a good article...

FOR ME TO POOP ON!

If this prick was "caught up" in the moment, then the arguement can be made that all of them ("them" being the people taking arms against the US) should be let go. It's one thing to savagely abuse your own people and change sides when it looks like you are going to get some retribution. It is another thing to take up arms against your own country in defense of the indefensible.

He can rot in jail for the rest of his pathetic life if you ask me.
 

AaronP

Diamond Member
Feb 27, 2000
4,359
0
0
I think we should execute him for treason. After all, he fought for an army that the US was at war with and fighting against. The people on his side (maybe him) took place in a prison riot that caused the death of an American CIA agent.
 

scauffiel

Senior member
Aug 11, 2000
455
0
0
Time to pay the piper. Bullet to the head. At least it'll be quick and painless, unlike what he and his kind perpetrated upon 4,000+ people.

Screw him. Screw his mental state. Screw getting his life back on track. Won't be happening for the dead and their families will it?

You absolutely cannot make deals with animals. If you don't take care of them now, and I mean take care of them, then they'll be back. These people are animals. Cowardly ones, yet still animals.

Kill them. All of them. I'm tired of this crap. We're supposed to be the understanding, compassionate ones and just for once I'd like to show the world we're not going to take it; that we're not buying into their lies.

I want the world to understand us.

Steve
 

OutHouse

Lifer
Jun 5, 2000
36,410
616
126
did he comit treason? im divided on that issue. he was fighting for the taliban before sept 11th. we dont evern know if he fired upon us forces.

another thing. he has not caused the deaths of any americans. now compare that to that high ranking FBI agent who sold out our country for a buck and caused the deaths of several cia agents. and he got life in prison. To me that is treason.

oh and one last thing, what crime did he commit? War has not been declaired by congress, he didnt sell secrets to a foreign country for a buck and he has not killed any americans.
 

OutHouse

Lifer
Jun 5, 2000
36,410
616
126
I dunno Citrix, maybe you should just go and join him if you love him sooo much.

I ask a reasonable question and i get a redneck answer.
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
I dunno Citrix, maybe you should just go and join him if you love him sooo much.
I ask a reasonable question and i get a redneck answer.


Yeeck...I don't think it was so *redneck* as it was childish...just like saying "Well, if you love carrots so much, why don't you marry them?"
 

scauffiel

Senior member
Aug 11, 2000
455
0
0
It's a fairly simple concept: He's a bad guy. Get it? Bad guys have to pay. The only way to make bad guys pay, so they don't come back, is to kill them. I guess in your eyes he has to fire upon and maybe kill our troops before he warrants punishment? Hmmm, why don't you grab a rifle and get on the front lines?

Never seen such mamby-pansyism in my life

S.
 

OutHouse

Lifer
Jun 5, 2000
36,410
616
126
Hmmm, why don't you grab a rifle and get on the front lines?

ive been on the front lines pally, in panama and the Gulf. what have you done?
 

Renob

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2000
7,596
1
81
So what should we do with John Walker (the American kid who fought with the Taliban), columnist says let him go

I agree 100%, let him go then as he is walking away put a big Fat gun to his head and cap one off.
 

jthsmak

Senior member
Jul 5, 2001
732
0
0
scauffiel,
Oh please, Bad Guys? You don't even know what he has or hasn't done. It is simple for you to label them all as animals. Most are starving and sick. Only a small group orchestrated the sep 11 attacks. The majority are doing what I believe you would not, defending their homeland. You are hateful and ignorant. It is sick you could achieve satisfaction through murder. Granted, executioners perform the act but they do not for one second enjoy it.
 

AaronP

Diamond Member
Feb 27, 2000
4,359
0
0
"the act but they do not for one second enjoy it. "

how can you possibly speak for all executioners. I bet some of em like it.
 

Capn

Platinum Member
Jun 27, 2000
2,716
0
0
"The majority are doing what I believe you would not, defending their homeland. "

Most of the taliban were from Pakistan originally, and the Al-Qaeda are comprised of many nationalities, with Saudis the majority/plularity I believe. If anyone is fighting for their homeland it's the NA.
 

Speedy3D!

Golden Member
Oct 31, 1999
1,794
0
0
Don't we have a law against treason people? Let him go?! Are you kidding me?

he can rot in jail if he's lucky.
 

jjones

Lifer
Oct 9, 2001
15,424
2
0
the way i understand it is he was a member of the al qaeda forces, not the taliban. in my book that makes him part of a terrorist organization. off to jail he goes.
 

Cyberian

Diamond Member
Jun 17, 2000
9,999
1
0
How long ago did he join the Taliban? If it was before our involvement in Afghanistan, the charge of treason is a bit questionable.
Wasn't the Taliban "the good guys" when they were fighting the Russians?