POLL: Would you be upset if you got fired?

rudeguy

Lifer
Dec 27, 2001
47,351
14
61
A relative of mine was just recently fired. He had been with the company for over 20 years, but due to a sales slump he was downsized. I felt bad for him until I head what he got in return: 6 months salary in one lump sum, 1 year unemployment pay, the balance of his vacation/sick pay, plus all of his 401k. This means that he got nearly a quarter million dollars.

So my question is, if your company fired you, and gave you a similar package, would you be upset?
 

Shockwave

Banned
Sep 16, 2000
9,059
0
0
I'd miss the money. But not the job. You need that as an option in the poll, cause that makes it a yes/ne.
Yes, upset I lost the pay.
No, not upset I didnt have to go back to the office.

Even WITH that package, cause I'm 25. So that package wouldnt last me for the rest of my life.
 

damiano

Platinum Member
May 29, 2002
2,322
1
0
i would be upset if i got fired
but for 250 K iguess it would pass the pain
 

Goosemaster

Lifer
Apr 10, 2001
48,775
3
81
I got fired last week.

I am not the greatest employee. Basically, I am usually about 15min late, and I have this problem with calling in. I MUST work on that.
I really need to work on this.


THis term is teaching me that I am a FANTASTIC student, but my working skills as an employeeeneed work.
 

Lovepig

Senior member
Nov 27, 2000
279
0
0
That's how it goes in sales. They make $$$ but they are first to go in bad times.

6 months salary is no big deal. He would have had that in a few months anyway...
1 year unemployment pay is like 1/2 what he was making, and dosen't really last a year anyway - unless he is still unemployed for the full year - in which case that won't be much of a condolence. Especially in the 13th month when even his 1/2 pay unelmployment stops.
They HAVE to (by law) give you unused vacation time... A unused sick time probably isn't too much anyway. And again, he would have HAD these anyway. You make it sound like he GOT something!
Uh, the 401k IS his. Money comes out of his check each pay-period. If they kept that they would be firing him AND robbing him. They can't keep it (unless he worked for Enron...) And if he uses the 401 $ he pays big big BIG penalties anyway!!

So, bottom line is he is getting nothing he wouldn't have recieved anyway. The only benefit is that he dosen't have to work in exchange for 6 months of pay. NICE!! - but probably not worth the trade-off of not being able to work for pay after 6 months.

Additionally, we don't know what else he lost. Could be a big pension plan lost after 20 years of service, and medical benefits, plus any sales perks co. car? co. plastic? Then we need to address the intangibles like friends, sense of accomplishment, and the plain self-esteem hit for being fired. (sales folks are NEVER fired if they are performing enough! That is what brings i the co. $$$)

Then we need to address his personal situation. If he's been there 20 years he may have trouble getting another job - either for age or other adjustments.

Summary: I think you have analyzed the situation poorly and innacurately. Don't be too hasty to think it is a good thing... (unless he was planning to quit soon anyway!)
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
If I got that and was a bit older (like 40), I wouldn't be too upset...
 

rudeguy

Lifer
Dec 27, 2001
47,351
14
61
Originally posted by: Lovepig
That's how it goes in sales. They make $$$ but they are first to go in bad times.

6 months salary is no big deal. He would have had that in a few months anyway...
1 year unemployment pay is like 1/2 what he was making, and dosen't really last a year anyway - unless he is still unemployed for the full year - in which case that won't be much of a condolence. Especially in the 13th month when even his 1/2 pay unelmployment stops.
They HAVE to (by law) give you unused vacation time... A unused sick time probably isn't too much anyway. And again, he would have HAD these anyway. You make it sound like he GOT something!
Uh, the 401k IS his. Money comes out of his check each pay-period. If they kept that they would be firing him AND robbing him. They can't keep it (unless he worked for Enron...) And if he uses the 401 $ he pays big big BIG penalties anyway!!

So, bottom line is he is getting nothing he wouldn't have recieved anyway. The only benefit is that he dosen't have to work in exchange for 6 months of pay. NICE!! - but probably not worth the trade-off of not being able to work for pay after 6 months.

Additionally, we don't know what else he lost. Could be a big pension plan lost after 20 years of service, and medical benefits, plus any sales perks co. car? co. plastic? Then we need to address the intangibles like friends, sense of accomplishment, and the plain self-esteem hit for being fired. (sales folks are NEVER fired if they are performing enough! That is what brings i the co. $$$)

Then we need to address his personal situation. If he's been there 20 years he may have trouble getting another job - either for age or other adjustments.

Summary: I think you have analyzed the situation poorly and innacurately. Don't be too hasty to think it is a good thing... (unless he was planning to quit soon anyway!)

Very thoughtful post, although very misinformed.

1. He was not in sales, he was a designer for the company. Sales positions are usually comission based, so companies can afford to keep them around. If they dont sell, they dont eat.
2. 1 year unemployment is nothing close to half of what he was making. Unemployment is max $350 a week. So it doesnt make up for his income, but it does help.
3. The 401k isnt necessarily always the employee's. With companies matching you have to make it through your vesting period. I know plenty of people who have gotten shafted by their employers on this issue. Most of the time it isnt worth the court battle over the percentage the company is trying to keep. You end up just settling for what you can get.
4. No company car, CC, or expense account here. As far as friends, if they were really friends wouldnt you be able to see them more now that you have free time?

All that being said, losing your job is never completely a good thing. The person we are talking about here is very close to retirement age, and much like myself hates working. He is selling his house and moving out to the country. He is buying his new house and property with the equity from his old house. This means all he has to worry about is taxes and insurance.

All the money I mentioned that he is getting is aside from his savings. So basically he doesnt have to work another day in his life. Doesnt sound too bad to me.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
I work stocking at Walmart. I like the shift, and the people I work with (for the most part), but not the work. I wouldn't really mind getting fired, but I don't see that happening anytime soon, at least not from Walmart's part.

Edit: that's a pretty nice bunch of money he got there.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Not a bad way to get dumped. Better than a little pink slip and having security escort you out and kicking you to the curb with no severance package.

If that had been me, I'd be booking a nice long trip the Caribbean and relax for a bit with my wife. Spend another month playing golf and then start job hunting.

 

Demon-Xanth

Lifer
Feb 15, 2000
20,551
2
81
For 6 months pay+1 year unemployment it wouldn't be too bad. The 401k is your own damned money though!

...as has been said, I'd miss the money, but not the job. My current employer doesn't give a rats arse about the employees. The last one (the guys that previously owned the company before the lay off+rehire move) flat out screwed the employees over.
 

Viper GTS

Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
38,107
433
136
First, that's not fired - That's laid off.

Second, I'll be getting laid off here in the near future. My entire team is being moved to Canada where they can pay someone $8 CDN to do a job they pay me $14 US to do. I can guarantee the quality of support is going to drop, but that's not my problem.

Am I mad? Nope. Actually, I'm kind of glad they've forced my hand. I'm way too complacent here (as most people here are), I make decent money considering the amount of responsibility I actually have. I won't get any kind of severance, I'll get paid the balance of my accumulated PTO, and of course I'll have my 401k when I leave, but other than that I'll have nothing.

I say good riddance, I've been here almost 4.5 years. I'm only 21, that's too damn long at one job.

Viper GTS
 

Aharami

Lifer
Aug 31, 2001
21,205
165
106
im still young (just beginning my career) so if i got fired now, it'd br devastating for my career plans. so yes, i'd be really upset. although all that money would be nice. make some wise investments and have supplemental income for the rest of my life

but finiding anothe job would be tough

btw. i voted yes
 

Gravity

Diamond Member
Mar 21, 2003
5,685
0
0
250k and I'd never work again! I'm not a worker. I'm a hmmm...well, er, um, a slacker!
 

damiano

Platinum Member
May 29, 2002
2,322
1
0
Originally posted by: vi_edit
Not a bad way to get dumped. Better than a little pink slip and having security escort you out and kicking you to the curb with no severance package.

If that had been me, I'd be booking a nice long trip the Caribbean and relax for a bit with my wife. Spend another month playing golf and then start job hunting.

sounds like a good plan
 

lokiju

Lifer
May 29, 2003
18,526
5
0
He didn't get fired, he got laid off, theres a difference, when you get laid off you can collect unemployment and it doesn't look like you were a bad worker to your next employer. If I got fired i'd be pissed but if I got laid off I wouldn't be as upset since it comes with severence money that can hold you over until you find the next job.