So how bad is surrendering a car with a loan? *UPDATE*

Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
My last job required a car to commute (not reachable by public transportation) but unfortunately I was laid off only 1 year into my car loan. My current job makes my car absolutely unnecessary now and I'm stuck with a $380 payment and $120 for insurance - $500 that's absolutely wasted.

I'm upside down on the loan (a cheapie nissan versa, not a BMW - keep the snooty attitude about living beyond my means to yourself!) and I expect to make less at this current job than the last, so that extra $500 will come in very handy.

I already have reached my before-30s goal of buying a house and don't anticipate needing credit for 2 years... My wife thinks we should just surrender the car or let them repo it but that seems dangerous, but wasting $500 a month for a car when I have a subway station across the street in NYC is getting tiring..

UPDATE
Figured that I got some great (yet obvious to everyone but myself) advice and you guys were owed an update.

We're keeping the car. I was a bit past due but I made a mother of a payment after I got my first commission check and everything's completely kosher. My wife and I figured that we'll eventually need a car when we get a kid so this will be that car. Figure I spend about $10 a day on smoking (NYC and her cig taxes!) so I agreed to quit to help make the car payments. I also plan on using the car for work over the weekends, driving in will actually be fun and free parking on Sunday - woot!

Thanks for helping me think clearly, it was easier to throw in the towel but ultimately a dumb decision.
 
Last edited:

her209

No Lifer
Oct 11, 2000
56,336
11
0
Does the bank repo the car and sell it off and make you pay the difference of the loan?
 

meltdown75

Lifer
Nov 17, 2004
37,548
7
81
so um... you took out the loan to buy the car and now you can't pay the loan?

uh... sell the car and put it towards the loan? surely it can't be that simple.......

yeah. just stop paying the loan and let them come and "repo" your car. seems like a better idea. i'm sure it would do wonders for your credit rating.
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
Umm you can't sell it?

loan balance is $11,000 it's worth maybe 7-8k... It's a versa after all. I got it because it offered 35mpg (I commuted 30 miles each way), but it's a shitty shitty car. I bet I'd get $6k for it, meaning I'd still be in the hole for 5 grand.
 

meltdown75

Lifer
Nov 17, 2004
37,548
7
81
loan balance is $11,000 it's worth maybe 8... It's a versa after all. I got it because it offered 35mpg (I commuted 30 miles each way), but it's a shitty shitty car. I bet I'd get $6k for it, meaning I'd still be in the hole for 5 grand.

tough titty, said the kitty
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
so um... you took out the loan to buy the car and now you can't pay the loan?

uh... sell the car and put it towards the loan? surely it can't be that simple.......

yeah. just stop paying the loan and let them come and "repo" your car. seems like a better idea. i'm sure it would do wonders for your credit rating.

It's not that I can't, it's just that the car is absolutely unnecessary since I was laid off and started a new job that's reachable by public transport.

I guess I should go to a dealership and see what they have to say... I wouldn't be able to lump sum the difference, which I worry about.
 

Mermaidman

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
7,987
93
91
loan balance is $11,000 it's worth maybe 7-8k... It's a versa after all. I got it because it offered 35mpg (I commuted 30 miles each way), but it's a shitty shitty car. I bet I'd get $6k for it, meaning I'd still be in the hole for 5 grand.

You would be 'in the hole' either way. If the bank repossesses the car and auctions it off for squat, then it will come after you for the difference. Better that you sell it yourself.

And . . . $380/mo for a Versa?! $120/mo for insurance for a Versa?!
 
Nov 7, 2000
16,403
3
81
sell it and bring cash to cover the gap, or sit on it until you are out from underneath

can you find someone to take over payments?
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
sell it and bring cash to cover the gap, or sit on it until you are out from underneath

can you find someone to take over payments?

Wish I could find someone to take over the payments (heck, I'd subsidize payments as an incentive), but this is NYC and car's aren't a necessity (unless, of course, you work an hour away, like I used to)..
 

highland145

Lifer
Oct 12, 2009
43,973
6,338
136
Does the bank repo the car and sell it off and make you pay the difference of the loan?
Try to. Will 1099C you for the remaining balance which is "income" you'll pay taxes on.
yeah. just stop paying the loan and let them come and "repo" your car. seems like a better idea. i'm sure it would do wonders for your credit rating.
I-9 for 7 to 9 years. Good luck getting another auto loan under 15%.
 

amdhunter

Lifer
May 19, 2003
23,332
249
106
Meh, you already have a house. That's all people want good credit for. Give it back. Fuck it.
 

highland145

Lifer
Oct 12, 2009
43,973
6,338
136
Wish I could find someone to take over the payments (heck, I'd subsidize payments as an incentive), but this is NYC and car's aren't a necessity (unless, of course, you work an hour away, like I used to)..
I would be hard pressed to trust ANYONE to take over payments even with you subsidizing them. After 23+ years in the finance industry, experience shows 99 out of 100 screw the borrower. They trash, wreck, break it....you still get stuck.
 

Capt Caveman

Lifer
Jan 30, 2005
34,543
651
126
Sell it and pay the remainder of the loan. Letting it get repo'd will just ruin your credit and the bank will still go after you for the remaining balance.
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
Good luck. Sucks but bad credit sucks more.

Completely cynical - but when buying a home I had an outstanding credit card charge off that my broker said I should settle on, which I did for 50% of what was owed.... That charge off was actually easy to deal with and is no longer on my credit report. Are car loans like that at all? Say I *do* want to get a car (or I need to relocate and buy a condo) in 2 years and this black mark is on my credit report- can I settle with this lender (even at 100% of what is owed) and get it removed from my credit report, or are car loans a completely other beast?


To phrase it this way, what if I do this:

1. Turn over the car
2. The balance after auction would be say $6,000
3. I don't make payments but instead save that $500 into a savings account
4. After a year, or whenever I need to have my credit accessed, I pay that $6,000 + whatever penalties back in full

Is that a solution at all?
 
Last edited:

arcenite

Lifer
Dec 9, 2001
10,660
7
81
Completely cynical - but when buying a home I had an outstanding credit card charge off that my broker said I should settle on, which I did for 50% of what was owed.... That charge off was actually easy to deal with and is no longer on my credit report. Are car loans like that at all? Say I *do* want to get a car (or I need to relocate and buy a condo) in 2 years and this black mark is on my credit report- can I settle with this lender (even at 100% of what is owed) and get it removed from my credit report, or are car loans a completely other beast?


To phrase it this way, what if I do this:

1. Turn over the car
2. The balance after auction would be say $6,000
3. I don't make payments but instead save that $500 into a savings account
4. After a year, or whenever I need to have my credit accessed, I pay that $6,000 + whatever penalties back in full

Is that a solution at all?

Better idea: Sell car, put remainder of loan on credit card via those nifty balance transfer checks you get, settle with lender of credit card.

/thread
 

CrackRabbit

Lifer
Mar 30, 2001
16,642
62
91
DO NOT DO IT.
Please take my advice on this, you will regret the stain it leaves on your credit.
Those stains do not go away easily, it will be at least 7 years for it to be gone.
Find a way to sell the car even if you take a loss on it in the short term.