• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Seasonic X750 vs Corsair 850HX

Midnight

Golden Member
Will this Seasonic X750 which is onsale right now at newegg:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817151087

be enough to run the rig below with a little room to grow? I was going to use an 850HX but this is cheaper and has newer internals. Plus its gold spec. If the 850HX is a good choice then Ill stick with that route. If theyre are both good choices and offer sufficient power then ill go with the seasonic on sale.

2x 5870
2600k
4 HD, 2x optical
4x dell U3011 30 inch panels.
Some case fans etc. No crazy cooling.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Will this Seasonic X750 which is onsale right now at newegg:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...6&Tpk=AX%20750

be enough to run the rig below with a little room to grow? I was going to use an 850HX but this is cheaper and has newer internals. Plus its gold spec. If the 850HX is a good choice then Ill stick with that route. If theyre are both good choices and offer sufficient power then ill go with the seasonic on sale.

2x 5870
2600k
4 HD, 2x optical
4x dell U3011 30 inch panels.
Some case fans etc. No crazy cooling.

Thanks.
Your link goes to the Corsair AX750.

Anyways, looking at the review for 5870s here:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/2841/26
The test rig with 5870 xfire uses up to 664W (that number should include the PSU's less-than-perfect efficiency, I believe). A 750W PSU should be more than adequate.
 
isnt there something like you can only use like a % of your total psus rating?

the test system is at 664W under full load.

can i just add up components and get the necessary PSU watts?

also updated the link in my original post.

thanks!
 
isnt there something like you can only use like a % of your total psus rating?

the test system is at 664W under full load.

can i just add up components and get the necessary PSU watts?

also updated the link in my original post.

thanks!

Pretty sure I answered your question over at SD. That power supply is one of the best on the market and will have no problems with your system.

When you hear people talk about only using a % of the total that either means A) cheaper power supplies drop off in efficiency sharply over a certain threshold, or B) the PSU is cheap and crappy and unable to reach its listed amount.

Neither of those affects this power supply, check this for more info on 80 plus certification.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/80_PLUS

Also, you once again list your monitors as a factor to consider for the power supply. Just to clear things up, your monitors do not pull from your power supply at all and are therefore irrelevant.
 
hi thanks again for answering =).

while i understand the monitors dont pull from my psu the cards must use more power when driving the actual mini dp ports on the card. thats all.
 
That 750W Seasonic will definitely be adequate for the dual 5870's!

If you look carefully at the benchmarks, a more practical load test - World of Warcraft pulls only 430W.

The 664W that was quoted was for a theoretical benchmark (OCCT) that tries to stress the CPU and GPU to 100% -- this is more than what you will realistically see in use.

Realistically, the system with dual 5870's will pull ~160W-220W idle, and in the range of 350-500W at load. It's only with crazy stress test programs that you'll pull 600W+, or if you're both gaming heavily, and encoding something intensive and loading up all of the CPU's 100%. Overclocking while overvolting (increasing CPU voltage) can also increase CPU power pull by 50-100W.

Your link goes to the Corsair AX750.

Anyways, looking at the review for 5870s here:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/2841/26
The test rig with 5870 xfire uses up to 664W (that number should include the PSU's less-than-perfect efficiency, I believe)
. A 750W PSU should be more than adequate.

That's good thinking, but I think "professional" reviews like Anandtech use measuring devices that measure actual system power consumption, not "at-the-wall" power draw. So a 750W PSU is rated to provide 750W of power to components after conversion of AC (wall power) to DC (computer power). At the wall it would pull more, for example at 80% efficiency a 750W PSU would pull 940W!

I could be wrong on this, but I think that the figure given on AT is measured by voltmeters hooked up to the system, not something like a kill-a-watt, which would measure power consumption at the wall. If someone knows for sure that would be very helpful to know!

---------
You always want to leave yourself a buffer of ~100W+ from the maximum capacity of the PSU because, as you read PSU reviews you realize that PSU's hit their peak efficiency when they are loaded at usually about 20-80% of the rated capacity (so for example, a 750W PSU gives you peak efficiency when the system is demanding 150-600W).

For your system, I'd say that 750W is definitely a good choice. You won't be pulling more than 450W in 99% of scenarios, and when just surfing the web and doing light tasks, your consumption will be closer to 200W.

isnt there something like you can only use like a % of your total psus rating?

the test system is at 664W under full load.

can i just add up components and get the necessary PSU watts?

also updated the link in my original post.

thanks!

Yes, you can just add up the components to get the necessary watts - the difficulty is finding exact figures for all of the components. I use rough guidelines when choosing my PSU. Generally hard drives pull about 5W each, motherboards from 10-20W, quad core CPU's are usually rated 95W or 130W, RAM takes very little, about 4-5W (usually you can just include that in the motherboard figure), and then check reviews for your Video card's TDP (peak power demand). 5870's are rated for 188W TDP (each), and idle at roughly 30W each.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top