Problems with optical drives, coincidence?

mikeymikec

Lifer
May 19, 2011
21,108
16,318
136
My PC spec here: http://www.mikeymike.org.uk/mikes/mypc.txt

The Samsung drive hasn't ever worked 100% for me (yes, it has the latest firmware). Initially it wouldn't read some of my older DVD-Rs, even though other drives could without any problems (Nero CDspeed showing no errors on the discs).

More recently however it has acquired the bizarre habit of becoming non-responsive immediately after attempting to play a DVD Video disc in any program (I normally use VLC but I've tried others). It becomes so badly non-responsive that the system can't talk to the drive properly any more (I've tried everything in software I can think of to attempt to reset it), and so the computer just sits there during shutdown (it doesn't hang, the animation continues, but I've tried leaving it for more than 5 minutes). If I just do a restart (ie. use the reset button), Windows again sits on the loading screen for ages. Apparently only switching the system off and on again gets the drive to talk again.

Otherwise that drive works fine.

The LiteON has more recently (than the Samsung's DVD playback issue) decided that it won't read any DVD discs at all, but will read CDs. It doesn't act up in the same way as the Samsung thankfully, but putting in a DVD disc results in a very short seek and then nothing. The system claims no disc has been inserted. I've tried using a CD lens cleaner but it didn't make any difference.

I don't really need two drives, an odd set of circumstances resulted in the second drive's installation. I also have an old USB DVDRW drive that doesn't have any problems reading any type of disc, which is my current fallback option.

I plan to simply replace two drives with the model of Pioneer drive that I've been recently using for customers' computer builds, unless anyone has any clever ideas for fixing these problems.

I don't have any software installed that does clever things with optical drives, and Windows doesn't have any UpperFilters/LowerFilters registry settings for optical drives. Removing the drives from Device Manager and redetecting them works but doesn't fix any problems.
 

Mushkins

Golden Member
Feb 11, 2013
1,631
0
0
Can you test them in another system? If not, i'd boot from a livecd of any OS at all and see if they behave normally.

If they're still acting up in different hardware or a different OS, honestly, DVD drives are $15 a piece for a reason. I dont think i've had a single build in the past ten years where the drive held up its reliability past the first year or so. The real question is whether or not the time and effort spent troubleshooting some old crappy dvd drives is worth trying to save $15 from buying a new one if you *really* need it.

Sometimes the answer is just to chuck it and move on :)