How so? I think i explain myself fairly clearly.
you asked for it.
i'm also quite good at games; shooters in particular. i am a strong team player, good at reading the game, and i'm fast and reasonably accurate; i also take the game seriously. these factors together, make me win more often than not.
how did i get like this? by practicing, reading, playing different games, speaking to better players, and developing my mindset.
through these i found several elements that were limiting my possibilities. i learned how to set up my sensitivity; how to reduce the pre-rendered framerates, how to calibrate my monitor, how to edit ini files. i learned about network latency, hitboxes, ping. i learned about reflexes, muscle memory, posture. i learned how to prefire, how to dodge, how to spot.
all these thinsg i have learned together, make up the sum of my skill. just like a professional athlete learns about form, practices, eats properly, sleeps regularly, and so on.
that is all that skill is. there is nothing, if not the above, which gets better when you play.
if you put two players in a new game, with two identical controllers, you are cutting out 90% of whatever skill is. at that point the only two factors which control who wins are 1) boredom and 2) luck.
and that is one point of my argument.
the second is,
a gaming mouse and a gaming keyboard don't do anything for you. at most, they let you do 100% of what you want to do but unless you have some sort of macro or other hack built into them, they do nothing. a mouse is considered "perfect" if it does EXACTLY what your hand does.
and you want to tell me that a control which does NOT do what your hand does, is better?
this is why people OF SKILL who play PC games have such a low opinion of console gamers. because they know nothing of the possibilities OF SKILL which they could have using a superior control, such as a mouse and keyboard; if they did, they would not lower themselves to using a controller, but they do because skill is something they don't care about nor understand.
here is a tip, genius. if you don't want to play vs inferior, controller wielding players, then don't. whining that controller players are bad doesn't absolve you from being a console player yourself. get a pc and go play counterstrike, then tell me about skill.
or keep doing what you do, gimp yourself by using a controller, then tell yourself you are doing the "skillfull" thing by staying in the kiddie pool and playing vs 12yo kids.