Pros/Cons: Buy a Condo Vs. Rent 3 bedroom apt. with 2 other friends

Night201

Diamond Member
Apr 23, 2001
3,697
0
76
I have 2 possible friends I might get a place with in the fall. It would either be a 3 bedroom apartment or buy a condo. What are some pros/cons? Anyone have first hand experience?
 

codeyf

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
11,854
3
81
Buy a condo.

Investment > Throwing your money away

The only downside to a condo/townhome is the typical dues you pay monthly/quarterly/whatever. Depending on the complex, they can be pretty high. Sometimes, it does cover some utilities which is good. I actually own a home, but it's in a planned neighborhood, and we pay just over $200 a year. Gets us access to the pool and some other benefits. Condo and townhome communities can easily cost that much per month, but typically include garbage/water/sewer utilities. In most cases, seperate bills for those services will be more than $200, but it's something you will need to research.

What it comes down to is, you won't see any sort of return on your money when renting. So if you can afford buying, it's the way to go. Especially with what rates are at.
 

crystal

Platinum Member
Nov 5, 1999
2,424
0
76
I see renting with friends are ok, but buy a condo together? I will have to think over again.
 

Hoober

Diamond Member
Feb 9, 2001
4,391
39
91
Originally posted by: Night201
I have 2 possible friends I might get a place with in the fall. It would either be a 3 bedroom apartment or buy a condo. What are some pros/cons? Anyone have first hand experience?

Are you going to be moving in the next five years? If so, I'd consider renting over buying. It will take you a number of years to start to turn a profit on your investment.
 

geno

Lifer
Dec 26, 1999
25,074
4
0
Don't forget to factor condo fees into your equation if you plan on going the condo route. My mom just bought the condo we used to live in, and it's not too cheap.
 

Luden

Platinum Member
Jul 15, 2001
2,269
0
0
Look at your investments.

Buying a condo: paying $xxxxx.xx upfront, along with all the bills every month. When your done with it you could sell it..

Renting: $xxxx.xx a month, plus some bills (water and garbage are usually included). money inthe hole..

How many years do you plan to stay there/with these friends? If its more then a few years buying may be more affordable but there is also alot more work involved..

figure out how much you would be spending renting vs. owning and that would be my deciding factor.
 

Karsten

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,192
0
0
Actually...

If you buy and have friends living with you you make an instant profit. Think about it....

Condo = 750$ Mortgage
Dues = 150$ (Covers Garbage , Sewer, Water)
Insurance = 50$
-----------------------
950$

You buy it and rent it to your friends at 350-400$ a month (in most places more then fair and cheaper then anything else). Throw in Internet access via Cable or DSL to every one for free. Now... it is a win win situation.

- You have your buddies paying into an investment of yours
- They live cheaper then anywhere else
- You have a mucho Tax deduction on top of it
- Depending where you are... in 3-5 years when you sell it you should make a profit on top of all of the above.

Now... DO NOT BUY AS A CO-OP. One person should buy! Things change... people learn to love and hate each other. You never know! In general it is not a good idea to bind your credit worthiness to someone else without a marriage certificate (sometimes not even then ;) )
 

codeyf

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
11,854
3
81
Originally posted by: Karsten
Actually...

If you buy and have friends living with you you make an instant profit. Think about it....

Condo = 750$ Mortgage
Dues = 150$ (Covers Garbage , Sewer, Water)
Insurance = 50$
-----------------------
950$

You buy it and rent it to your friends at 350-400$ a month (in most places more then fair and cheaper then anything else). Throw in Internet access via Cable or DSL to every one for free. Now... it is a win win situation.

- You have your buddies paying into an investment of yours
- They live cheaper then anywhere else
- You have a mucho Tax deduction on top of it
- Depending where you are... in 3-5 years when you sell it you should make a profit on top of all of the above.

Now... DO NOT BUY AS A CO-OP. One person should buy! Things change... people learn to love and hate each other. You never know! In general it is not a good idea to bind your credit worthiness to someone else without a marriage certificate (sometimes not even then ;) )

Wise words!!!! And VERY good points. Rent the rooms to your friends....now you're the land lord!!! :D:D:D
 

Karsten

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,192
0
0
Oh... and of course adjust prices for rent and purchases according to the area where you are. Crunch some numbers... either way... if you pay 100$ more a month for owning your own place it is worth it!

And don't forget that there is finacing available with little to no downpayment!
 

Evadman

Administrator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Feb 18, 2001
30,990
5
81
Originally posted by: Karsten
Actually...

If you buy and have friends living with you you make an instant profit. Think about it....

Condo = 750$ Mortgage
Dues = 150$ (Covers Garbage , Sewer, Water)
Insurance = 50$
-----------------------
950$

You buy it and rent it to your friends at 350-400$ a month (in most places more then fair and cheaper then anything else). Throw in Internet access via Cable or DSL to every one for free. Now... it is a win win situation.

- You have your buddies paying into an investment of yours
- They live cheaper then anywhere else
- You have a mucho Tax deduction on top of it
- Depending where you are... in 3-5 years when you sell it you should make a profit on top of all of the above.

Now... DO NOT BUY AS A CO-OP. One person should buy! Things change... people learn to love and hate each other. You never know! In general it is not a good idea to bind your credit worthiness to someone else without a marriage certificate (sometimes not even then ;) )


This is EXTREAMLY good advice.
 

CrazyDe1

Diamond Member
Dec 18, 2001
3,089
0
0
Originally posted by: DeafeningSilence
Buy the condo, and rent it out to your friends!

That's what I plan to do very soon...

Exactly...then it's like you're still livin w/ your friends and you're still gettin a place...and you're also having htem pay for your place:) Same price as renting only you're getitn somethin out of it
 

desy

Diamond Member
Jan 13, 2000
5,446
214
106
Yep Karston has the best advice the only Con is, you might be freinds now but living with somebody can change that I've known lots of guys best freinds
before lving together , hate each other after.
Also when you become the owner you have to put up with the washing machine dying etc.
Renting means your level of responsibility is nil pretty much.
So do you want to become a property owner? Its the best financially but reliable roomates who pay their bills is key!
I bought a house and have rented out the rooms to aquaintances not freinds , some of the 'freinds' and I that have lived together as renters
haven't got along so well as roomates.
 

Maetryx

Diamond Member
Jan 18, 2001
4,849
1
81
Another vote to buy and rent out the bedrooms to your friends (or grad students or whatever). The tax situation maybe be very favorable, but you should check with a tax preparer. I rent a house out, but I don't live in it myself like you would be. I don't know what kind of wrinkle is created by living in your investment property.

Still though, you can write off the interest on the mortgage no matter what.