Plot hole in Pirates of the Caribbean? (somewhat spoiler)

[Lager]

Geoffry Rush said that they cannot taste or feel anything, since they are dead.

How the hell did Johnny Depp (supposely also a ghost), taste the rum and not standout in the moonshine?

PS

Keira Knighley is fusking HOT x 100.

 

[wedi42]

he didn't become a ghost untill near the end, when he took a coin out of the chest.

 

[kag]

damn lager, you are active tonight. you posted in like half of the threads i read

 

[bleeb]

Jyeah Jyeah... he was kicked out of the Pirate Entourage and left on the island. THEN the Pirates stole the treasure (booty)... explaining why he didn't have the curse upon him. Only when he took the coin did he become apart of the curse.

 

[CarlKillerMiller]

Yeah...they're right.

Good flick.

 

[Zim Hosein]

Originally posted by: lager
Geoffry Rush said that they cannot taste or feel anything, since they are dead.

How the hell did Johnny Depp (supposely also a ghost), taste the rum and not standout in the moonshine?

PS

Keira Knighley is fusking HOT x 100.

Psst...it's a movie

 

[xSauronx]

Originally posted by: Chraticn
Yeah...they're right.

Good flick.

so-so flick
not as bad as i thought it would be, or rather, better than i expected

 

[Lager]

Originally posted by: Zim Hosein

Originally posted by: lager
Geoffry Rush said that they cannot taste or feel anything, since they are dead.

How the hell did Johnny Depp (supposely also a ghost), taste the rum and not standout in the moonshine?

PS

Keira Knighley is fusking HOT x 100.

Psst...it's a movie

I know that.