Quiz -- 4 devices, 3 cables

Felecha

Golden Member
Sep 24, 2000
1,434
0
0
I was so confident that the guy who built my box at the local computer shop knew it all, now that's a little shaken.

Athlon 900 TBird, ABIT KT7-RAID, 256, 98se. I got a second hard drive so I could use the RAID, so I now have 2 IBM DeskStar 75GXP 30GB. And I got a CDROM and a Plextor 8/4/32 CDRW. On the board, there are 4 IDE controllers -- 1 & 2 are "regular", 3 & 4 are RAID. When it was built, he put the HD on #1 , with the CDRW as slave. CDROM is on #2. 3 & 4 are open. When I got the 2nd HD, I looked inside and saw the setup and was puzzled. The ABIT manual says they strongly urge not to put a CD-ROM on the same IDE channel as a HD, for performance reasons, depending on the CDROM performance. And I thought that 3 & 4 were the hotshot connectors, so the HD would have gone there. I called him, and he said this was his first RAID motherboard installation, and he hadn't read the whole manual word for word. He thought he had seen 1 & 2 as the RAID connectors, and he completely missed the fine print about not putting a CD with a HD.

I can't complain a lot about the performance the way he set it up. It's so fast compared to what I had (200 Pentium Pro). But now I have this second drive, and one more cable, to make a total of three cables available, and 2 open connectors -- the 3 and 4 RAID connectors. I don't know much about these things, but I think I can do the install myself, having read enough on websites. I can install my own RAM and peripherals, just never installed a HD before.

So the quiz is -- with 4 connectors, 4 devices, and 3 cables, what goes where? I can of course just get a 4th cable and each device would get its own connector and cable, and I expect the HD's would get the RAID connectors and the CD's would get 1 & 2.

The manual says not to connect a HD and CDROM together. Does that apply to a CDRW as well?

For now, would I put the HD's on one cable in one of the RAIDs, as master and slave? I plan to use the 2nd HD for installing a Linux partition, and for massive backup capability. Would backups benefit from individual channels for the HD's? If each HD gets a cable and a channel, that leaves the CD's having to go piggy-back. Somewhere I read that a CDROM and CDRW should not go together, it would make copying really slow.

Anyhow, that's my puzzle and what I've thought of it so far. Any gurus out there?

Thanks a lot

F
 

CygnusX1

Member
Dec 6, 2000
110
0
0
Well I'm not a guru, but I'll give it a go.

The raid controller should be completely separate from the on board IDE controllers. I would put one hard drive on the first raid controller and the second on the other raid controller. Then I would put the CD-RW on the primary IDE and the CD-ROM on the secondary IDE controller, both as primary. In the bios you should be able to specify that you want to boot from the RAID controller. You'll have to get one more cable for this, but the performance should be optimal. You'll want two UDMA 66 cables for the hard drives (with 80 wires) and two regular IDE cables (with 40 wires).

Hope that helps,

Mark.
 

Dulanic

Diamond Member
Oct 27, 2000
9,963
587
136
Each device on its own device is best.... HDs on the RAID cause I think its ATA100... and its never good to put CD-Roms on that type of thing...

Primary IDE=CD-Rom
Secondary IDE=CDRW
Primary RAID/ATA100=HD /w 80pin IDE cable
Secondary RAID/ATA100= Second HD /w 80pin cable.


I have a semi same setup...

Primary IDE=CD-Rom and DVD
Secondary= CDRW
Primary Promise onboard ATA100=Maxtor HD
Secondary Promise=WD HD.