portable cd discman/mp3 player or just a smaller mp3 player only?

[holden j caufield]

so which would you go for? My regular cd discman just went out on me and though I would like the discman combo and smaller pure mp3 player I'm sure has it's merits. So what would you get?

 

[erub]

heh, I just made a simliar thread: Link

 

[holden j caufield]

hehe I know I'll get some flak for not reading 10 lines down so no one needs to tell me now.