Putting new engine into a $1200 Chevy Astro worth it?

[zeelandia]

I've been searching around for a new car; new being relative here. I've always thought the Chevy Astro van to be pretty helpful. I finally found a '00 model off of Craigslist for $1200 with an engine that looks to be shot.

1) How much would a new engine cost? Like $1500 maybe?
2) How much would labor cost?
3) Ultimately, you guys think its worth it?

Let's say engine and labor is $3000 total. Thats like having a new car for $4500. Right? Right...?

As always, your opinions are valued no matter how insulting.

 

[wiredspider]

idk, the garage is here http://forums.anandtech.com/forumdisplay.php?f=49

 

[quakefiend420]

no, because the engine isn't the only component of a vehicle...you have the transmission and the rest of the driveline, suspension, electrical, etc etc

 

[RPD]

No and wrong forum

 

[lxskllr]

$1,200 sounds high to me for an 11 year old Astro with a blown motor. It /might/ be worth it if the rest was in good shape, AND you did the work yourself, but not paying someone to do the work for you.

 

[strep3241]

My dad has a 89 Chevy 2500 that recently had a new motor installed. He bought a brand new GM crate engine(350 I think) for $800 from Coyle Chevrolet. He still had to pay for labor(not through Coyle) to install it but don't know how much. I would not think it would be anywhere near $3000.

 

[Fenixgoon]

you have to factor in the cost of the engine *and* the labor. labor is $$$$

 

[mmntech]

Is this it?
http://washingtondc.craigslist.org/nva/pts/2129381964.html

Guy claims the engine is ok. 220,000 miles is a lot though IMO. No telling what else could be wrong. Transmission goes, that's a costly fix.

 

[iGas]

Is this it?
http://washingtondc.craigslist.org/nva/pts/2129381964.html

Guy claims the engine is ok. 220,000 miles is a lot though IMO. No telling what else could be wrong. Transmission goes, that's a costly fix.

Not worth it if it is a service vehicle, because the transmission and suspension can go at anytime due to weight over load and abuse.

 

[Iron Woode]

I've been searching around for a new car; new being relative here. I've always thought the Chevy Astro van to be pretty helpful. I finally found a '00 model off of Craigslist for $1200 with an engine that looks to be shot.

1) How much would a new engine cost? Like $1500 maybe?
2) How much would labor cost?
3) Ultimately, you guys think its worth it?

Let's say engine and labor is $3000 total. Thats like having a new car for $4500. Right? Right...?

As always, your opinions are valued no matter how insulting.

either get a reman'd v6 or buy a SBC swap kit and make a killer van out of it.

:awe:

 

[thomsbrain]

Transmissions are notorious weak points on Astros.

Personally, I don't think the van will be worth $4500 when you're done fixing it. $0.02.

 

[kornphlake]

First off the 4l60e transmission is no more prone to failure than any other transmission in any other mini-van. That transmission is used in several GM vehicles including several heavier vehicles and/or vehicles with much more powerful engines than the 4.3l vortec. I won't say it's perfect, but I wouldn't suspect it to fail any sooner than any other transmission of the same age. Second, plenty of people put V8 engines in Astro vans and report no problems except for a stupid grin that takes weeks to wash off. That said, I'd probably pass on that van unless you've 1) done an engine swap before or 2) you're looking for a project car so you can say you've done an engine swap in the future.

 

[BTRY B 529th FA BN]

wow

 

[Meghan54]

I have to ask.....OP, have you ever driven/lived with an Astro van for any length of time?

If you haven't....they're very stiffly sprung and ride like a concrete block when empty, they're not exactly quiet under any circumstance, the driving position is not the best...esp. foot placement as the wheel well intrudes a LOT into the foot well, they're rather hungry beasts, and did I mention they're not exactly quiet?

As for the mileage, depends upon how it was maintained. While my current vehicle isn't an Astro van (although I owned one for a year), I've got a GM vehicle with the same exact drivetrain with 220K miles on it and have no qualms about hitching up our boat and pulling it for hours.....in fact, it's going to pull the boat to the lake on Friday if the weather forcasts are correct and we hit 70F as predicted.

 

[dawp]

Is this it?
http://washingtondc.craigslist.org/nva/pts/2129381964.html

Guy claims the engine is ok. 220,000 miles is a lot though IMO. No telling what else could be wrong. Transmission goes, that's a costly fix.

if it overheats in 10 minutes, I'd say a bad thermostat, easy test is to just remove it and let it run and if it works fine, that was the problem. It'll cost less tham 20 bucks to replace it.

 

[Vette73]

Cars/Trucks that need major work like that are knows as mechanic specials. If you can't do the work then it is probable not worth it. If it was worth it to replace the motor/trans and then sell they would.

 

[AMCRambler]

Not worth it.

For $4,500 you can get a pretty nice used van. A van with a blown motor has likely been abused which means it can have a lot more problems that aren't readily apparent.

Here are a few near me:

2002 Chevy Astro 125,400mi - $4,500
2003 Chevy Astro 132,423mi - $4,495
2003 Chevy Astro AWD 135,000mi - $3,900

Forget buying one with a blown motor. It's not worth the hassle. Especially an Astro van that's not going to be worth the money you're putting into it.

 

[halik]

Why would you want that vehicle?

 

[SJP0tato]

if it overheats in 10 minutes, I'd say a bad thermostat, easy test is to just remove it and let it run and if it works fine, that was the problem. It'll cost less tham 20 bucks to replace it.

This is true, that or the water pump are likely culprits. The trouble is most people who'd sell a vehicle for overheating have probably already driven hundreds/thousands of miles on it in an overheated condition blowing headgaskets, warping heads/decks, and just generally destroying the engine. It's possible to get lucky and find one that just needs a few parts and some TLC, but it's equally as likely to find one that's 100% trashed and not worth salvaging.

 

[kornphlake]

$1200 is pretty cheap for a lockable outdoor storage container, I don't think there are permitting requirements like there would be with a shed or other temporary building. For a van with that many miles and of that age I don't think it's worth the price.

 

[GuitarDaddy]

No Wai!

 

[MovingTarget]

Astro Vans are pretty useful/durable vehicles. However, considering how common they were I'd find one in better condition unless you know how to replace that engine yourself.

 

[exar333]

If you can do the work yourself (or know someone who can do it for you), replacing the engine would make sense. For this car, you would probably do better with just getting a new one.