Originally posted by: Lola
It is a pet-peeve. Plus, I get annoyed when after they "sniff" it... they look up with a stupid... "ewwww" look on their face. I gues it comes down to rudeness.
why does it have to be rude?
If its not a situation where you are a guest at someone's house or special event, I don't find it rude at all. But, I also despise political correctness, I think its the worst thing and is a major downfall of our society. All it does is slow progress.
Now mind you, I have a lot of manners and respect for individuals, but the concept of sniffing food and being disgusted, to me, is far from disrespectful or rude unless in the settings I briefly described.
As someone else stated, smell is a powerful sense. I sniff unfamiliar food, and even familiar food, all the time to judge whether its even worth my time tasting or eating. My nose has never been wrong. If I don't like the smell, I surely won't like how it tastes. Now sometimes a smell is a little confusing or makes me a little cautious, but if it smells downright bad, no way will I like it. I have tested that even, after others have urged me to ignore my nose.
I don't mind others being disgusted with food that doesn't smell right to them. If its at a buffet or a restaurant or a group outing or just a very casual event, I think its more respectful to display a little disgust, then to taste it and nearly gag or spit it out.
I can understand pet peeves, but I can't understand how it could be viewed as rude.

Unless its your own personal cooking, or the cooking of a relative or friend. But even then, I respect the notion of people have their own personal taste preferences. This is probably because I have such a picky taste, so I'd know where one might come from.
+