Serious Question: Why are people upgrading to G80?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

D22

Senior member
Nov 13, 2004
396
0
0
GTS are already going for $449 and just OC, that is what I would do if I had the money to blow. Plenty of games are unplayable on x1900's with lots of candy.
 

Matt2

Diamond Member
Jul 28, 2001
4,762
0
0
Originally posted by: Sunrise089
Wow, never had so many replies so fast

Originally posted by: Nightmare225
What, the ability to game at 2560x1600 with 4xAA doesn't count?
Yes, this is fine. It also accounts for 1% of the people who are upgrading. Let me officially say those with 30" displays are a special exception to my criticism.

Originally posted by: Matt2
Superior image quality + over twice as fast isnt worth it?

I seem to remember people dropping their Nvidia 7-Series cards like hot cakes for R580. The performance difference between G70 and R580 was no where near as large as G80 is offering now.
Twice as fast on the exact same games is my point, plus twice as fast as an already playable resolution.

People jumped to R580 because
1) Nothing better was on the horizon
2) There were more games (IMHO) that went from not playable to playable at common resolutions from a 7800GT to a X1900XT than from an X1900XT to a 8800GTX.
3) They didn't pay $650, and they could sell their cards for close to the cost of the R580 part. The total cost to upgrade was quite a bit less.

I'd like to see your 7900GT play FEAR with settings maxed, 16xaa, 16xHQAF @ 1680x1050 or 1600x1200....

That's why people are upgrading.

It doesnt matter if there are no DX10 games, a card that is not limited in resolution or amount of eye candy makes this the most worthwhile upgrade since 9700P
 

Waylay00

Golden Member
Nov 15, 2004
1,793
0
71
Yeah, it's inevitable that the prices will go down after the first wave of "excitement". (about a couple of weeks)
 

BFG10K

Lifer
Aug 14, 2000
22,709
3,004
126
I'm upgrading for better performance and better IQ over my 7900 GTX.

Also 8xMSAA on a single card is a massive step forward with AA. After four years nVidia finally have MSAA that is better than ATi's 6xAA.
 

imported_RedStar

Senior member
Mar 6, 2005
526
0
0
Except for the hard core ...i would bet it all depends on where you are in the upgrade cycle.

I have an ati 9600 pro. the choice is obvious :)

(now i have been tracking the price of the 7900 GT for 1 year ...since i was gonna go to that 1)

In that time it has only dropped 100$. Based on that ....even buying an x800xl for 130$ cdn (while suffering performance) would not be worth it.

bottom line: I think more people have older hardware than you thought :)

This could be a big upgrade cycle for those hardware suppliers to really appreciate. :)
 

MrUniq

Senior member
Mar 26, 2006
307
0
0
Early adopters always pay more...that's why. Plus there are alot of 9800, 6800 folks still out there... compared to the debut price of the 7800..the G80 is a bargain.
 

Sunrise089

Senior member
Aug 30, 2005
882
0
71
Flexy: You sort of make my point for me - the games won't be out for months. I can indeed look a few months down the road, and I see a time when the games you're mentioning are out, and G80 is far cheaper.

Matt: I wasn't saying my card could run everything at any res, I was saying I think the smart upgrade is to a X1900XT, if I wanted to buy a new card. I could get it cheap, especially used, and I think it will depreciate less.

I guess I can see the really high AA arguement, but I sure don't know how much better things look at 8xAA than 4xAA. Maybe they're a huge gain that makes it all worthwile.....but I tend to think that once you're playing at 1920x1200 and max detail settings, you aren't unable to enjoy the game due to 'only' 4xAA.
 

uo7

Senior member
Jun 23, 2002
450
0
0
I'm still using a plain vanilla 6800 is why i'm upgrading. It's really showing its age playing bf 2142, and oblivion is pretty much a joke to play with any candy :( It would cost me about the same to buy an 8800 now as it would an x1900xt and upgrade to an 8800 later when it's cheaper.
 

MadBoris

Member
Jul 20, 2006
129
0
0
I don't understand these types of questions at all. But probably no amount of explaining will really fulfills most peoples lack of understanding on why to upgrade.

I have had a 6800 since it came out, I have been waiting a long time to upgrade and now with a core 2 duo and new generation video card this gives the most bang for the buck with longevity. It is a smart upgrade for me.

Why? To play games at full settings, not struggle with game performance but instead bath in the beauty of immersion "the way it's meant to be played".

Besides you have a 7900GT, why should you upgrade? You shouldn't, you should have waited for the 8800GT! ;)
 

jevans64

Senior member
Feb 10, 2004
208
0
0
I am getting a 8800GTX for the better IQ and faster frame rates at 1920 x 1200.

I built a Conroe system two months ago. At that time I purchased an eVGA 7900GTX knowing full well that the new cards would be out within 90 days. I completed an eVGA step up so the 8800GTX is only going to cost me $263.51.
 

Mysteriouskk

Senior member
Oct 19, 2003
315
0
0
Should I replace my EVGA 7900GTO for the GTS or GTX? I can trade it in to EVGAs website using their trade up program and get $250 off. Worth it?
 

Elfear

Diamond Member
May 30, 2004
7,165
824
126
Originally posted by: Mysteriouskk
Should I replace my EVGA 7900GTO for the GTS or GTX? I can trade it in to EVGAs website using their trade up program and get $250 off. Worth it?

You probably wouldn't get $250 for it on Ebay so I'd say it's worth it. That is if your games are putting the hurt on your video card and you have the disposable funds.
 

dev0lution

Senior member
Dec 23, 2004
472
0
0
Originally posted by: Midwayman
'cause I have a crappy x800xl and dont want to bother upgrading twice?

Haha..the X800XL wasn't too bad in it's day, but it's been ages since it came out in terms of GPU cycles.

Easy upgrade justification = running an older mid-range (X800XL) card and you've since upgraded your CPU to Core2 Duo, you're running Vista and you're not running 1024x768 anymore. Only DX10 card that's got enough muscle to run insane rates at 1600x1200 and above with DX10 support is the 8800 series. It's not like the ATI reply is right around the corner either....

If you want the best for current and titles coming out in the next couple of months you've got a 8800 on your mind. Is it worth it? depends on how much you care about your card depreciating over a month or so :laugh: I'm overdue, but I'll probably end up with a GTS
 
Oct 4, 2004
10,515
6
81
Performs like 7900GTX SLI/X1950 Crossfire but a few hundred less.

Seriously, what's not to like about a card that lets you play at 1920x1200, everything maximized, perhaps even 16XAA while maintaining a minimum FPS around 60? Or bumping it to 2560x1600 with measly 4XAA?

It is super-expensive but it's actually a pretty good deal considering the knockout performance. If you have a 24"-30" LCD, it is simply amazing. And it's targeted exactly at those people.
 

uo7

Senior member
Jun 23, 2002
450
0
0
Originally posted by: theprodigalrebel
Performs like 7900GTX SLI/X1950 Crossfire but a few hundred less.

Seriously, what's not to like about a card that lets you play at 1920x1200, everything maximized, perhaps even 16XAA while maintaining a minimum FPS around 60? Or bumping it to 2560x1600 with measly 4XAA?

It is super-expensive but it's actually a pretty good deal considering the knockout performance. If you have a 24"-30" LCD, it is simply amazing. And it's targeted exactly at those people.

Exactly. I've been very antsy especially when the 7800's came out. In my case, and I imagine quite a few others this upgrade is going to be a huge performance gain in games. The only question in my mind is what ps to buy now. My 400 watt pcp&c just isn't going to cut it anymore.
 
Jun 14, 2003
10,442
0
0
because they can?

theres alot of smart people here with good jobs, if they got the disposable income and their hobby is computers then why not spend what they worked hard for on the latest equipment?

alot of people dont buy things because they need them, they buy because they want them.

i have the desire to own a 8800GTX and if i actually owned a computer and had the money i wouldnt hesitate. i dont need a 8800, i could probably get away with a x1950pro, but want > need
 

Geomagick

Golden Member
Dec 3, 1999
1,265
0
76
Originally posted by: otispunkmeyer
because they can?

theres alot of smart people here with good jobs, if they got the disposable income and their hobby is computers then why not spend what they worked hard for on the latest equipment?

alot of people dont buy things because they need them, they buy because they want them.

i have the desire to own a 8800GTX and if i actually owned a computer and had the money i wouldnt hesitate. i dont need a 8800, i could probably get away with a x1950pro, but want > need

Exactly. Currently waiting for my 8800gtx to arrive on the doorstep.
 

nanaki333

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2002
3,772
13
81
i'm upgrading cause i can. i went from a 9700pro to 6800gt to x1900xtx to 7950gx2 to 8800gtx. i get freebies, so why the hell not? :D

my gtx won't be here til tuesday. :(
 

Polish3d

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2005
5,500
0
0
Originally posted by: Sunrise089
Right now a 8800GTX is $650. The card is awesome. It plays any game at any resolution. It also seems totally unnecessary.

Today, a X1900XT costs $320. There is a $330 difference in price between the cards. So what game are people needing to play that really need $330 more graphical power?

"But Sunrise089, you're being an idiot, G80 will dominate down the road"

Yes it will, it will also drop in price greatly. When R600 launches, which is BEFORE the vast majority of promising upcoming games in the Crysis vein will emerge, the 8800GTX will probably be under $500. For that depreciation to make owning the card worthwile, either a X1900XT will only be worth $170 in 4 months, or there are lots of games available now that the ATI card cannot play. Where are those games? Nothing promanant has launced recently, and plenty of people have been playing Oblivion (the most demanding title available now) extensively with lesser hardware than G80. So what is it really allowing you to do, other than play the same F.E.A.R. and Half Life 2 you've been playing fine already?

I bring this thread up because when 6800 Ultra and X800XT launched we had games coming out like Doom 3 that were NOT playable at desirable resolution on the older hardware, AND were still not fully playable on the new hardware. You were left happy with your 6800GT performance, but not able to destroy the game. I can see no such software lead with G80, infact I see a huge lead in hardware performance. It makes me happy actually, since I have no budget for a new card right now, because I'm not missing out on anything so much as I can tell. Am I missing something here?



That's exactly the view I've expressed. If I could get a G80 for free I would take it, but there are literally NO GOOD GAMES coming out that would make it worth upgrading from an overclocked x1900xtx. I bought the XTX for new games and still nothing has come out. So this time I'll wait
 

enz660hp

Senior member
Jun 19, 2006
242
0
0
I think if I was filthy rich, I would probably have two 8800gtx's in sli right now....wouldnt you? If you have money, buy it! .....(and buy one for us poor poeple as well) hehe
 

Muhadib

Member
Jan 11, 2005
168
0
0
Originally posted by: the Chase
Originally posted by: munky
I have an x1900xt, and I would upgrade if I had a high res monitor. But I game on a CRT at 1280x960, and I'm not switching to any LCD. So, I have the luxury of playing at all out settings, like HDR+AA+AAA+HQAF, and I'll most likely only upgrade once DX10 games make it worthwhile. But to run those settings at 1600x1200 or higher with playable fps, you'd need the g80 right now, even for DX9 games. That's why some ppl are upgrading now.

Hey happy birthday munky!

Same thing here with my 1800XT. Going to 1600x1200 really limits the eye candy I can use and I'm getting tired of the slowdowns in Bf2 esp. at that resolution.

Haven't gone for the G80 quite yet though. Can't make myself spend $650 for a video card and the GTS is a great card but far off from the GTX. Hoping prices will drop and an in between GT model will come in at below $500 with closer specs. to the GTX. (And keeping the ear to the ground on the R600).

Your video\CPU is not your weakness in BF2, Its your 1gig of memory.
 

XNice

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2000
1,562
0
76
Originally posted by: flexy
But sooner or later there WILL be games which run only w/ DX10, AFAIk Crysis will be one of them, POSSIBLE ut2k7 and other high-end titles.

Look more a few months more down the road, pls :)
Crysis is DX9 also......
 

Golgatha

Lifer
Jul 18, 2003
12,405
1,079
126
Since when are high end video card purchases dictated by logic? If you want more, faster, and now, then you go get some 8800GTX.
 

IndyJaws

Golden Member
Nov 24, 2000
1,931
1
81
Here's why I bought the 8800GTX...

1) I'm building my first new PC in 5 years. Currently dealing with an Athlon 2000+, 6800GT (bought 2 years ago to try to extend life of computer).

2) I've never had the top-of-the-line video card, always mid-line at best. Always had to make sacrifices in video quality, especially with AA/AF. Did I lose any sleep over it? No, but there was always a part of me that wished I didn't have to.

3) My wife and I work hard, provide a good life for our kids, including one in college, and make decent to good money. Like the Loreal commercials..."Because I'm worth it." ;)