Well I broke down and just spent about $100 or so on ebay for steam codes and got around half the games I was looking for. I guess I will just have to keep hitting up Goodwill and other thrift stores for cheap older-ish style games and what I cant find I will have to get from ebay or amazon.
No love for lightscribe? I think they still make the discs for people who love obsolete archaic technology, like OP.Or, buy them on gog, buy some blank dvd's and labels and a printer, and print labels for the games and stick them on the dvd's. You can probably even copy the game to the dvd!