Quit playing with my heart admins! You goin' down or what?!
I really only play RTTS, and my guy plays 1B.
Did get put as a catcher once, calling pitches is kind of cool. I remember with 09 I did play an exhibition game to play around a bit, and then decided RTTS was gold as a game-mode.
Batting, I wish I could tell you a secret, but quite simply, it's hard. It's very hard if the pitcher doesn't make any mistakes and leave one in a happy spot. You kind of figure out your own good hitting spots over time, and just hope you never get stuck with an at bat where you never see a ball remotely close to that spot.
And many of those at bats I end up not making good contact and getting out, or striking out.
With The Show 09, I was pretty bad at hitting. I picked up 10, took a little while to re-familiarize myself with the game, and then bam, I just started tearing up, for the most part. First two MLB seasons and I'm tearing down records.

Sometimes I have to resort to cheating a little bit, by quitting the game before it can save a really bad game. But ended up with Rookie of the Year, and then MVP (also Playoff MVP, but wasn't too hot during the World Series, and while we won, I didn't get
WS MVP). Broke the single-season RBI and Hits records, hits leader for two seasons (HR leader the second season)... ended last season with a .480 or so.

Gunning for the single-season HR record this year. Screw you Barry Bonds!