Registry cleaner's usefulness

Leonadavinci

Junior Member
Oct 4, 2009
6
0
0
Hello,

I've read that registry cleaners are snake oil. They don't really boost the performance
of a Windows box ,instead registry cleaners may cause instability problems to your PC.

What's the truth? Does a registry cleaner help your computer?

LD
 

Leonadavinci

Junior Member
Oct 4, 2009
6
0
0
Originally posted by: Nothinman
You read correct, snake oil is the best description I can come up with.

Thanks for the answer Nothinman. What about the registry defragers?
 

Harvey

Administrator<br>Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
35,059
73
91
Originally posted by: Nothinman

You read correct, snake oil is the best description I can come up with.

I beg to differ. I use PC Tools Registry Mechanic, and it has definitely improved the performance of my machines under XP Pro. I've seen far more radical improvenents when I've used it on friends' machines where they have never previously run a registry cleaner.

It creates a restore point so I can always undo any changes it makes, which, to date, I have used ZERO times with ZERO failures.

Playing with your registry CAN be dangerous so you have to trust any such software. I trust Registry Mechanic. :cool:

For XP, I also trust an older version of WinDoctor, the registry cleaner in Norton SystemWorks 2003, which I have kept updated. Newer versions of that and other Norton products have been far too bloated for my taste.
 

DBissett

Senior member
Sep 29, 2000
240
1
81
Ditto for Registry Mechanic. I've run it for years and it works great. The improvements are small since I run it every week or 2, but I remember when I first ran it the results were dramatic. I've also read good things about CCleaner and downloaded it recently. It also appears to do a good job and catches a few things that Registry Mechanic doesn't. It's also free.
 

lxskllr

No Lifer
Nov 30, 2004
60,926
11,257
126
I'd love to see someone provide a benchmark that shows registry cleaners speed up anything. The same goes for 3rd party defraggers....
 

Rottie

Diamond Member
Feb 10, 2002
4,795
2
81
You can try ccleaner it will not hurt your PC...it will not make your computer runs faster but to remove any clutters in the registry. I also use Auslogics Registery Defragmenter and RegCure both are good but they are not free.
Good luck
 

corkyg

Elite Member | Peripherals
Super Moderator
Mar 4, 2000
27,370
240
106
It may not make it run faster, but a good one can get rid of registry crap that starts slowing things down. That can reduce the compulsive need to periodically do a clean install.

I used Norton WinDoctor monthly for years - but hardly ever now. About every 3-4 months I run RegistryBooster 2 by Uniblue. It completely backs up the Registry before making any changes, and saves the last 8 backups.

 

nerp

Diamond Member
Dec 31, 2005
9,867
105
106
Originally posted by: lxskllr
I'd love to see someone provide a benchmark that shows registry cleaners speed up anything. The same goes for 3rd party defraggers....

I'd love to see it too. Especially since the size of the registry really has nothing to do with your computer's overall performance.
 

Leonadavinci

Junior Member
Oct 4, 2009
6
0
0
Originally posted by: nerp
Originally posted by: lxskllr
I'd love to see someone provide a benchmark that shows registry cleaners speed up anything. The same goes for 3rd party defraggers....

I'd love to see it too. Especially since the size of the registry really has nothing to do with your computer's overall performance.

Which is the reason that Windows gradually reduces its performance after months of use in a regular basis?
 

nerp

Diamond Member
Dec 31, 2005
9,867
105
106
Originally posted by: Leonadavinci
Originally posted by: nerp
Originally posted by: lxskllr
I'd love to see someone provide a benchmark that shows registry cleaners speed up anything. The same goes for 3rd party defraggers....

I'd love to see it too. Especially since the size of the registry really has nothing to do with your computer's overall performance.

Which is the reason that Windows gradually reduces its performance after months of use in a regular basis?

That hasn't happened to me since Windows 95/98.
 

DBissett

Senior member
Sep 29, 2000
240
1
81
Do not buy/use RegCure before doing a search on the name and reading the user boards.
 

Nothinman

Elite Member
Sep 14, 2001
30,672
0
0
Which is the reason that Windows gradually reduces its performance after months of use in a regular basis?

Except that doesn't happen. I've got a several years old XP install at work that runs perfectly fine.
 

Deanodarlo

Senior member
Dec 14, 2000
680
0
76
I'd say most of the time cleaning the registry does absolutely nothing speedwise and you can in fact do more harm. Some registry keys they detect may not be in use at the moment, but may be required for a future function. If you do mess with a needed entry, you'll have a nightmare troubleshooting down the line. Computers can access the registry so quickly that removing items or compact it really does nothing you'd notice. It's all placebo. If your computer is working fine, don't touch the registry.

It does have the occasional use however. Some progrmas can leave annoying context menu items, or unwanted behaviour by not uninstalling properly. A registry cleaner can quickly resolve these unwanted entries without having to search manually.

Also, on really old installs (few years old for example), registries can become quite large with deleted entries and unoptimized space. Something like ERUNT might be useful then, to bring it back down to a smaller size, or a registry cleaner, but again if you weren't having any issues I doubt you'll notice a speed difference - perhaps a little less ram being used.

Overall I'd say don't use a cleaner unless your install is really old or has issues connected with the registry. ERUNT and NTREGOPT should be enough in most cases if you want to reduce its size.

 

Modelworks

Lifer
Feb 22, 2007
16,240
7
76
You really cannot compare how the registry effects one pc vs another. It depends too much on other factors like what they each install and what the pc is used for. If you have a lot of bad keys in the registry it can slow down the OS. Particularly if they are things like bad shortcuts, missing program links or video/audio codec keys. The easiest way to avoid any of this is to use something that monitors what a program changes when it installs and uninstalls. I like Revo Uninstaller.
http://www.revouninstaller.com/

It is free and finds most of the garbage that programs leave behind on uninstall.
 

Rottie

Diamond Member
Feb 10, 2002
4,795
2
81
Originally posted by: DBissett
Do not buy/use RegCure before doing a search on the name and reading the user boards.

I am curious why? I never had any problem with RegCure.
 

DBissett

Senior member
Sep 29, 2000
240
1
81
Rottie - I'm glad it works for you. I bought it because the website said it solved a particular problem I was having at the time. Well, it didn't solve the problem and it caused a number of programs not to load. I also ran across many dissatisfied users who had published their opinions at sites like below (I didn't do this research first.) so I scrapped it and have had no problems since.

http://www.complaintsboard.com...html?sort=datea&page=1
 

Rottie

Diamond Member
Feb 10, 2002
4,795
2
81
Originally posted by: DBissett
Rottie - I'm glad it works for you. I bought it because the website said it solved a particular problem I was having at the time. Well, it didn't solve the problem and it caused a number of programs not to load. I also ran across many dissatisfied users who had published their opinions at sites like below (I didn't do this research first.) so I scrapped it and have had no problems since.

http://www.complaintsboard.com...html?sort=datea&page=1

thanks for link it seems have no issues for me after try this out for a week I am going to uninstall it anyway.
 

gevorg

Diamond Member
Nov 3, 2004
5,070
1
0
TuneUp Utilities 2009 did wonders on several machines I cleaned from various crap. Pretty good tool when cleaning an OS install of several years.

I don't use it my machine since I reinstall/reimage Windows at least once a year.