Second monitor display is stretched too wide...?

Petros_k

Member
Jan 20, 2014
149
0
71
Trying to set up dual monitors (to DUPLICATE the desktop display, not extend) with a 19" LCD monitor (native resolution is 1440 x 900) and a 26" LCD TV (native resolution is 1377 x 768, but it does 720p and 1080p) and the TV display is stretched just enough to notice. Graphics card is an ATI Radeon HD 6450. Connection types:

LCD TV monitor HDMI-input, graphics card HDMI-output.
LCD computer monitor HDMI input, graphics card DVI output

Connected in this way I get excellent text on the computer screen with a slightly degraded quality for text on the TV. Switching the cable connections degrades the computer monitor text quality too much and does nothing to fix the slight stretching of the display on the TV.

My attempt to troubleshoot:

For the ATI Radeon HD 6450, the AMD Catalyst Control Center (CCC) has been installed. When I go to the tab called "Creating and Arranging Desktops", I can see both displays are set at 1440 x 900, and I can't change this, but this shouldn't be the place to alter the resolution for the TV anyway because it's not set as the primary display.

If I go to the tab called "My Digital Flat-Panels" > Properties, for the TV monitor I can select "Maintain Aspect Ratio," and this stops the stretching but makes black bars on the sides of the TV monitor display. The display height is correct.

If at the same tab I instead select "Scale image to full panel size, I can then use the Scaling Options of the CCC (also under "My Digital Flat-Panels" ) to get the image on the TV to fill the screen, but the proportion is again stretched just enough to notice.

I see there's a tab called "HDTV Support," but when I try to change this to create a custom HDTV format it changes both the desktop (the 19" LCD monitor) and shrinks the size of the TV display image. I don't even know if I should be fooling with settings here because the options page here says: "if your digital panel is set to 720p or 1080i standard format and portions of the image are not visible you can create a custom format," but that's not the issue.

On the TV monitor remote, when I select the HDMI source connected to the PC, I get a dialog box that says 1920 x 1080, and with an HDMI connection I'm assuming that's what I would want. There's no other adjustments for resolution or aspect ratio that can be made on the TV itself (on this TV only a VGA connection allows PC Timings and ratios to be changed. The digital connection appears to be auto-detect).


Is my only choice to "Maintain Aspect Ratio" and live with the black bars on the TV monitor? Anybody familiar with the AMD CCC know what setting might be wrong here that can alter only the TV monitor?

BTW I'm using Windows 7.
 
Last edited:

KingFatty

Diamond Member
Dec 29, 2010
3,034
1
81
The native resolutions are different shapes right (different native aspect ratios)?

I can't see how you can fit the same shape on two differently shaped displays, unless one of them is stretched or letterboxed (black bars). Just basic limitations of geometry/mathematics/reality.
 

Mushkins

Golden Member
Feb 11, 2013
1,631
0
0
and a 26" LCD TV (native resolution is 1377 x 768, but it does 720p and 1080p)

It can only "do" 720p and 1080p by stretching, letterboxing, or overscanning. There's nothing you can do to get it to fit perfectly, just like you can't fit a rectangle perfectly into a square. Personally, i'd let it letterbox since it's close enough to 720p that you still maximize screen real estate and I hate stretching with a passion.
 

Petros_k

Member
Jan 20, 2014
149
0
71
I don't know why I thought you could completely control the resolution of each monitor regardless of the desktop settings -- even if you are creating a duplicate of the desktop. I can see though that's like a contradiction if the native resolution sizes are different because "duplicate" would include the desktop resolution. So the only way then would be to preserve the aspect ratio of the desktop?
 

Sohaltang

Senior member
Apr 13, 2013
854
0
0

KingFatty

Diamond Member
Dec 29, 2010
3,034
1
81
What about prioritizing image quality on the TV, and then stretching or using letterboxing on the monitor?
 

Petros_k

Member
Jan 20, 2014
149
0
71
What about prioritizing image quality on the TV, and then stretching or using letterboxing on the monitor?

I already thought of switching desktop resolutions like this, but it doesn't make sense to cut down on the viewing space of the 19" monitor just to do full screen on the 26" monitor.

I guess most people don't have this issue because when they're connecting multiple monitors they are usually the same size.