• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

since the navy is arming frickin ships with frickin lasers now...

Yes, in much the same way that you can stop a bullet with a bullet proof jacket. Hopefully the Chinese didn't read this post. If they strap bullet proof jackets all over their boats they will be invincible.
 
Now all we need is some pet sharks to take out submarines.

frickin_lasers.jpg
 
Pocatello said:
Hopefully the new laser system can shoot down supersonic anti-ship missiles.
Click to expand...

That's their only use, and only if the missiles aren't polished.

I can't really see the use of lasers as a naval weapon. Enemies with cannons can simply fire from beyond the horizon. Planes can hide behind clouds. The only thing lasers can accomplish are sinking small boats - but not at a distance if the waves are high.
 
oynaz said:
That's their only use, and only if the missiles aren't polished.

I can't really see the use of lasers as a naval weapon. Enemies with cannons can simply fire from beyond the horizon. Planes can hide behind clouds. The only thing lasers can accomplish are sinking small boats - but not at a distance if the waves are high.
Click to expand...

What about if the laser is being used in conjunction with a radar system/satellite system. Then the clouds wouldn't really be an issue. If a weapon is fired beyond the horizon... wait until it crosses it, then shoot it down. Then we launch 154 tomahawks at them from a SSGN. Game over.
 
ViRGE said:
No, it cannot be reflected. Mirrors aren't reflective enough to fully reflect a high intensity laser beam; it will quickly absorb enough energy to burn through the mirror and render the mirror useless.
Click to expand...


Even if the mirror did reflect, it a) won't necessarily reflect back to the firing ship and b) they are still not 100% reflective, so a high powered laser could easily still send enough energy through the mirror to destroy its target.
 
JTsyo said:
really?
Seems it might be more of a Coast Guard weapon. Maybe anti-pirate action.
Click to expand...

This. The video clearly shows its intended purpose, disabling small craft with outboard engines or vulnerable fuel supplies. Hopefully it can burn through the propellant or explosives of an incoming missile as well.
 
Ben90 said:
Yes, in much the same way that you can stop a bullet with a bullet proof jacket. Hopefully the Chinese didn't read this post. If they strap bullet proof jackets all over their boats they will be invincible.
Click to expand...

now I have coffee sprayed all over my monitor and keyboard...
 
Brainonska511 said:
Even if the mirror did reflect, it a) won't necessarily reflect back to the firing ship and b) they are still not 100% reflective, so a high powered laser could easily still send enough energy through the mirror to destroy its target.
Click to expand...

ok, say its 98% reflective. the mirror would get 2% and the ship get's 98% reflected back! 😱
 
Last edited:
How would that even work? The boat is covered in a big square mirror that can adjust the angle of said mirrors so the beam reflects back exactly the way it came? Oh not to mention it would need to detect the incoming beam then adjust the mirror(s) at the speed of light.
 
z1ggy said:
How would that even work? The boat is covered in a big square mirror that can adjust the angle of said mirrors so the beam reflects back exactly the way it came? Oh not to mention it would need to detect the incoming beam then adjust the mirror(s) at the speed of light.
Click to expand...

Probably not a square, more likey a large parabolic mirror to preemt unnecessary adjustments
 
brainhulk said:
ok, say its 98% reflective. the mirror would get 2% and the ship get's 98% reflected back! 😱
Click to expand...

And how would it be reflected back? Is the mirror's plane going to be normal to the incident laser? Mirrors that are highly reflective are very expensive. Even at your 98% (which is probably less reflective than what you'd find inside of the actual laser), you'd still transmit 2% - a 150kW (taken from Wikipedia's article on some laser defense system) would still transmit 3kW to a very narrow area. That's still a lot of energy for such a small surface area that the laser would be hitting.

And what do you do if the laser system changes to a wavelength that the mirror isn't reflective to? Then all the energy would go right through.
 
z1ggy said:
What about if the laser is being used in conjunction with a radar system/satellite system. Then the clouds wouldn't really be an issue. If a weapon is fired beyond the horizon... wait until it crosses it, then shoot it down. Then we launch 154 tomahawks at them from a SSGN. Game over.
Click to expand...

The problem with the cloud cover is that clouds do a very good job of stopping lasers.

Are you suggesting shooting down an artillery shell? Good luck with that.

Using lasers against missiles make a bit of sense. However, during SDI it was found that polishing the surface of the target reduced the efficiency of lasers tremendously. Up to 85% reduction IIRC.

Hey, discussing frickin' lasers is fun! (and delightfully geeky).
 
oynaz said:
The problem with the cloud cover is that clouds do a very good job of stopping lasers.

Are you suggesting shooting down an artillery shell? Good luck with that.

Using lasers against missiles make a bit of sense. However, during SDI it was found that polishing the surface of the target reduced the efficiency of lasers tremendously. Up to 85% reduction IIRC.

Hey, discussing frickin' lasers is fun! (and delightfully geeky).
Click to expand...

Cloud cover.. yes this is true. I haven't done much research in this area really...but I would assume then once the target comes out of the clouds toward the boat..it would still have time to shoot down the projectile. And what would they polish it with? I mean if it is then highly reflective, is it then not going to be picked up by every radar system in the area? Who knows, they could even equip planes with these, too. Even submarines I am sure could apply these as well.
 
z1ggy said:
How would that even work? The boat is covered in a big square mirror that can adjust the angle of said mirrors so the beam reflects back exactly the way it came? Oh not to mention it would need to detect the incoming beam then adjust the mirror(s) at the speed of light.
Click to expand...

Cover it with an array of very small corner cube reflectors. 🙂

And btw high quality mirrors in laser applications are usually 99.8% or better in reflectiveness.

http://www.rp-photonics.com/laser_mirrors.html
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top