Samsung's Epic 4G looks to be more of the same

Narmer

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2006
5,292
0
0
So many problems. As with all Samsung products (especially their phones) how long until they move on to the next big thing (Windows 7 Phone's launch is just around the corner) and leave their current customers screwed. You have 1 day left.

http://www.engadget.com/2010/09/29/epic-4g-problems-so-far-and-a-few-solutions/

Epic 4G: problems so far -- and a few solutions

By Richard Lawler posted Sep 29th 2010 4:52PM





Since the Epic 4G launched on Sprint August 31, we've been receiving notes from owners on various issues they've experienced with the phone. We've heard about and experienced problems with the supposedly-fixed GPS, to surprisingly slow 3G uploads (fix on the way), to odd issues with battery drain and glitchy market install problems. Now that we're facing the end of Sprint's 30-day return period, we're wondering if Sprint and Samsung have shown enough of a commitment to resolving any problems to keep owners and potential buyers hanging on. Check after the break for a few of the issues we've found and what can be done about them, and let us know in our poll how optimistic you are about the future of this otherwise well-received device. http://forums.anandtech.com/#poll53527Are you sticking with the Epic 4G or choosing another phone?
I had an Epic 4G, but I've already returned itI bought the Epic 4G at launch or soon after and I'm sticking with it no matter whatI bought the Epic 4G and if I don't hear about fixes I will probably trade it in for something elseI've been considering the Epic 4G but until these issues are taken care of I probably won't pick one upI'm still thinking about buying an Epic 4GSomething elseVote


epic4ggps.jpg

Problem: GPS
Description: The most commonly complained about GPS issues on the Epic 4G seem to center around three things: It's ability to lock onto satellites, even in favorable conditions, constantly reporting accuracy of 30m by satellite at all times no matter what accuracy it should be indicating, and a complete inability to use satellite GPS or provide accurate location information after being on fora few hours. As a result, even with "use network assistance" checked as recommended by the manufacturer, it either gives inaccurate location information that throws off key apps like navigation or is unable to get report its location at all.

Workaround: A reset of the device clears up the issue for a few hours, varying from 4-8 at times depending on conditions. The problem seems to be caused by caching GPS data, so posters from AndroidForums and elsewhere have come up with a workaround to force it to update that information on each request as indicated below. This seems to provide the desired affect of getting a GPS lock without rebooting constantly, but has the downsides of slowing down initial requests and not being able to pull results when outside network range.

Steps:
  • Enter "*#1472365#" in the dialer (no quotes)
  • Select Setup>Position Mode>Starting Mode
  • Change the option from "Hot Start" to "Cold Start"
We've contacted Samsung about this issue, so far they have not acknowledged to us that they've been able to recreate it, and stated that turning on network assisted GPS is a sufficient fix to provide accurate information. Unfortunately in our experience that doesn't do much as described above -- we're eagerly waiting to see how this is dealt with on the Epic as well as the other Galaxy S phones exhibiting GPS issues, any Captivate owners want to chime in on how it's going?

epic4gspeeda.jpg

Problem: 3G upload speeds
Description: When uploading large files or testing with apps like SpeedTest, upload speeds average a max of about 150 kilobits per second, well below other 3G devices on Sprint's network tested at the same time and location, like the EVO, MiFi or EV-DO modems. Casual browsing does not appear to be consistently affected, however some users have reported unusually inconsistent data speeds even while browsing the web. Speed are unaffected over WiFi, and 4G speeds report higher, although some have indicated those appear to be capped as well. We've tested several units and have been unable to reahc a higher speed on any of them, however an Epic tethered to a MiFi or computer connected to Sprint 3G showed no problem reaching higher speeds. In forum posts, a few users have reported isolated incidents of reaching higher speeds, but the 150kbps limit is prevalent across devices and locations, causing issues with trying to use video chat or sending email attachments.

Workaround: None. After reaching out to Samsung and Sprint on this issue, the company sent us this response:
"We have heard reports of users experiencing less-than-expected 3G upload speeds with their Samsung Epic 4G. After extensive investigation, Sprint and Samsung have identified an enhancement that may improve upload speeds on the Epic. This fix will be made available in the next maintenance release. It's important to note that network speeds are impacted by many factors when using commercially-available speed test applications and test results may or may not be true indicator of the actual network performance."
A post today on the Sprint support forums indicates the firmware update should arrive tomorrow and roll out to users over the next several days, so all that's left is waiting for it to be fixed, although we'll still be waiting to see if performance has improved enough to bring the Epic up to par with other phones in terms of web browsing and hotspot speed.

epic4gmarket.jpg

Problem: "Download unsuccessful" when installing apps from the Android Market
Description: Upon activating an existing Gmail account on the phone, trying to initiate app downloads eventually begins to fail, and the user is unable to download any apps at all. This problem does not appear to be exclusive to the Epic, or even the Galaxy S family of phones, but it is prevalent among certain users. We've experienced it on more than one device and account, including two Epics and the Verizon Fascinate. Requests on Google's support forums and elsewhere have not appeared to reveal any concrete reason why this happens or what can be done to fix it.

Workaround: Following the cache clear steps listed below (originally found here) consistently resolved the issue on our Galaxy S devices, however we have had the problem recur later. One permanent fix appears to be to create an entirely new Gmail account on the device, however for various reasons that is hardly a satisfactory solution for all, but being unable to install apps makes the phone practically useless.

Steps:
  • Go to Settings>Applications>Manage Applications
  • Press the Menu button, select Filter, then "All"
  • Go to "CheckIn Service" and select "Clear Data"
  • Go to "Download Manager" and select "Clear Data"
  • Go to "Google Apps" and select "Clear Data" (this may not be an option, if so, skip)
  • Go to Google Talk Service" and select "Clear Data"
  • Go to "Market" and select "Clear cache"
  • Turn the phone off, then back on again
epic4gissues.jpg
Problem: Battery drain
Description: One particular source of battery drain on the Epic appears to be the cell modem on standby. After a fresh boot, when it's on battery it consistently draws power and reports up to 50% of time spent off network, even in areas with good signal coverage. It appears to be searching for signal unnecessarily and drianing the battery while left on standby.

Workaround: Flipping the phone into airplane mode and then back to normal at any point after turning it on clears up the reported time off of network and appears to lower the drain on the battery enabling it ot last longer on standby, but this has to be done every time the phone is turned on.

We've been in contact with Samsung and Sprint regarding these issues but so far have only received direct confiration regarding upload speeds. These aren't the only things to nitpick either, there's a more complete list on the Sprint forums here. The positives we've noted about the Epic 4G in our review are still present but many users look at these, plus a history of unresolved issues with the Moment and worry about the phone's future. We'll let you know what information we get from the carrier and manufacturer about any more fixes on the way, but for now let us know, will you keep holding on or look for bluer skies elsewhere?
 

Fingolfin269

Lifer
Feb 28, 2003
17,948
34
91
Are these problems really so far out of the norm as to require an article on Engadget? It looks like they even mention that they are being worked on by Samsung. Do other manufacturers have a better track record at fixing problems within the first 30 days?

I've never really thought about it but then again I've never noticed an article specifically pointing out a phone, its issues, and that there is 1 day left to change your mind if you bought it on launch.
 

Narmer

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2006
5,292
0
0
Are these problems really so far out of the norm as to require an article on Engadget? It looks like they even mention that they are being worked on by Samsung. Do other manufacturers have a better track record at fixing problems within the first 30 days?

I've never really thought about it but then again I've never noticed an article specifically pointing out a phone, its issues, and that there is 1 day left to change your mind if you bought it on launch.

The Galaxy S series has been out for months. They've had more than enough time to iron out these problems. However, my guess is that Samsung will string customers along until they settle for the mediocrity that is a Samsung phone. Looks good on paper until you use it.
 

Fingolfin269

Lifer
Feb 28, 2003
17,948
34
91
The Galaxy S series has been out for months. They've had more than enough time to iron out these problems. However, my guess is that Samsung will string customers along until they settle for the mediocrity that is a Samsung phone. Looks good on paper until you use it.

Yep I'm just trying to figure out if this is par for the course or if these Galaxy S phones deserve the additional scrutiny they're receiving by engadget posting this story.
 

Narmer

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2006
5,292
0
0
Yep I'm just trying to figure out if this is par for the course or if these Galaxy S phones deserve the additional scrutiny they're receiving by engadget posting this story.
I think the Epic 4G is the best of the best of the Galaxy S phones (in America, at least). Also, this is supposed to be their flagship line (until something else comes along). The only problem is their track record, which is horrendous. I take a wait-n-see approach with products but it is doubly so with Samsung. HTC and Apple are much better when it comes to supporting products after launch.
 

zerocool84

Lifer
Nov 11, 2004
36,041
472
126
Yep I'm just trying to figure out if this is par for the course or if these Galaxy S phones deserve the additional scrutiny they're receiving by engadget posting this story.

Well I have the Samsung Moment, their last Android phone before the Galaxy S phones. It had bad GPS as well but they fixed that MONTHS after release. It still gets data lock-ups every so often and they said they are going to release an update over a year after the phone was released which is later this year. They finally released an update for Airplane mode problems 3 days ago. All I know is that I'm never getting a Samsung phone again. It seems it takes them months and months to fix problems with their phones. The phone came out in November last year and they're barely fixing big problems for it.
 

rudeguy

Lifer
Dec 27, 2001
47,351
14
61
Yep I'm just trying to figure out if this is par for the course or if these Galaxy S phones deserve the additional scrutiny they're receiving by engadget posting this story.

They deserve every word of bad press they get.

How many different carriers have these phones launched on even though there were known issues? How many millions of phones have been sold even though there are known issues?
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
They deserve every word of bad press they get.

How many different carriers have these phones launched on even though there were known issues? How many millions of phones have been sold even though there are known issues?

How much money has Samsung spent to get these phones on national and regional carriers? :p
 

Fingolfin269

Lifer
Feb 28, 2003
17,948
34
91
They deserve every word of bad press they get.

How many different carriers have these phones launched on even though there were known issues? How many millions of phones have been sold even though there are known issues?

I'm not trying to defend them. I'm just wondering if they are getting extra special attention and why that might be.

I've got a Palm Pre. I know shitty phones (from a hardware perspective). I just don't remember Engadget writing a 30-day warning article about it's issues.
 

zerocool84

Lifer
Nov 11, 2004
36,041
472
126
I'm not trying to defend them. I'm just wondering if they are getting extra special attention and why that might be.

I've got a Palm Pre. I know shitty phones (from a hardware perspective). I just don't remember Engadget writing a 30-day warning article about it's issues.

The Pre didn't have multiple basic features not work correctly.
 

MrX8503

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2005
4,529
0
0
Honestly, if I was a Galaxy S owner I would not put up with that crap. I would return the device if I was within the 30days.

I owned an EVO and I was sick and tired of HTC with their issues, namely the 30fps cap, so I ended up returning it.
 

zerocool84

Lifer
Nov 11, 2004
36,041
472
126
Honestly, if I was a Galaxy S owner I would not put up with that crap. I would return the device if I was within the 30days.

I owned an EVO and I was sick and tired of HTC with their issues, namely the 30fps cap, so I ended up returning it.

At least they fixed the 30fps cap.
 

MrX8503

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2005
4,529
0
0
At least they fixed the 30fps cap.

Yeah they did recently, but it was way beyond the 30 days so I had to make a decision to keep it or return it. I think I would be happy with the EVO with its current 30fps fix, but its a little too late.

I followed the EVO quite close and HTC was beating around the bush and not giving the public a clear answer on the fix. So I just said screw it, I'm returning the device.

I think the popularity of the iPhone is where things like this pays off. When the antenna problem surfaced, people were on Apple like white on rice. Apple ended up holding a press conference not too long after and addressed the issue.

By comparison, HTC did not seem as concerned and did not make a public announcement. Months later we finally got a fix. If a company has my money out as a personal loan, they can take back their device.
 

AznAnarchy99

Lifer
Dec 6, 2004
14,695
117
106
Who else here has an Epic 4G besides me?

Ill speak up from my own experience that I have not had any of those problems except for GPS when I first got it. I use GPS everyday to check traffic because I have a long commute and it pinpoints my location in seconds. Used it a couple of times for navigation and it got my location correct everytime.

My 3G speeds itself are low at times but I blame that more on Sprint that Samsung. I also get 4G signal most of the places I go so it hasnt been noticeable for me at all.

Ive never seen that ever when looking at my battery usage. The two main things that drain my battery is the screen and the voice calls.

And Ive never had a download go unsuccessful.
 

Narmer

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2006
5,292
0
0
Who else here has an Epic 4G besides me?

Ill speak up from my own experience that I have not had any of those problems except for GPS when I first got it. I use GPS everyday to check traffic because I have a long commute and it pinpoints my location in seconds. Used it a couple of times for navigation and it got my location correct everytime.

My 3G speeds itself are low at times but I blame that more on Sprint that Samsung. I also get 4G signal most of the places I go so it hasnt been noticeable for me at all.

Ive never seen that ever when looking at my battery usage. The two main things that drain my battery is the screen and the voice calls.

And Ive never had a download go unsuccessful.

There is a Samsung Galaxy S (variants) thread here. Many others have mentioned these problems.
 

AstroManLuca

Lifer
Jun 24, 2004
15,628
5
81
I have one. GPS hasn't been a problem for me but I don't use it for navigating. The most annoying thing has been the upload speed. Actually, 3g speed in general has been awful. I often get under 300kbps download and under 100 upload. And always under 150 upload because of the cap. Only good thing is that I have 4g in a lot of places.

Oh and my wife got an evo a couple days ago. Once the 30 fps cap was removed, it performed well. It was very laggy before. I'm still inside my 30 day return period - wonder if switching to the evo would be worth it. It's less powerful but I know it will get better support after the fact.
 
Last edited:

sswingle

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2000
7,183
45
91
Did they base their ROM from the HTC Eris? It also had issues with GPS and reporting 50% time without signal.
 

AstroManLuca

Lifer
Jun 24, 2004
15,628
5
81
Some news on the Epic. The current most talked about problem is the 3G upload cap. It simply won't let you upload faster than 150 kbps if you're on 3G. Sprint/Samsung announced that they would release a patch that was supposed to go out yesterday. But apparently someone forgot to flip the switch - so far, it still hasn't been pushed out to anyone's devices, and Sprint has even announced that it's been delayed for a day or three because of an "administrative issue" on Google's end. No idea what that means but I totally called it - Sprint and Samsung are always late with everything.

Anyway, it will eventually come out and it's supposed to fix the upload issue. I guess probably sometime next week.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
I returned my Epic. I loved the phone, but the battery drain was pretty bad. Not the worst I've seen (that title belongs to the Palm Pre), but still, not good, and it charged SLOW. I've never had a lithium-based battery that charged so slowly. Not a good combo. But the biggest factor was reception...I just wasn't getting good Sprint reception the places I use my phone most. Even my old T-Mobile phone was better.
 

rudeguy

Lifer
Dec 27, 2001
47,351
14
61
I returned my Epic. I loved the phone, but the battery drain was pretty bad. Not the worst I've seen (that title belongs to the Palm Pre), but still, not good, and it charged SLOW. I've never had a lithium-based battery that charged so slowly. Not a good combo. But the biggest factor was reception...I just wasn't getting good Sprint reception the places I use my phone most. Even my old T-Mobile phone was better.

I'm going to complain in person tonite. Now that you mention it, my battery does charge rediculously slow.
 

AstroManLuca

Lifer
Jun 24, 2004
15,628
5
81
How are you charging it? I've seen vastly different charging times depending on several factors.

It charges much more slowly from a USB port on a computer than it does from the included USB charger.

If you're using a different USB charger than the one it came with, it's possible that it's not charging it as quickly as with the included one.

Lastly, if you're using the phone or especially if you're running a demanding program, it'll charge slowly or not at all. One time I was charging from my computer's USB port and the phone was just heating up but barely charging at all. Found out there was a rogue process - once I killed it the phone cooled down and charged much more quickly.
 

snikt

Member
May 12, 2000
198
0
0
Captivate owner. I must be one of the lucky ones. Haven't had any problems with my Cap since day one. Everything, including GPS, has worked flawlessly for me. Battery charge time is less than 3 hours for me; my old Motorola Z9 took about the same amount of time to charge. Battery drain doesn't seem unreasonable to me, averaging about 36 hours on a full charge with moderate use. 36 hours may seem unbelievable but I've explained why I am getting that many hours in another thread. Never had a failed download. My only complaint is 3G upload speeds, I believe I am averaing between 300-400kbs. From what I've read and understand this is a cap from AT&T, not Samsung. I was impressed enough by this Samsung phone that I recently bought another Samsung, a Rugby II, for when I'm "roughing it" and need a phone that can take a beating and not worry about damaging it.