MovingTarget
Diamond Member
G8 is nice, but imho is inferior to the Impala. Besides, there hasn't been a real fullsize car from GM since the demise of the Caprice.
-
We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.
Saturn goes rogue
Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
G8 is nice, but imho is inferior to the Impala. Besides, there hasn't been a real fullsize car from GM since the demise of the Caprice.
DrMrLordX
Lifer
The Astra has not sold well in the North American market. It failed as a replacement for the Ion, and it would fail as a replacement for the Cobalt. The Cobalt is doing pretty well for Chevy actually.
Chevy is killing the Cobalt after 2010 and replacing it with the Cruze in 2011 anyway.
What Saturn really needs to do is go back to their roots and do what the Cruze is meant to do, only better. Revamped SL2 with a 1.4-1.6 litre turbocharged or Eaton TVS Supercharged (yeah baby!) engine, lightweight like the old models, good handling, etc.
Of course, it remains to be seen whether or not the American public really likes the idea of putting premium pump gas in a fuel-sipper (fourtwo notwithstanding). If not, there's no reason why they couldn't use a 1.8 litre NA engine like the one in the Astra. It produces almost as much power as the 2.2L engine in my Ion and drags around a heavier car yet gets better mileage in the city.
Oh yeah, plastic panels = win, even if some people made fun of them.
MovingTarget
Diamond Member
Don't knock it. My fiancée owns an 07 LTZ. I'd put it up against a G8 anyday.
The Impala is a nice car I agree. I don't know what reasoning you are using to place it ahead of the G8 though. Comfort maybe? Value? It can't be performance, that's for sure. the G8 is RWD and V8 powered, has an optional 6spd manual, IRS. I know the Impala has an optional V8 but it's only pumping out 300 HP and it's driving the front wheels through an automatic... no thanks.
MovingTarget
Diamond Member
More for comfort and niceties for the price. Performance is great, but imho you can't beat RWD which the Impala does not have. They are two completely different cars fulfilling two different purposes. Besides, the frozen yanks probably would like to keep a FWD option for the "full-size" segment. Keep 'em both, and rebadge one as the Caprice.
Kaervak
Diamond Member
As a Saturn owner (99 SL2, 121,000+miles) they're time is up unfortunately. They've been nothing but badge engineering for GM for the past few years. Everything that made them Saturn has been long gone. The Astra is damn nice and I'd love to see it moved to another badge. Everything else they offer is underwhelming and offered in another badge, especially the Sky. A two seat roadster for the brand of GM that was designed to take on the cheap econobox imports, no wonder GM is in trouble. If Saturn does stick around, going back to "the beginning" is probably the only thing that will save them.
MovingTarget
Diamond Member
The Impala and the G8 really fulfill two different types of vehicle... The G8 really is just an imported Holden Commodore that really fulfills more of a performance niche. It is not, however, designed to be the kind of high-production mainstream vehicle that the Impala was. The Impala, however, is going to be redesigned soon, and they are looking at the possibility of going to RWD for the updated Zeta platform, which has really proven to be successful. Personally, I doubt that this will happen, but it is an interesting possibility. Some people simply aren't suited to drive a RWD vehicle. The G8 would really be best to compliment the Impala in the full-size segment.
As far as the Malibu goes, although it is a great car, a person looking to buy an Impala is not one that would've considered a Malibu. In that case, size matters. 😛 It is fulfilling a different role. You cannot pass off a midsize car like the Malibu as a fullsize car. That is like trying to pass off a Toyota Corolla for something as big as a Taurus. It just doesn't work.
MovingTarget
Diamond Member
Lemme guess, you got the LT1 model? The 3.5 is a bit anemic for my tastes. The next step up actually is a vast improvement. Besides, for a true Interstate car, comfort is key.
I didn't mean the G8 in its current iteration but you can downsize the engine choices
Its a large car, people are chosing the inferior Impala over the excellent Malibu based on price as they are virtually identical and don't realize that one car is superior to the other car.
Dump the inferior large car and with traction and stability control any RWD can be driven as easily as FWD. GM needs to sell the best cars it can, always. . .
http://www.thetruthaboutcars.c...-a-tale-of-two-chevys/
"This raises a number of interesting questions about the value of GM?s supposed product-led turnaround. If the Impala sells better than the Malibu at retail, despite its aged underpinnings and staid looks, was Bob Lutz?s enormous paycheck and frequent outbursts worth the investment? Class-competitive styling, interiors and platforms cost a considerable amount of money, and based on the numbers it seems that loyal GM customers aren?t particularly swayed by them. For all its accolades, the Malibu looks to be not only less popular than its fleet-flooding cousin but less profitable "
Its a large car, people are chosing the inferior Impala over the excellent Malibu based on price as they are virtually identical and don't realize that one car is superior to the other car.
Dump the inferior large car and with traction and stability control any RWD can be driven as easily as FWD. GM needs to sell the best cars it can, always. . .
http://www.thetruthaboutcars.c...-a-tale-of-two-chevys/
"This raises a number of interesting questions about the value of GM?s supposed product-led turnaround. If the Impala sells better than the Malibu at retail, despite its aged underpinnings and staid looks, was Bob Lutz?s enormous paycheck and frequent outbursts worth the investment? Class-competitive styling, interiors and platforms cost a considerable amount of money, and based on the numbers it seems that loyal GM customers aren?t particularly swayed by them. For all its accolades, the Malibu looks to be not only less popular than its fleet-flooding cousin but less profitable "
Dunno which one it was. I didn't think it was low-powered but that it seemed really old dated to me. To be honest, the first one I rented had issues with the wheels so I exchanged it for another Impala which was a tad better but still looked old. Both cars smelled like pee which didn't help either.
TRENDING THREADS
-
Discussion Zen 5 Speculation (EPYC Turin and Strix Point/Granite Ridge - Ryzen 9000)- Started by DisEnchantment
- Replies: 25K
-
Discussion Intel Meteor, Arrow, Lunar & Panther Lakes + WCL Discussion Threads
- Started by Tigerick
- Replies: 25K
-
Discussion Intel current and future Lakes & Rapids thread- Started by TheF34RChannel
- Replies: 24K
-
-
