Ph II 710 vs c2d e6400: one needs to find a new home

konakona

Diamond Member
May 6, 2004
6,285
1
0
Not sure if this is the right forum to post this, but looks most cpu-relevant to me so here it goes.

I returned from the local fry's store with a i7/P55 combo, ready to replace one of the to boxes at my house. One is a phenom II 710 which failed to unlock, clocks up to about 3.2ghz stable. The other is a e6400@3.4ghz on a P35 board. Between the two, I have a total of 12GB ram (4x2GB and 4X1GB).

Now, there is no way I am going to need a third computer (sorry, I am not a folder) so one of these are gonna have to go. As is, the C2D is being used a secondary rig as it has an inferior vid card on it, I use it for playing music, downloading stuff, storing files and occsassional gaming. As far as I can tell, I won't be doing any encoding, 3d rendering, or anything outside of pure entertainment on either of these machines.

I ended up with two computers simply because how cheap ram and PhII combo was at the beginning of the year, but funny how ram prices shot up and made selling DDR2 a worthwhile trouble. If I were to keep just one of them, say with 4gb of ram (1gb x4), which one shall it be? The only real metric that pertains me in terms of performace is gaming. I am inclined to say the third core of phII is likely to work better in the long run, but I could be wrong.

Another way to look at it is how much cash I am going to be able to muster out of these. I have no experience selling gear on ebay or craiglist, so I was going to try the FS/FT forums here first. The fact we are not allowed to post price inquiry threads makes it a bit harder to judge which one is worth more resale value wise. I was planning on scanning some threads to get a feel for it, but decided to ask you guys first (well I am working on it now :)). PhII looks like a better value for me to keep (less cash to be recouped from selling), but again I could be wrong here.
 
Last edited:

alyarb

Platinum Member
Jan 25, 2009
2,425
0
76
keep the phenom. there are $70 tri-cores that do 3.6+ GHz these days. you could sell your current X3 for $50 if it really isn't fast enough for you, but it should be. either way an AM2/AM3 system is better than 775 going forward...
 
Last edited:

konakona

Diamond Member
May 6, 2004
6,285
1
0
yeah, that's what I was thinking too. C3 550s were tempting, but I bit on that i7 so...
 

BD231

Lifer
Feb 26, 2001
10,568
138
106
Intel dosen't care about gaming. Keep the phenom II, give it more voltage, get the 3.7ghz that thing is capeable of. The AM2/AM3 platform is currently tremendous for gaming.
 

Ben90

Platinum Member
Jun 14, 2009
2,866
3
0
Intel dosen't care about gaming. Keep the phenom II, give it more voltage, get the 3.7ghz that thing is capeable of. The AM2/AM3 platform is currently tremendous for gaming.

Last time I checked a 3.8ghz PII x4 was trading blows with a 2.66ghz 920 with setups where your not vcard bound (AT benches)
 

konakona

Diamond Member
May 6, 2004
6,285
1
0
Intel dosen't care about gaming. Keep the phenom II, give it more voltage, get the 3.7ghz that thing is capeable of. The AM2/AM3 platform is currently tremendous for gaming.

sadly, mine can't handle more than 3.2ghz, even at somewhat precarious +2.125v. temps were still good at that too. not being able to use acc could be part of it, turning acc on attempts to unlock the 4th core, which gives me weird artifacts in games and videos.