Guys, you are both elite members (RebateMonger and Nothinman), that means at some point you already well-proved your ability to help others as well as your persistent desire to do so.
But that also means you both should know that people's receptiveness to your efforts in assisting them decreases the more your post conveys a tone of talking over them, at them, or even possibly deriding them.
And since I think we can safely assume your motives are noble (the pursuit of helping others) that means I would also think it is safe to assume you want to know this and you want this kind of feedback so as to better enable yourselves to serve those you wish to serve.
You catch more flies with honey than vinegar. The posts by both of you in this thread are distasteful in my eye, waaaay too much vinegar here folks. Sweeten it up a bit, try and not take the stance that the OP is an idiot by default. And try and understand why deriding them after possibly insulting them is not exactly a super great way to help them.
We know your intentions are good, elite membership doesn't come from cracker jack boxes, but your methods are undermining your efforts.
(this type of post would ordinarily be a pm, but the OP deserves some closure in my mind and by making this plea to you both in public I hope it increases the chances of the OP gaining some)