Returning bikes to their rightful owners is a painful process...

Ricemarine

Lifer
Sep 10, 2004
10,507
0
0
Today I just returned a bike that had been reported missing that I had just bought the day before off Craigslist.

The person originally posted the bike for a price that was very tempting but didn't give that (wow something's totally wrong here). Bikes around here on craigslist that are good deals go very fast. Therefore if you don't attempt to contact the seller within the first 15 minutes, someone else will. Well, I called the person and he stated that if I can meet him in an hour, I can have the bike. So, being a college student that I am, bussed down to meet him. There, he brought the bike saying it was his father's old bike that had passed away with pancreatic cancer. Of course, the bike matters more than the deal so after a bit of riding the person had written up a contract saying he had given me this bike. He also said that he would give me a tuneup at a local bike shop if I come by tomorrow (or today). So, I gave him my $200 and walked off. While I did, I noticed he had a woman and a husky guy walking with him.

Fast forward to today, I bring the bike to the shop he told me to go by (I didn't read the original address he put on there, I used the name as reference) and the shop owner tells me that no one by the name works there. He then goes to tell me that a few bikes have been stolen a week before and has curly brown hair. Crap. %**@. Too good to be true. So, the shop owner contacts a local detective and told me the bike wasn't stolen but the seller is wanted for bike theft. Whew for the bike part, lame for the thief part. The shop owner did then proceed to tell me to go to the local PD and give a statement in hopes of catching the guy.

When I went to the PD, the detective had stated that there has been an upsurge in bike theft lately in the area and he might be a prime suspect. He then ran my bike through the database (they apparently use .txt's to store their bike info...) and found no match. Whew. He then told me to as soon as possible, submit a report of everything I remembered about the transaction.

A few hours after the talk and sending the report, I get a call saying that they had found a missing bike report that was filed the day prior to the transaction and that they're going to have to take my bike back. The original report had matched up to the description of the bike which I never gave to the local PD. ^*#*... My $200... noo... so I called one of my friends to find possible ways of getting my money back. The only thing he could recommend at the time was to get a written proof that I returned the bike.

After my phone call, I get waived over by the same detective I met a few hours earlier. He then introduced me to the original bike owner who seemed very enthusiastic to get the bike back. The detective then made me do a photo lineup to find the guy. Thankfully, it was very easy to ID the person. Apparently he was smart enough to use his real name. He also apparently was selling a few other stolen bikes on craigslist and other websites. Hurray... When asking the owner what kind of lock he used, he stated he used a cable lock... ...wtf. He stated my area seemed very secure so he thought he wouldn't need anything more... ...U-lock + cable ftmw. He did mention that he saw the same ad, which implied that he was the one calling the whole time while the transaction was taking place.

Anyhow, the only way to get my $200 back is to hopefully let the law enforcement do their work, catch the guy, put him on trial, and make him pay restitution. Other than that, my $200 is down the drain. Returning a bike back that you paid for and having to wait that hopefully the bike thief idiot doesn't screw up and get life in prison so that he can pay you back sucks... especially if you're short on cash.

Cliffs:
- Bought bike off craigslist for $200
- Went to bike shop where the seller was supposed to clean the bike, only to learn I bought it from a bike thief
- Went to local PD, gave statement, kept bike.
- Few hours later, PD calls saying the bike belongs to someone and they're going to repossess it.
- They do... and I'm out $200 for however long it takes to apprehend the guy.
- Feel good morally, feel bad for my wallet and the wasted time and effort.

Update:
The police have caught the bike thief and he did confess. However, he only has $0.82, only solidifying my position as a victim and having the $200 tagged on as restitution for his case. The detective is trying all he can to get the charges upgraded to felony status since the thief has been a repeat offender. But, that implies it'll take a lot longer to get my money back (which of course, I'm doubtful). The trial is expected to be in a month or two.
 
Last edited:

deadlyapp

Diamond Member
Apr 25, 2004
6,652
734
126
Unfortunately in a case like this, I'd take the bike and run. I can't afford to lose 200 dollars.
 

Ballatician

Golden Member
Dec 6, 2007
1,985
0
0
yeah you did the right thing, your 200 will find its way back to you and so will the bike of your dreams
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
65,703
14,102
146
yeah you did the right thing, your 200 will find its way back to you and so will the bike of your dreams

WTF are you smoking?

OP, your money is gone forever. I wouldn't bet 10 cents against $100 that you'll ever get paid restitution by the thief.

BUT, if karma is really true...maybe it'll come around in something good for you...maybe.

You definitely did the right thing...even if it did cost you $200 to do it.
 

fantolay

Golden Member
Dec 6, 2009
1,061
0
0
Next time sanded down and spray paint black.
edit: Forget about sanding, spraying over is fine.

Lol.

OP- the guy you bought from must be an idiot. He used his real name and is selling many other bikes in the same area? Must be some dumbass junkie or something.
 

Bignate603

Lifer
Sep 5, 2000
13,897
1
0
Lol.

OP- the guy you bought from must be an idiot. He used his real name and is selling many other bikes in the same area? Must be some dumbass junkie or something.

Yeah, he may be stupid enough to get caught. Hopefully if they do catch him he'll have $200 to take away.
 

Vette73

Lifer
Jul 5, 2000
21,503
9
0
If you have his name and want to be "first in line" fill a small claims action against him.
As long as Small Claims does not cost a lot to fill there.
 

PricklyPete

Lifer
Sep 17, 2002
14,582
162
106
Well done on returning the bike. Sorry that you lost the $200 (and you likely have)...but you did the right thing. People who steal bikes need to be smacked.
 

Gunbuster

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
6,852
23
81
Why don't the police get off their asses and do some work for a change. Troll Craigslist and buy some bikes that look cheap. I'm sure they could did up a couple dollars from speeding ticket taxes. I would love to see the looks on some crooks faces as a PD cruiser rolls up to buy a suspiciously inexpensive bike.
 

Cogman

Lifer
Sep 19, 2000
10,284
138
106
Sucks that you may be out $200. But kudos for not just taking the bike and running.
 

Vette73

Lifer
Jul 5, 2000
21,503
9
0
Why don't the police get off their asses and do some work for a change. Troll Craigslist and buy some bikes that look cheap. I'm sure they could did up a couple dollars from speeding ticket taxes. I would love to see the looks on some crooks faces as a PD cruiser rolls up to buy a suspiciously inexpensive bike.


What? Thats as dumb as Ms Dicks and other idiots saying to keep the bike and run.


In this case when the cops showed up the bike would report clean. It was not till days after it showed up as stolen.
 

Elias824

Golden Member
Mar 13, 2007
1,100
0
76
Well glad you did the right thing, sometimes it doesn't pay to be the good guy.
 

SandEagle

Lifer
Aug 4, 2007
16,809
13
0
let's start a donation to get OP his $200 back for doing the right thing. I pledge one Canadian penny. next?
 

rivan

Diamond Member
Jul 8, 2003
9,677
3
81
Why don't the police get off their asses and do some work for a change.

Well, in this case, it wouldn't have yielded anything if a cop had shown up on the initial buy. The report for the stolen bike wasn't filed before the sale.

Seems to me the cops WERE working on it, since they knew enough to have a photo lineup including the perp within hours of the OP talking to the detective.

I guess thinking it through doesn't fit well with the "see police mentioned in a story" --> "make random statement about cops being lazy, fat, corrupt, stupid, etc" mentality so many people seem to have.
 

Thump553

Lifer
Jun 2, 2000
12,833
2,620
136
Unfortunately in a case like this, I'd take the bike and run. I can't afford to lose 200 dollars.

Possession of stolen property is a crime-and your knowledge (or lack thereof) of the theft is irrelevant.

Congrats on doing the right thing. Losing the $200 (it is almost certainly gone forever) hurts I'm sure, but karma and self respect are a lot more important.
 

Doodoo

Golden Member
Feb 14, 2000
1,423
0
76
You'll probably never see your money again...but props to you for doing the right thing. Hopefully karma works its way to you.