Originally posted by: FFactory0x
Whats easier. Does the analog signal record ok? Look good? Im in the dark with this so any info would be great
Looks about the same on my PVR150 whether I'm going through the onboard tuner or the cable box, so I wouldn't worry much about PQ. You need a cable box to view digital channels or Comcast On Demand, so if either of those is important, you'll need a second cable box (or you'll have to split the video out of the cable box, but then you can only watch one thing at a time).
The splitter and direct hookup to the cable line is easier to set up, because the PVR software can just change channels on the card instead of having to use an external IR blaster. But even that's not too bad as long as your software supports it.
Edit: If you're talking about a hardware standalone PVR (such as a TiVo or ReplayTV box), they usually come with the IR blaster to hook up to a cable box, and setting it up is pretty easy. I had assumed you were building an HTPC originally for some reason...