well another issue too is added cost. Those high detail super glossy big boxes aren't cheap. Even if you are making a half a million at a shot, each box still probably costs the company at least $1.50-$3 which means an added $5-7 for the consumer. It depends on the box though, some boxes are much fancier then others with gold foil, raised relief, embossing. All that costs alot of money. Ever notice how cheap OEM stuff is that's just a CD? Legitly Downloadable software is also usually cheaper. Sometimes half the retail price (Although thats not totally because of no packaging).
Still, I'd like more OEM-type options available for people who don't want or need all the packaging or even manuals. I'm fine with having PDF manuals included on a CD in some cases. I'd like to see more game companies have options to buy CD Keys as well but I doubt that will ever happen. Since many of my oline games I run one more then one machine at once, I already have the CD's and boxes and manuals, I just need another req Key to go online. I could understand though that game companies don't want people copying or DLing software and buying a CD key for cheap. I'm not asking for super cheap, just like OEM prices. High enough to dissuade a pirater but low enough to make it a deal for someone who already bought their product. It would be nice to go to a store and see boxed games and their CD/DVD case only counterparts for 20%-30% cheaper.
Newegg had OEM battlefield 1942's for like $20 at one point. Of course they sold out within ours... I needed a 2nd copy so I had to pay for a full retail boxed version for $40. They got my money but I almost didnt buy it. There are many games I demo'd and would buy an OEM CD, but it's not worth full retail for me. Thats alot of lost sales from people in the same boat as me. One of my girlfriend's also mistakenly threw out one of my CD sleeve's with SOF2's CD-key on it. I want to replace it but I'm not buying another one at full retail.