Portable music player recommendations

bononos

Diamond Member
Aug 21, 2011
3,938
190
106
Whats a decent step up from the nano for use with good headphones? I'm planning to get something in the range of the Senn 598.

At what point would I benefit from something like an Fiio/Iriver? An ATH-M30? M50? Senn 700? Or should I just get a portable amp with cheaper mp3 players if I'm not using anything but the top of top end of headphones.
 

smitbret

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2006
3,382
17
81
Depending on your needs, I would spend less on the player and more on the headphones. At the inexpensive end, get something from the Sansa Clip family. The sound is on par with the best players out there and even the biggest capacity won't run more than $50. They are strictly music players. The screens are strictly for rough album art and text. The Fuze family has better screens but the controls are almost unbearably bad and I couldn't recommend one to anyone.

The Cowan players sound great, or at least they did a year or two ago when I was last shopping for a player.

Sony's aren't bad but I hate Sony.
 

bononos

Diamond Member
Aug 21, 2011
3,938
190
106
Depending on your needs, I would spend less on the player and more on the headphones. At the inexpensive end, get something from the Sansa Clip family. The sound is on par with the best players out there and even the biggest capacity won't run more than $50. They are strictly music players. The screens are strictly for rough album art and text. The Fuze family has better screens but the controls are almost unbearably bad and I couldn't recommend one to anyone.

The Cowan players sound great, or at least they did a year or two ago when I was last shopping for a player.

Sony's aren't bad but I hate Sony.

Is there a significant difference with the Sansa clip+/Cowan vs the Fiio X3 to justify the price difference? I know its a basic question.
 

MongGrel

Lifer
Dec 3, 2013
38,466
3,067
121
The X5 is almost the same as the X3 less they've dropped, I have no clue.

Sound wise I do not know personally, it is digital and you'd have to look at reviews and specs maybe I guess.

I use a Sansa Fuze+ 8 Gb myself daily even if the interface can be a PITA.
 

smitbret

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2006
3,382
17
81
Is there a significant difference with the Sansa clip+/Cowan vs the Fiio X3 to justify the price difference? I know its a basic question.

I don't have any experience with the Fiio lineup. If you are ready to make that kind of investment, you may wanna look at these, too:

http://hifiman.com/

Where it's all digital I still think you are better off putting the money into a better set of earphones. I don't know of anyone that has ever complained after spending $30 on the Clip.
 

bononos

Diamond Member
Aug 21, 2011
3,938
190
106
I don't have any experience with the Fiio lineup. If you are ready to make that kind of investment, you may wanna look at these, too:

http://hifiman.com/

Where it's all digital I still think you are better off putting the money into a better set of earphones. I don't know of anyone that has ever complained after spending $30 on the Clip.

So is it reasonable to use the sansa clip or cowon (maybe with a portable amp) together with headphones like the Senn 558/598 like I said in the OP? Thats all I'm asking.
 

smitbret

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2006
3,382
17
81
So is it reasonable to use the sansa clip or cowon (maybe with a portable amp) together with headphones like the Senn 558/598 like I said in the OP? Thats all I'm asking.

I don't think you'll be disappointed.

;)
 

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
26,067
24,396
136
for on the go just get a pair of sennheiser momentums powered by anything. they were all on sale recently on amazon for like $130, every color but blue which was $199. now some went up but some are still low. they were considered totally worth it at full msrp of $349, at that price they are a steal. closed cans so you don't bother anybody else with your nice pair of open backed senns.

then get the HD 600 for home use and save up for an amp for that for non-portable use. that's my setup.
 

bononos

Diamond Member
Aug 21, 2011
3,938
190
106
I don't think you'll be disappointed.

;)

Lemme get this straight. A discrete soundcard or external dac is usually recommended (over integrated audio) for listening music on the desktop, but a smartphone(post #3) or a sansa happens to be alright for a good headphones?
 

smitbret

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2006
3,382
17
81
Lemme get this straight. A discrete soundcard or external dac is usually recommended (over integrated audio) for listening music on the desktop, but a smartphone(post #3) or a sansa happens to be alright for a good headphones?

OK, I have no idea where you are coming from and it would appear that most of the rest of us don't know, either.

Only your ears know the difference.

So, I think it is appropriate to calibrate my own listening ideology so you can relate to my tastes or discard my recommendations. It does you no good if you have the impression that I am an audiophile and then end up being disappointed by my recommendations.

So, here's my personal listening profile:

Good speakers or good head/earphones are where your money should be spent. There is very little difference between the players themselves. The source is digital so any differences in the sound is due to the player itself modifying and changing the source.

I think anyone that uses a discrete soundcard over intergrated audio is wasting money unless there is a specific feature the soundcard provides. There is literally no difference and blind tests done over and over and over and over prove this time and again. If you are listening at a PC, you would be better off investing in putting sound absorbing materials on your walls and creating an acoustically noiseless, listening environment.

A DAC does not improve audio quality, it changes it. It might change it so that you or another listener might like the tone or feel a little better, but the simple act of converting it from digital to analogue actually lowers the sound quality. Obviously, I am not a DAC fan, either. Analogue playback introduces analogue distortions. The "feel" is the opposite of accurate playback. The hiss of a record is not a quality I want and I can replicate and add it to my audio tracks with a digital filter if it matters that much.

Some people think they can hear a difference if they invest thousands of $$$, I don't. Can I tell the difference between a CD Rip to lossless FLAC and an .mp3 download from Amazon? Sure, but once you hit 320kbps on that .mp3 I would have to be told to listen for the difference to know that it exists. I don't believe there is 1 bit of difference provided by spending $1000 in a power cord for my home audio system and a I don't believe the sound reproduction in my head is improved when I stick pennies between my teeth when I listen. I generally listen to my .mp3 at the gym or working in the yard. My go to earbuds are JVC and RCA wraparounds that won't fall off my head. They are both about $20 at Target and I can tell which pair I am wearing because they do sound different. I have some Sennheiser headphones that I pull out every couple of months when I want to do some "serious" listening. They sound great but I regret spending the money because the difference just isn't big enough to justify the expense over a $40 pair of Sony headphones.

I hope this helps you get where I am coming from. You sound like someone that is willing to invest a little money to get the best quality within your budget and I think that's good. I literally cannot listen to more than about 15 seconds from someone's iPod and the stock earbuds. I would rather hum the tune in my head. My impression is that you are similar.

If you think we have similar listening styles:

Sansa Clip Zip + Senn 598 will make you happy. Optionally, it would be worth the extra $30-$50 to grab a Fiio amp.